Mini Normal 2294: Monkey Business (Endgame)

[Enchant]

VOTE: geraintm

why not

[Kokichi Oma]

Well that's just a silly vote

[Enchant]

yes

[geraintm]

Look forward to hearing thatvreason Nepe

i don't find their play sincere in that their overreactions to being voted read way more as scared mafia "pr" than scared town (vanilla or otherwise) to me so i assume they're some kind of scum one-shot who hasn't been able to use their ability and won't if they're lynched today because otherwise, i don't see anyone who is actually town caring so much to the point they're that thrown each time someone mentions them and doesn't follow it with a tr. i'm not buying it, i think it was gimil who called them "bleeding town" (may have been someone else, i can fact check, don't @ me) which to me reads as a much more sincere (but imo incorrect) read than anything elsa's outed all game.

i find your posts really hard to follow, too many commas.
i don't like the whole "locked in my vote" thing, i don't believe it.


naughty point for you.

[also, the L word is banned on site]

[geraintm]

VOTE: geraintm

why not

because i am a terrible person to eliminate day 1.
i know i am easily solveable as scum (i get really panicky) so this is a waste.

[Gimli]

you know what happens when we sell ourselves cheap in mafia game

we get wagoned
we get eliminated
people betray us
people meme wagon us
people meme hammer us

its not a great thing

your vote is valuable you should like, sell it, instead of giving it to people for NAI reasons

What do you think about voting Elsa?

since enchant decided to post a few townie things I think that'd be okay actually

[Enchant]

VOTE: geraintm

why not

because i am a terrible person to eliminate day 1.
i know i am easily solveable as scum (i get really panicky) so this is a waste.

Who is not terrible person to eliminate day 1, day 1 is literally fucking dodgeball with no flips and evidence

[geraintm]

VOTE: geraintm

why not

because i am a terrible person to eliminate day 1.
i know i am easily solveable as scum (i get really panicky) so this is a waste.

Who is not terrible person to eliminate day 1, day 1 is literally fucking dodgeball with no flips and evidence

someone unreadable. not_mafia i always thought was an excellent person to eliminate day 1.

and nice that you agree with my "Day 1s are awful" idea

[Comus]

I never called elsa bleeding town and I think she can be scum, i just also think she is a horrible d1 kill

What do you think about voting Elsa?

since enchant decided to post a few townie things I think that'd be okay actually

Elsa Jay, what do you think about how Gimli continues to flip-flop on you? He has been doing it from the start. In one breath cautions against you being voted, says even if you are scum we should be voting someone else. In the next breath says you can be scum. Now he's suddenly willing to vote you? Why are you now on the table, just because Enchant has done, well nothing much in fact?

His reasoning is lacklustre. It doesn't exist truthfully. From one page to another he changes his mind on you like a kite swept away by the wind, whirling and twirling every which way without direction.

I don't like this from Gimli. Is it possible he wanted to pocket you but now that the heat's on he's willing to abandon you in the woods? Sink you like a tombstone, as you said. He earlier said Elsa has such sharp reads but only on two people. Now that's all swept under the rug, Gimli has a new crush on Enchant and will vote anywhere suddenly it seems.

Is the Dionysus vote a desperate attempt at being saved? Is this pivot on you a desperate attempt to be saved? Is Gimli indeed a wolf and both Dionsyus and Elsa Jay are mis-executions he's eyeing to push through?

[Gimli]

defends elsa: i dont like this from gimli
pushes elsa: i dont like this from gimli

maybe you just dont like gimli

[Gimli]

gera is a townie so killing him would be bad

i like enchant's posting as of late. I understand he had nothing to say about the game because its... closed? so there wasn't any mech for him to do his thing etc

I don't think he is a good enough scum to make that 'if gimli was scum then id be flipping instead of him' type of comment

[Comus]

defends elsa: i dont like this from gimli
pushes elsa: i dont like this from gimli

maybe you just dont like gimli

I've discussed this behavior from you in my earlier posts. Before you were willing to vote Elsa. You clearly are not discussing anything anymore beyond throwing one-liner reads out there, you use terms such as village idiot to describe me instead of tackling what I say, so I'll wait for Elsa to answer. I did ask Elsa after all.

Talk to me when you're serious.

[Gimli]

sorry I was drunk when I made the VI comment, I didn't mean to be insulting

[Gimli]

my thoughts on elsa are pretty clear: I think her emotions are genuine or, if they're not, they feel close enough to the real thing that I have a hard time not townreading that. I think her reaction especifically to your early tunnel was good. she made a few comments that are good - maybe too good - and I'm tentatively townreading those while simultaneously thinking they could be TMI. her position wrt both koki and kawaii are almost like she knows they're town. since I never played with elsa before, IDK what that means. maybe she is very good townie who can grasp the right things to townread people for, and I don't wanna punish that. maybe she is a wolf and TMI spews people as town when she is a wolf.

I agree with kawaii that there's an aspect of her play that just feels informed and makes her a decent kill. that's a read that I'm developing throughout d1 and it's clear from my posting. as I told you before: you just don't wanna read me.

[Comus]

sorry I was drunk when I made the VI comment, I didn't mean to be insulting

Don't worry about the insult, these things are normal. I am at times completely idiotic so such statements are warranted. What I wonder about is whether such frustration comes from a villager mindset. Well, I'm waiting for Elsa's answer, and anyone else who wants to weigh in.

[Comus]

I think her reaction especifically to your early tunnel was good.

To be clear, and I see Kawaii also repeating this as much as possible, there was no early tunnel. There was me saying a thing, and then Elsa jumping onto my back for it. From there, from her pre-emptive strike vote, I started focusing on her and geraintm because they were acting strangely. I notice when people twist narratives like these.

I'll return to this later and actually try and read the rest of your posts, I would rather post when not in blah blah blah and blind mode. But more than this I would like to hear from Elsa Jay.

[Kokichi Oma]

I think we just vote Elsa or Ausuka

[Kokichi Oma]

Ausuka is probably not getting voted out today which is sad, but Elsa has a good chance so I think go there

[geraintm]

Ausuka is probably not getting voted out today which is sad, but Elsa has a good chance so I think go there

its sad that we still have 2 players away from keyboard, no way we can go to night just in case either has a role which we need them to use tonight

[Kokichi Oma]

Ausuka is probably not getting voted out today which is sad, but Elsa has a good chance so I think go there

its sad that we still have 2 players away from keyboard, no way we can go to night just in case either has a role which we need them to use tonight

Sure we can. We just do it

[geraintm]

Ausuka is probably not getting voted out today which is sad, but Elsa has a good chance so I think go there

its sad that we still have 2 players away from keyboard, no way we can go to night just in case either has a role which we need them to use tonight

Sure we can. We just do it

Ok, we could do it but it would be 100% irresponsible. Day 1 don't matter, but night 1 does and we can't afford to miss any night actions

[Kokichi Oma]

Ok, we could do it but it would be 100% irresponsible. Day 1 don't matter, but night 1 does and we can't afford to miss any night actions

Why do you assume they are town and can't be scum?
Interesting..

[KawaiiKame]

I think her reaction especifically to your early tunnel was good.

To be clear, and I see Kawaii also repeating this as much as possible, there was no early tunnel.

Feels like you pursuing Elsa, Idk if I said you tunneling Elsa

[Gimli]

lmao at it being irresponsible

everygame there's scum between the lurkers and everygame the lurkers are >rand scum while the people tryharding are >rand town, by postcount alone that's pretty much always the case

killing people who aren't playing the game they signed up for is a great way to keep a healthy gamethread

I don't think flipping enchant today works and I can see the justification in flipping elsa, but salsa/dio/nono probably contains scum

[Elsa Jay]

Page bottom so my next post isn't here.