you're new here, and i've been sort of nice so far but I have a limit.In post 173, Rogue wrote: What do you townread from Black on pages one and two?
it's this post, to be clear.In post 24, Black wrote:I like this a lotIn post 21, Rogue wrote: Also known as Rogue. I’m the pretty one not to be confused with Gambit who’s the handsome devil.
"you're new here" is just a euphemism for never having played with me before, chilllllIn post 176, Rogue wrote: Yeah sorry only been on the site 10 years my b
She's lying. She'll explain her town reads, in great detail, any time it suits her. It's mostly because the town read is weak and for nebulous reasons, and if she gives details then scum-black can play into them. So basically if the read is weak, there's no good motive to give any details because if you're wrong all it does is encourage scum to play into a confirmation bias (and if the logic becomes accepted it becomes a blind spot that can last until endgame).In post 175, Lady Lambdadelta wrote:you're new here, and i've been sort of nice so far but I have a limit.In post 173, Rogue wrote: What do you townread from Black on pages one and two?
I do not generally explain townreads. The answer you get this time is GUT >=D!
The more detailed answer is I saw something within their play that indicated they are town within those first like, 5 posts, mostly an exchange with you.
What that is, I'm not explaining.
But also she's scum soooooooIn post 155, Lady Lambdadelta wrote: Nah, more like "my girlfriend feels bad that I'm hyper shoving her on page 5 of a mafia game I invited her to and I don't want to be the reason she quits mafia right after she rejoins mafia".
sadfyjkldfkaslIn post 186, GreyICE wrote:She's lying. She'll explain her town reads, in great detail, any time it suits her. It's mostly because the town read is weak and for nebulous reasons, and if she gives details then scum-black can play into them. So basically if the read is weak, there's no good motive to give any details because if you're wrong all it does is encourage scum to play into a confirmation bias (and if the logic becomes accepted it becomes a blind spot that can last until endgame).In post 175, Lady Lambdadelta wrote:you're new here, and i've been sort of nice so far but I have a limit.In post 173, Rogue wrote: What do you townread from Black on pages one and two?
I do not generally explain townreads. The answer you get this time is GUT >=D!
The more detailed answer is I saw something within their play that indicated they are town within those first like, 5 posts, mostly an exchange with you.
What that is, I'm not explaining.
Besides, we're only eliminating one person today. That means no matter what, there's twelve people we're not eliminating, and any good townie would tell you that's eleven living people too many. So discussing the elimination is far more productive.
So, moving past the theory discussion Rogue, you tossed down your vote on post 21. That's fine, it's a good vote for post 21. But here's the thing, unless something has changed, I have to assume that your reason is the same as it was in post 21. So has anything progressed for you? Because I can be sold on wagons, but unless you've got the mother of all Stoofer tells I'm not doing it off a post 21 read.
OH BOYIn post 189, GreyICE wrote: The nice part is that if Hebi is scum we actually have a way to read LLD for once.
In that LLD wouldn't start out this game by throwing Hebi under a bus based on those awkward first few pages, she'd see if it could slide and opportunistically bus around 3-4 days in when Hebi had some time to get used to the new reality. I'd say that's actually a v. strong read.
So if Hebi is scum, LLD is town.
Look love, I signed your face up to be a bullet catcher
yeah but i don't want sad snek =(In post 187, GreyICE wrote:But also she's scum soooooooIn post 155, Lady Lambdadelta wrote: Nah, more like "my girlfriend feels bad that I'm hyper shoving her on page 5 of a mafia game I invited her to and I don't want to be the reason she quits mafia right after she rejoins mafia".
Hmmm, well we must all keep our townreads close to our chest it appears. Presumably so when we beat our chest we hit them first.In post 188, Rogue wrote: Our post in 21 was an RSV post.
However, there’s a reason why we haven’t moved our vote because we really haven’t found someone who we are solidly scum reading to the point to move it to a serious vote.
I have at least two players I’m townreading, but I’m keeping them close to my chest right now.
Right now for the most part everyone’s in a null pile and currently being sorted.
~R
oh you mother fuckerIn post 195, GreyICE wrote: Oh and apropos of nothing, I've realized I'm probably a miller. I will not be answering questions on this subject.
AhahahahahIn post 197, Lady Lambdadelta wrote: you did it didn't you
you picked Archer's Dog that pissed on the tree didn't you