Newbie 2116 - Booza (Game Over)

[GuyInFreezer]

VC 3.00

Not Voting (5):

Arko, skitter30, Black, Deltabreedy, Cat Scratch Fever

With

5

remaining,

3

to eliminate

Deadline

(expired on 2023-03-29 12:35:36)

[skitter30]

Soooooooooo abt that mallow scumflip ...
I think at this point the other pr should claim (presumably fn?)

[skitter30]

Black tbh i'm signicantly more sus of you now than yesterday

P sure csf is scum
Delta's day2 was p awful too

Arko i think is just distracted by irl things and is town

[Cat Scratch Fever]

I still think it's skitter and black

[Black]

@skitter, that's understandable. I tunneled on mallow and you being a scum pair and I was wrong

We agree on CSF at least. I think she's the most likely wolf here

I admit I'm less sus of you skitter after Mallow's flip but I also don't think it's Delta here. In fact I think Arko had a much worse D2 than Delta

I think CSF/Arko is the most likely pair here with CSF/skitter and Arko/skitter as the only other possible options to me

I want to dive into these possibilities more when I get the chance later. One wrong vote and we just lose so I think we should take our time

[skitter30]

I still think it's skitter and black

B/c ...?
Wdym by 'still', this wasnt your solve yesterday

Why do you even think i'm scum here

[skitter30]

Nobody shouod be voting now

[skitter30]

Black, why don't you think it's delta

[Black]

I think Delta is the towniest person left and if I remove him from the picture then the scum pool becomes much more clear

There are two wolves in {CSF; skitter; Arko} and we just have to make sure we don't lim the wrong one and we win

Since mallow flipped town I'm pretty confident we win by limming CSF and Arko but I need to reread the thread to make sure we don't fumble this

[Deltabreedy]

Can you summarise for me why you think it's Arko over Skitter?

[Deltabreedy]

Also I'm pretty confident Skitter is scum - the reaction to the flip in #1251 is purely to bait out a 2nd PR.

[skitter30]

I think Delta is the towniest person left and if I remove him from the picture then the scum pool becomes much more clear

There are two wolves in {CSF; skitter; Arko} and we just have to make sure we don't lim the wrong one and we win

Since mallow flipped town I'm pretty confident we win by limming CSF and Arko but I need to reread the thread to make sure we don't fumble this

Why is delta the towniest person? I don't think they're nearly townie enuf to justify removing from the pool

[Deltabreedy]

Why do you want someone to claim

[skitter30]

Also I'm pretty confident Skitter is scum - the reaction to the flip in #1251 is purely to bait out a 2nd PR.

- yesterday you thought it was me and mallow and mallow is town: you should really be reassessing your view of the game based on that
- i'm not fishing. It's elo and this is when prs should claim, esp. give that the tracker died. The doc should have been on her, but wasnt, so that indicates we have an FN: two of the other players already know ths anyways

Why exactly is this fishing, and why are you ascribing malicolious intent here. I.e. why is this more likely to come from scum-me than town-me

[skitter30]

Why shouldnt they claim

[skitter30]

Like what do we gain from then not claimingat this point

If they claim there's someone to take out of the pool and that makes the game easier for us to solve

It's either a doc who didntdo their job or an fn who should be known to half the remaining players

Like what's the point not knowing now

[Deltabreedy]

Take the assumption that I'm town Skitter - just for a minute.

What should my lim pool be and why?

[Deltabreedy]

@Black, what are your thoughts on Scum!Skitter?

[skitter30]

Csf and black
{In fact that's probably just the solve if you're town}

Now you do thr same exercise imagining i'm town + explain why i should be taking you as town

[skitter30]

Also I'm pretty confident Skitter is scum - the reaction to the flip in #1251 is purely to bait out a 2nd PR.

- yesterday you thought it was me and mallow and mallow is town: you should really be reassessing your view of the game based on that
- i'm not fishing. It's elo and this is when prs should claim, esp. give that the tracker died. The doc should have been on her, but wasnt, so that indicates we have an FN: two of the other players already know ths anyways

Why exactly is this fishing, and why are you ascribing malicolious intent here. I.e. why is this more likely to come from scum-me than town-me

I want you to address this please

[Black]

Can you summarise for me why you think it's Arko over Skitter?

Arko has been coasting since mala tracked him and I don't think skitter has been all that scummy outside of her connections with mallow. But I'm getting the PR hunting vibes that you're seeing and that's making me second guess myself now

I remember thinking some skitter/CSF interactions didn't feel like svs after they were cased by Arko but I want to go back and see if they feel forced or faked

Skitter/Arko is a possibility too. Arko cased skitter what feels like decades ago but he has never voted for her and has kinda rode the fence on her this entire time. He has voted for CSF though so I'm trying to figure out if Arko is scum, would he vote for his partner (CSF) or would he sus them without voting (skitter)?

Or maybe I'm just overthinking it and Arko was right all along. CSF is my #1 SR atm so I'm not really feeling any possibility that involves her not being on the scum team

[skitter30]

What is this pr hunting thing ... it's elo, and we should be fullclaiminhlg today. Like we all should hlbe claiming now.

Both black/delta: i want you yo explain why it's scummy for to suggest this and why it isnt in town's best interest to do so ...

[Black]

@Black, what are your thoughts on Scum!Skitter?

Wasn't feeling this after the mallow flip but now I'm going spend some time looking over the thread to see if there's anything I missed

[Black]

What is this pr hunting thing ... it's elo, and we should be fullclaiminhlg today. Like we all should hlbe claiming now.

Both black/delta: i want you yo explain why it's scummy for to suggest this and why it isnt in town's best interest to do so ...

Wouldn't it be better to save the claim for D4? If the other PR claims now then they just die overnight. What am I missing here?

[Deltabreedy]

Csf and black

{In fact that's probably just the solve if you're town}

Where did this solve come from? Why are you suddenly more sus of Black over me than yesterday?

Yesterday you were utterly convinced that I'm scum, now CSF and Black is 'Probably the solve'? Make this make sense to me please

Ninja'd: Because a claim allows scum to come up with the optimal position for a counter-claim and force a 50/50. I think my odds right now of hitting scum are greater than that from gut and a variety of reasons I covered off on yesterday and I think a claim would muddy the waters on that.