Newbie 2117 | Postgame

[furtiveglance]

1.05

Votecount 1.05

Brian Skies (2):

usesPython, Deltabreedy.

brzeczyszczykiewicz (2):

chaodck, Black.

Andante (1):

Brian Skies.

usesPython (1):

brzeczyszczykiewicz.

Black (1):

Malakittens.

Not Voting (2):

Andante, BlueSnakelet.

With 9 players alive, it takes 5 votes to eliminate.

The phase deadline is in (expired on 2023-03-30 20:16:46).

[Deltabreedy]

@Mala

Why are you still voting Black? Do you SR them?

[Black]

What would it take for you to rejoin the Brian vote?

Not much since brz is getting replaced

VOTE: Brian

[BlueSnakelet]

Now's a great time to renew the

E-1

.

VOTE: Brian

[Deltabreedy]

I get bad vibes from how quick Black jumped back after the replacement. They think that the 'slot' is scum, according to #370. I was honestly expecting them to be a bit more rooted in for voting that slot and I get weird vibes from how that plays out.

[Deltabreedy]

If the slot is scum, how does a replacement shake your faith in that read to the extent that you'll jump back onto the wagon?

[Deltabreedy]

If the slot (

Brz

)is scum, how does a replacement shake your faith in that read to the extent that you'll jump back onto the (

Brian Skies

) wagon?

Edited for clarity.

[Black]

I usually unvote a replacement. I think brz is scum but I also think Brian might be and plus you asked me to rejoin the wagon. Kinda rude to scumread me afterward for it, especially since you are so gung-ho about using our votes and whatnot

[Andante]

whether you think the slot is scum or not, I still say at least give replacement a chance. like, voting out scum with no interactions doesn't make this easy, but letting the replacement interact, gives way more info, and also if it's a town slot, giving the replacement a chance allows us to see town slot... I see no point in racing towards a lim there right now, we literally still have 5 days till deadline, not sure why "MUST LIM NOW" is feeling like the vibe here.

sorry for my absence, had 2 exams, so much stress. I'd like to try and find a scum today, delta,blue.. welcome, idk who yall are replacing lol

WAIT. MY REDDIT MAF FRIEND IS GONE? HE WAS COOL!!!

[Deltabreedy]

I didn't say I scumread you, I said I got bad vibes from it.

[Deltabreedy]

@Andante - That doesn't make sense. You make two points in #383:

1. That the replacement should be given a chance to speak and contribute. (

I agree with this.

)
2. That there's no point racing towards a lim right now. (

I also agree with this.

)

What doesn't make sense is that Black's actions align with point 1, but then jumped onto a wagon putting it to E-2, Blue puts it to E-1 and there's no commentary on it beyond what seems to be 'I disagree with this'. No thoughts on what's happened there at all?

For context, I replaced Wiz, and Blue replaced Nothing's New.

[Deltabreedy]

That reaction to such a small comment is awful to be honest, Black.

[Andante]

@Andante - That doesn't make sense. You make two points in #383:

1. That the replacement should be given a chance to speak and contribute. (

I agree with this.

)
2. That there's no point racing towards a lim right now. (

I also agree with this.

)

What doesn't make sense is that Black's actions align with point 1, but then jumped onto a wagon putting it to E-2, Blue puts it to E-1 and there's no commentary on it beyond what seems to be 'I disagree with this'. No thoughts on what's happened there at all?

For context, I replaced Wiz, and Blue replaced Nothing's New.

Doesn't make sense?
yeah the 2 points are like what I was saying, is this the race to the brian wagon yesterday? yeah no thoughts cause I'm not really reading, if I were reading, I'd have more thoughts?

I don't want to lim black if that's what you're asking?

[Andante]

That reaction to such a small comment is awful to be honest, Black.

but if scum is trying to look as towny as possible here, do you think it comes from scum?

[Deltabreedy]

How have you jumped from 'you haven't commented on what's happened with the wagon', to me thinking you want to lim Black?

[Andante]

idk man, like, that's just how my brain works although the second part is more me thinking you want to lim black/sr black, and me going "uhh nah I don't think that's the case here"

[Deltabreedy]

I mean, look where my vote is - if I wanted to lim Black I'd tunnel in on them and not let up. I just think their reaction in the last page has been a really odd one.

[furtiveglance]

KawaiiKame replaces brzeczyszczykiewicz.

[usesPython]

Hi Kawaii

[usesPython]

but if scum is trying to look as towny as possible here, do you think it comes from scum?

Why is scum necessarily trying to look as townie as possible here? Obviously not being obvscum is gonna be part of their goals but being obvtown is not necessarily optimal if it means sacrificing other aspects of their play.
In that sense looking scummy by jumping on a wagon can still be a good play for scum as long as it results in a miselim where there wouldn't be one without it

[Malakittens]

As much as I like the Brian wagon I’m not entirely sure I like the fast buildup without my vote

[BlueSnakelet]

As much as I like the Brian wagon I’m not entirely sure I like the fast buildup without my vote

Out of Python, Delta, Black and me, who do you suspects the most?

[Deltabreedy]

I also kind of don't like that response from Blue. It feels more reactionary and I feel like it's the kind of question someone would ask to judge the read on themselves than a genuine interest in the read, because Mala didn't indicate that they actually thought anyone on the wagon was scum? To assume that Mala suspects any of the people on the wagon seems to be an assumption that town wouldn't have.

[Brian Skies]

I don't think scum are on my wagon right now.

[BlueSnakelet]

I also kind of don't like that response from Blue. It feels more reactionary and I feel like it's the kind of question someone would ask to judge the read on themselves than a genuine interest in the read, because Mala didn't indicate that they actually thought anyone on the wagon was scum? To assume that Mala suspects any of the people on the wagon seems to be an assumption that town wouldn't have.

Mala said:

As much as I like the Brian wagon I’m not entirely sure I like the fast buildup without my vote

This implies that Mala thinks there's at least a possibility that there's something nefarious about Brian's wagon (right, Mala?). I want her to elaborate on this possibility.

Also, what do you mean by "reactionary"? And why is it a bad thing? As far as I know, most things in a game of Mafia are "reactions" to what came before it.