large normal 243: lindOVER

[Enchant]

VOTE: Andante

[Andante]

if 4 more people wanna be my biggest fan I can be freee

[Andante]

Andante (4): Kowahbunga, GuyInFreezer, Flavor Leaf, Venmar

+ enchant

That wagon just.. lmaooo ok.. rock solid TRs on them... Like, I have a level of SR on literally all 5 of these people

[Andante]

no clue who venmar replaced but he has been scummy af

[Cephrir]

@Ceph who would you put in the machine today if it was all up to you or if you'd rather just answer who is your biggest scum read from today?

enchant

[NJAC]

I townread Skygazer

Please explain.

Explained

What? Where?

ISOing you I see you had that slot leaning scum, am I wrong?

[Save The Dragons]

Ugh am I really 180ing on hu tao

[Save The Dragons]

Maybe I'm wrong. I dunno.

Still a lot of scummy slots I'd toss in the machine today tho

[GuyInFreezer]

I'm a sucker for AtE. I don't want Ceph. I think their spouse would be able to tell of they are faking it. Unless they are scum together but I don't think Dragons is scum.

I think sky is still the best vote and I think Venmar has been quite scummy in the last few pages

Would scum nonchalantly do the exact same thing she got wagoned for before?

[Save The Dragons]

Yes

[Save The Dragons]

Also I might be willing to do venmar

[Hu Tao]

Vote Venmar then. I would prefer that over sky I think

[Kowahbunga]

@Ceph who would you put in the machine today if it was all up to you or if you'd rather just answer who is your biggest scum read from today?

enchant

You've voted that slot (a lot) but not since Enchant replaced in, give me a why, please.

[Cephrir]

Their analysis felt forced - ie, their comments were uninteresting in a way that makes me think they were created just to have something to say rather than to scumhunt - and their manner of writing was really stilted and awkward, which could be personality but I don't know them and it could also be scum

[Kowahbunga]

I like Ceph for town today. Hu Tao, and all their many votes on many different people, is someone I will compromise for if we end up letting Andante off the hook.

[GuyInFreezer]

Andante will just kill me if we let her off the hook

…although that is actually a plus

[MalcolmTucker]

My intuition is telling me NJAC is a bad vote out today.

VOTE: Andante

Let's see what dreams are made of

Way behind on my catch-up but I don't particularly like this, feels like potential scum aware they'll look bad if NJAC comes back town and wanting to hedge their bets as a result. Has risks to it but if Hu wasn't confident about staying on at this point it's potentially a risk worth taking.

[MalcolmTucker]

but i don't have a better idea either if im honest

This doesn't sit well with the aggressive approach that Cephrir showed earlier in the game.

Cephrir is scum, my friends.

This feels a bit desperate, town players can evolve in how they approach the game and can admit to uncertainty at some points while otherwise having conviction.

[MalcolmTucker]

Yeah this doesn't feel like scum ceph

Don't think Ceph seems scummy at all either. They may have flip-flopped a bit but I feel they're being honest about their uncertainty in a way that feels natural and reasonable in a D1 where no solid suspects have necessarily solidified. The sudden light but very noncommittal scumreads are noted though, not sure I like (while catching up) how this wagon that's not a wagon seemed to be forming.

[MalcolmTucker]

Like unbiasly I don't see how I'm scum here by my play this this week. NJAC was an easy push if I was scum and is the other wagon, I'm literally risking myself to get another wagon going because I think my town read is town. [I guess we could be scum together though that would be a theory ]

Series of posts that follows from Hu Tao feels a bit more townie. There's a bit of that wild desperation of somebody who really doesn't seem to comprehend why they're being scumread even if the read itself is reasonable from the POV of others, I've definitely felt like this early in games before where I'm invested and feel like I'm making okay town contributions but most of the other players aren't seeing it. At first I saw the NJAC push as scummy but maybe it is just town being honest.

[MalcolmTucker]

whatever, I don't have the energy to fight a wagon on me right now, the case against me is just... we don't like my playstyle? sorry I was having fun, like, yeah, I was having a good time, and not like half this PL was doing anything... that clearly makes me the best lim.

nah, i've explained multiple times that's absolutely not the reason I'm pushing you.

Don't like this.

Nor do I. Aware Andante typically doesn't take being scumread particularly well but just feels like a complete misreprensation of why others might be suspicious about the slot. Scum points added to a slot I was largely townreading.

[MalcolmTucker]

I see no reason for this wagon on NJAC to have been dropped. Nothing has fundamentally changed about their play since it first formed, they remain fairly quiet and cautious in their play in a way I find believable in scum, and I don't think all that many people have particularly moved their read on the slot? That it was so close to working out and yet seems to have faded away seems suspicious to me, don't like it at all.

The vote on Skygazer isn't great either given that wagon has sort of popped up out of nowhere.

VOTE: NJAC

[Andante]

Maybe I'm wrong. I dunno.

Still a lot of scummy slots I'd toss in the machine today tho

am i scummy slot?

[Andante]

Scum points added to a slot I was largely townreading.

I mean, shouldn't you be concerned if you don't sr anything I do?

[Andante]

Andante will just kill me if we let her off the hook

…although that is actually a plus

Will I now... did you know it's possible for town to have killing power? )