Amnesiac Mafia: The Movie! That's a Wrap!

[Dunnstral]

Mafia get roles too, they just can't use them. Matching up doesn't confirm anybody, but actually using roles does. Maybe. Someone said mafia could have a mimic making that a dangerous assumption. This is why I was saying Firebringer could end up confirmed town depending on how role distribution worked out.


Kuribo, has anybody responded in your chat now that everybody has checked in? If not then the role could have gone to the dead/mafia. Or maybe there's more than 15 roles and it's out of the pool.

[Pink Ball]

I'm confused too now

[Titus]

Wait Titus, I think I had things backwards. Are you looking for who had your actual role on D1, or who has your D1 role today?

The latter.

Wait why are you looking for people that have the VT role?

I'm not. I have a role d2. Was trying to match the d1. I screwed up thinking we could confirm someone's alignment that way.

I'm not following here, I'm sorry. You told PB that you were looking for who has your D1 role today

No you misunderstood.

I'm looking to match you, StD, PB with my d2 role bc you guys were missing d1.

[Dunnstral]

So you are looking for who had your actual role on D1?

[Titus]

If I was unclear, that's on me. I'm playing when sick. On reread I can see the mixup.

@Dunn, yes.

[Pink Ball]

Yeah but you answered the latter and that meant the opposite of what you are saying lol I thought I had to crumb you my actual role to match your D1 role. Your D1 role was missing too

[Titus]

Yeah but you answered the latter and that meant the opposite of what you are saying lol I thought I had to crumb you my actual role to match your D1 role. Your D1 role was missing too

Sorry. I am taking a back seat to Drixx, against my better judgment, because my thoughts are wrong and jumbled.

[Black]

So you are looking for who had your actual role on D1?

How did you reach this conclusion when she said the exact opposite?

Also I don't understand what y'all mean by we were missing D1

[Pink Ball]

Unclaimed? I thought she meant that, I was paraphrasing her

[Titus]

Yeah let's go confusing Titus.

Drixx, my apologies if I was horribly wrong in my ill thinking. I hope you can take my claim as a sign of good faith I am rethinking. I know your skill level so I'm reluctant to give possible scum!you the entire setup but I bungled this bad enough where I shouldn't be at the wheel.

[Klick]

Wait Titus, I think I had things backwards. Are you looking for who had your actual role on D1, or who has your D1 role today?

The latter.

Wait why are you looking for people that have the VT role?

I'm not. I have a role d2. Was trying to match the d1. I screwed up thinking we could confirm someone's alignment that way.

*gasp*
Is this... fishing?

[Pink Ball]

I'm still confused tho. Maybe the mech talk is not ideal right now?

[Dunnstral]

So you are looking for who had your actual role on D1?

How did you reach this conclusion when she said the exact opposite?

Also I don't understand what y'all mean by we were missing D1

So you are looking for who had your actual role on D1?

How did you reach this conclusion when she said the exact opposite?

Also I don't understand what y'all mean by we were missing D1

I repeated what Pink Ball said in 2917. Titus meant the former but said the latter.

[Dunnstral]

I'm not sure why that is quoted twice.

[Save The Dragons]

I'm not sure how anyone can look at these last few pages and go "yep there's a clear scum agenda from Titus posts"

I'm not sure there's a clear agenda period

[Frozen Angel]

What I'm worried about a complete mass claim is chances of scum powers that can counter some aspects/skills even not knowing who will has them.

we don't know what scum utility exists in a game like this and (those skills should exist to balance the movements of roles and how pr cant be removed from game.

So I prefer just claiming targets personally until later days and why I suggested this yesterday and tried explaining it.

But if you all insist on a full mass claim I'm fine with that too and will do so if everyone else is doing it.

[Frozen Angel]

for what it's worth I think titus "being confused about setup" and going back on her day 1 "propositions" about no-claims seems genuine on first look.

[Frozen Angel]

also wtf is with this game and the cryptomessaging and asking for looking up "words" or "characters" in role pms to confirm roles

did you guys forget how all these stuff are the most awful things that can be suggested in a mafia game and so against the spirit of game itself?

like just focus on the game. discussing mech doesn't mean you need to literally break the game by asking for quotes. let people paraphrase claims and play game as it should be

[Frozen Angel]

that last rant is as a regular game designer and a passionate mod and not really related to game/my reads itself.

anyways will try to read day 2 more thoroughly tomorrow and will post my notes about day 1

nini

[kuribo]

Mafia get roles too, they just can't use them. Matching up doesn't confirm anybody, but actually using roles does. Maybe. Someone said mafia could have a mimic making that a dangerous assumption. This is why I was saying Firebringer could end up confirmed town depending on how role distribution worked out.


Kuribo, has anybody responded in your chat now that everybody has checked in? If not then the role could have gone to the dead/mafia. Or maybe there's more than 15 roles and it's out of the pool.

They have not

[Save The Dragons]

Help I'm bored at work someone do something scummy

[Save The Dragons]

Or someone suggest who to claim maybe?

[Save The Dragons]

I like shorts they're comfy and easy to wear

[Pink Ball]

I like shorts they're comfy and easy to wear

My Rattata is different from regular Rattata. It’s like my Rattata is in the top percentage of all Rattata

[Save The Dragons]

I heard they gave that rattata max ivs and evs so it's actually true