Amnesiac Mafia: The Movie! That's a Wrap!

[Klick]

This is the kind of energy I like to see

[Klick]

VOTE: TSQ

[Thestatusquo]

I don't really know FB's scum game. Is he cool calm and collected in these situations or does he flail? He seems like a good enough player to handle this well imo

It's more of a town!anyone reaction rather than a town!FB reaction. FB could fake being calmed when he's not, but doubling down with the "I didn't get the setup lol" is not what I expected. I think scum!FB (and with Ali) would create a scenario were what he did made absolute sense.

PB has equity with FB if FB flips scum mechs be damned.

What did you expect him to do but double down on the dumb tell he TWICE made?

This is ridiculously surface level.

[Pink Ball]

I like Klick's and STD's reaction to this too

[Thestatusquo]

You always ask me to scum read you and vote me when I do.

[Pink Ball]

Hmmm I like Klick's reaction to this a little less now

[Firebringer]

I never said i wouldn't scumread u when i didn't believe u actually scumread me.

[Black]

I find it odd that 'Firebringer is one of the best scum players on the site and could play this off cool easily' is coupled with 'I think Firebringer is scum for claiming to not submit an action that would have a high chance of confirming him as town'.

If FB is scum though then he can't use the role, so the easy way to explain that in the event of a rolecop/tracker/whatever would be to say he didn't use it right?

[Thestatusquo]

How is it possible that alisae only exists to give you reads to disagree with and not to discuss your night actions?

[Thestatusquo]

I find it odd that 'Firebringer is one of the best scum players on the site and could play this off cool easily' is coupled with 'I think Firebringer is scum for claiming to not submit an action that would have a high chance of confirming him as town'.

If FB is scum though then he can't use the role, so the easy way to explain that in the event of a rolecop/tracker/whatever would be to say he didn't use it right?

fucking finally.

[Black]

Klick/FB is entirely possible and honestly a little scary

[Thestatusquo]

I shouldn't say that so forcefully black has been listening to me the whole time.

[Klick]

Hmmm I like Klick's reaction to this a little less now

Would it help if I said my vote on TSQ is heavily influenced by my current thinking on the PoE

[Firebringer]

i think we can at least say for certainty that i have the role i claimed i had, even if im scum though.
cause if im scum the way to go wouldl be claiming VT as someone else said.
not that this helps anyone read me and i am not looking to help anyone read me,
but i can say im not gambitting with role claim and action. I could still be scum WHO COULDNT USE ACTION and DIDNT KNOW but im not lying about having the role and not acting.

[Klick]

I find it odd that 'Firebringer is one of the best scum players on the site and could play this off cool easily' is coupled with 'I think Firebringer is scum for claiming to not submit an action that would have a high chance of confirming him as town'.

If FB is scum though then he can't use the role, so the easy way to explain that in the event of a rolecop/tracker/whatever would be to say he didn't use it right?

Or claim vt
Or something that doesn't have an action to submit
Or like anything that isn't actively bad-looking

[Thestatusquo]

I find it odd that 'Firebringer is one of the best scum players on the site and could play this off cool easily' is coupled with 'I think Firebringer is scum for claiming to not submit an action that would have a high chance of confirming him as town'.

If FB is scum though then he can't use the role, so the easy way to explain that in the event of a rolecop/tracker/whatever would be to say he didn't use it right?

Or claim vt
Or something that doesn't have an action to submit
Or like anything that isn't actively bad-looking

Why is it believable to you that FB would make a mistake as town (i.e. not realizing the role was confirmable and that this mattered) but not as scum (i.e. not realizing how bad it would look to not try to confirm the role?)

[Black]

cause if im scum the way to go wouldl be claiming VT as someone else said.

Or claim vt
Or something that doesn't have an action to submit
Or like anything that isn't actively bad-looking

If there's a rolecop then this plan falls apart. Or if there are a set number of VT's or something

[Firebringer]

How is it possible that alisae only exists to give you reads to disagree with and not to discuss your night actions?

Did u miss me saying i briefly discussed with alisae the night action

[Pink Ball]

Hmmm I like Klick's reaction to this a little less now

Would it help if I said my vote on TSQ is heavily influenced by my current thinking on the PoE

In a world where I assume you're town, I would have almost the same PoE as you, except for TSQ and I would add StD (but I've seen your townread there and I could compromise with that).

But you started pushing the exact push I wouldn't.

[Thestatusquo]

its like you came into this interaction expecting FB to be town.

[Dunnstral]

If Firebringer was a mafia goon who received the amnesiac role "Corrupt Judge", and a Role cop targeted them, the Role cop's result would read: "Vanilla"; Because that is what a mafia goon returns as, would be Firebringer's actual role, and because of this line:

The Mafia Team will be assigned Amnesiac Roles in the same random manner,

though the roles will not be granted to them.

This assumes a standard Role cop. There

could

be a special variation for this setup.

[Firebringer]

cause if im scum the way to go wouldl be claiming VT as someone else said.

Or claim vt
Or something that doesn't have an action to submit
Or like anything that isn't actively bad-looking

If there's a rolecop then this plan falls apart. Or if there are a set number of VT's or something

A rolecop who targetted me night 1....okay

[Thestatusquo]

How is it possible that alisae only exists to give you reads to disagree with and not to discuss your night actions?

Did u miss me saying i briefly discussed with alisae the night action

You sure did claim to, but clearly you didn't do so successfully, or you're lying about that too.

[Klick]

I find it odd that 'Firebringer is one of the best scum players on the site and could play this off cool easily' is coupled with 'I think Firebringer is scum for claiming to not submit an action that would have a high chance of confirming him as town'.

If FB is scum though then he can't use the role, so the easy way to explain that in the event of a rolecop/tracker/whatever would be to say he didn't use it right?

Or claim vt
Or something that doesn't have an action to submit
Or like anything that isn't actively bad-looking

Why is it believable to you that FB would make a mistake as town (i.e. not realizing the role was confirmable and that this mattered) but not as scum (i.e. not realizing how bad it would look to not try to confirm the role?)

The nature of the mistake is pretty disastrous for scum but not actually that bad from a town!FB perspective
Town is also more likely to not care about the details of the setup or their claim

[Firebringer]

How is it possible that alisae only exists to give you reads to disagree with and not to discuss your night actions?

Did u miss me saying i briefly discussed with alisae the night action

You sure did claim to, but clearly you didn't do so successfully, or you're lying about that too.

This is why i don't believe ur scumread on me.