Amnesiac Mafia: The Movie! That's a Wrap!

[kuribo]

I'm asking rhetorically


I don't expect anything from scum except to die and be a cheap funeral

[Klick]

If I take out Dunn and STD and Firebringer and the Lovers here's what I am left with

Drixx
Frozen Angel
GuyInFreezer
Pink Ball
Thestatusquo

[Firebringer]

If I take out Dunn and STD and Firebringer and the Lovers here's what I am left with

Drixx
Frozen Angel
GuyInFreezer
Pink Ball
Thestatusquo

didn't pink ball claimed to have given Black specifically caterer before she even claimed. That makes Pink Ball 100% town.

[Klick]

If I take out Dunn and STD and Firebringer and the Lovers here's what I am left with

Drixx
Frozen Angel
GuyInFreezer
Pink Ball
Thestatusquo

didn't pink ball claimed to have given Black specifically caterer before she even claimed. That makes Pink Ball 100% town.

No, it doesn't. Black strongly hinted at having the role ages before Pink Ball said anything. I think Pink Ball having the role originally as scum, it randomly going to Black, and Pink Ball claiming to have targeted Black is a viable theory.

[kuribo]

Flail baby flail

[Ircher]

I'll wait for everyone to check in case someone counterclaims Fire, but otherwise, my vote is going on Klick.

[Firebringer]

id be amazed if someone counters

[Firebringer]

kuribo did no one post in the lover PT yesterday. Can we get a confirmation on there was no other lover or what

[Klick]

Whoever had my role last night should be able to clear me as town or confirm the person they targeted is scum. Unless they targeted Fey in which case that's pretty unfortunate

Black's second post of D2

I'm waiting to see if anyone claims my D2 role as their role yesterday because that should either confirm me as town or confirm someone else as scum

Black, I initially ignored this because I read it backwards, but I saw you claimed VT on D1 so...
A question, should the person that had your role on D1 be conftown too in case there were no interferences?

PB's first legitimate hint at being the one to target Black

There's plenty of time to organise thoughts in theory

[Ircher]

But why would scum Pink Ball remove Black from the PoE?

[Klick]

viewtopic.php?t=90488

If I am eliminated today, I strongly advise that a plan akin to the one discussed in this thread is put in place.

[Dunnstral]

If I take out Dunn and STD and Firebringer and the Lovers here's what I am left with

Drixx
Frozen Angel
GuyInFreezer
Pink Ball
Thestatusquo

didn't pink ball claimed to have given Black specifically caterer before she even claimed. That makes Pink Ball 100% town.

No, it doesn't. Black strongly hinted at having the role ages before Pink Ball said anything. I think Pink Ball having the role originally as scum, it randomly going to Black, and Pink Ball claiming to have targeted Black is a viable theory.

How would Pink Ball know it went to Black?

[Firebringer]

If I take out Dunn and STD and Firebringer and the Lovers here's what I am left with

Drixx
Frozen Angel
GuyInFreezer
Pink Ball
Thestatusquo

didn't pink ball claimed to have given Black specifically caterer before she even claimed. That makes Pink Ball 100% town.

No, it doesn't. Black strongly hinted at having the role ages before Pink Ball said anything. I think Pink Ball having the role originally as scum, it randomly going to Black, and Pink Ball claiming to have targeted Black is a viable theory.

How would Pink Ball know it went to Black?

because she claimed it first.

[Firebringer]

But why would scum Pink Ball remove Black from the PoE?

because it removes himself too. But yeah i mostly agree. Unlikely to do this its more pro town move and the fact black has to be killed to prevent guilties now.

[Klick]

But why would scum Pink Ball remove Black from the PoE?

Claiming to target Black convincingly enough sets PB up to endgame
Who cares if Black is removed from the PoE if it wins PB the game

[Firebringer]

But why would scum Pink Ball remove Black from the PoE?

Claiming to target Black convincingly enough sets PB up to endgame
Who cares if Black is removed from the PoE if it wins PB the game

not sure why u think scum!PB had a good reason to remove himself from the pool when he was never very strongly scumread to begin with. Think scumPB was in a good enough position that eliminating someone i would call pretty scummy imo (Black) was more + town points than any benefit gained from scum!PB.

But this is what i mean is how ur keeping too many options open to argue as many people as possible, i feel ur lim pool should be pretty small right now.

[Dunnstral]

If I take out Dunn and STD and Firebringer and the Lovers here's what I am left with

Drixx
Frozen Angel
GuyInFreezer
Pink Ball
Thestatusquo

didn't pink ball claimed to have given Black specifically caterer before she even claimed. That makes Pink Ball 100% town.

No, it doesn't. Black strongly hinted at having the role ages before Pink Ball said anything. I think Pink Ball having the role originally as scum, it randomly going to Black, and Pink Ball claiming to have targeted Black is a viable theory.

How would Pink Ball know it went to Black?

because she claimed it first.

No, Pink Ball was clearly hinting towards Black having the role they had on day 1 and was trying to get that info out of Black before Black claimed anything

[Firebringer]

No, Pink Ball was clearly hinting towards Black having the role they had on day 1 and was trying to get that info out of Black before Black claimed anything

quote me the posts of PB hinting he was giving the role to Black Day 1. I only saw a late claim on day 2 of pinkie confirming he sent to black. Which can read a bit post hoc.

[Firebringer]

actually idk if this matters
pretty sure Pinkie is town regardless of which happened.

[Dunnstral]

@Black either you already know it or you don’t

If you don’t get it either you’re too dense or I’m wrong and you don’t have my role.

Who do you think I targeted Black… and why do you think I don’t want to claim it

And both those questions are for you to think, not to post in thread

I'm sorting you, Black. Not the other way around

you still thought I was scum even after I crumbed my role

I haven't seen you crumb your role until this morning, if by "I am conftown from the one who targeted me's perspective"

And I really think that if you had my role, you wouldn't think I should claim my role if you understood the potential that the role has for the future

Look for the fucking crumb. Quote my posts where you think the crumb is if you want, and if you can't find it, then it's not it and something messed with my night action.

A question, should the person that had your role on D1 be conftown too in case there were no interferences?

The only thing that is tripping me up here is you asking if you should be conftown if you had my role

That question can be rephrased as "did you have to be targeted to get the role you got?"
You could've received it randomly if either the scumteam or DE had it

Black you either got it or not, I'm not talking about this anymore

Why won't you answer 3136? I think this is an important question. I would really appreciate an answer

Yes Black, if there were no inteferences, you're conftown from my perspective, and anyone who you target tonight should get conftowned from your point of view too if it's succesful

Black for fucks sake, giving information about the role is BAD. If I start the day by plainly voting you and saying "Black is confscum because I targeted her and didn't get my role" when there's a chance that my target failed for ANY other reason, I'm giving free information to the scumteam

All this is before Black claims the role

[Dunnstral]

I meant that PB had the role on day 1; day 2 is when they were talking about it but it was still before Black claimed

[Firebringer]

Dunnstral.

U quoted posts that happened after the claim.

[kuribo]

kuribo did no one post in the lover PT yesterday. Can we get a confirmation on there was no other lover or what

No one but me posted in it yesterday

I no longer have access to it and am no longer a lover

[Pink Ball]

Scum!me would have to make that play taking the risk of being tracked/followed/JKed/etc. I reached Black to conftown her and to work around a mech solve, not to get townie points that I didn’t need

[Dunnstral]

Oh we do. I'll just claim it at this point. Everything about my role is already out in the open

I'm a Caterer. I can target someone tonight. If they are town they get my role. If they are scum or if they die then the role is put back into the pool and randomly given to someone

PB was Caterer yesterday and he's claiming to have targeted me

This is the claim I am seeing and what I quoted happens before this