BooneyToonz XVI: Boons Ahoy! - [END]

[TemporalLich]

yet another sort of catchup because I somehow keep needing these type of posts...

yeah Doctor Drew is towny, 658 and 662 are good posts

wheme using the joke defense screams scum

frogs did post a read list in 672 so my assessment that frogs is scummy town is more confident now

enchant is scummy on page 28 as well

you said my posts on pg 24 were NAI; how does this then lead you to us being scummy town?

-Cakez

page 25 is when I started thinking that

and oh wow enchant just randomly claims neighbor with a partner for no good reason?!

VOTE: WhemeStar

I want to be confident a claimed neighbor is actually scum before voting, sorry

and such a hasty claim probably means enchant is town (though Klick is also likely town)

[Theta Alpine]

i should probably note
i am going to be gradually more and more limited access until the 28th while i pack up and then move
i should only have three or four days where i am practically unavailable though so i should still be able to participate

hmm
four person neighborhood do be pretty big though
not at certainty of having scum levels but
very high chance

i will say that does put enchant in another light for me
i do not think i would vote them today

also temporal uh
did you miss that wheme was also in that neighborhood or

[Emperor flippyNips]

I missed that wheme is in that neighborhood

[Emperor flippyNips]

Why, why. Why are you not wanting a enchant lim?

[Theta Alpine]

for me at least it would be a policy lim more then an actual scum read
i am not sure i could actually tell if enchant is town or scum

[Klick]

I never claimed hood is all town, i said assuming one of hood is mafia and making assumption only based on that is silly

Your reasoning in hood was simple that you assume hood MUST contain mafia and therefore it's one of us because "other is obvtown".

It was a good enough assumption for early game

A better reason for thinking there's scum in the hood is that many players in this game are towning it up and you and Wheme aren't

[Theta Alpine]

i am

not sure about wheme still
i am a bit more suspicious of them then i was earlier but
i feel like they would be playing more cautiously as scum

i end up reading and rereading them though
i am starting to get more willing to vote there at least
we are slowly starting to dwindle in remaining time left
and i am finding a lot more reasons not to vote people then reasons to vote people

[Theta Alpine]

the game has not yet clicked for me
and even though i am usually wrong when it does

every time i start to engage on someone i end up retracing my steps afterwards
i can kind of empathize with frogs cause they said similar about the game not clicking for them yet

[NorwegianboyEE]

Anyone wanna talk about how Malakittens has made posts but basically isn't playing?

[NorwegianboyEE]

VLA til Friday - lots of tests

Oh nvm i missed this.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I don't townread Theta, but they are mostly just being waffly with their reads and i don't feel like there is anything scummy i can pinpoint from their comments lately so i guess i should vote somewhere else.

@Whemestar
What are your thoughts on Enchant/Klick? TvT or is there scum in there?

[Klick]

Anyone wanna talk about how Malakittens has made posts but basically isn't playing?

I have been thinking about this and think it is a slight scumtell!

[Theta Alpine]

I don't townread Theta, but they are mostly just being waffly with their reads and i don't feel like there is anything scummy i can pinpoint from their comments lately so i guess i should vote somewhere else.

i mean i am self admittedly a bit waffly
no one is being all that scummy though aaaa
or when they are scummy they also have reasons to town read them so
i am having trouble this game

i mean enchant and firebringer are being scummy but those are a different sort of scummy and i do not want to elim there yet for one reason or another
temporal and wheme are a bit off but i think it was just early pressure on temporal and for wheme uh
not sure what to think about them
i want to say them and temporal is tvt but
scum has to be somewhere and unless the scum team is like
enchant | firebringer | ranger | malakittens
then there has to be someone outside of that

[Here There Be Dragons]

I want to be confident a claimed neighbor is actually scum before voting, sorry

???????????????????????

-c

[Here There Be Dragons]

i mean i am self admittedly a bit waffly

can't even commit to being waffly lmao

-c

[TemporalLich]

Why, why. Why are you not wanting a enchant lim?

I'm not confident that Enchant is scum anymore, especially with that strange Neighbor claim

basically, Enchant with that claim is now a low confidence scumread, but the claimed role is high value

[Here There Be Dragons]

wheme using the joke defense screams scum

frogs did post a read list in 672 so my assessment that frogs is scummy town is more confident now

how do you expect town to respond if accused of being scum for a joke?

is posting a read list alone +town to you regardless of what it says, or was there something actually town about the post?

why do i feel compelled to try to fix this mafia player.

-c

[Here There Be Dragons]

the claimed role is high value

i am starting to think you do not know what a Neighbor is

-c

[Here There Be Dragons]

Since its 1 am and i have nothing better to do. I am going to do a ranking list of how prolific I think each poster will be in this game. We will go with who i think will be top to least prolific posters in this game starting with:

1. Firebringer - obvious choice is obvious.

where u at dawg

-c

[Enchant]

Why, why. Why are you not wanting a enchant lim?

I'm not confident that Enchant is scum anymore, especially with that strange Neighbor claim

basically, Enchant with that claim is now a low confidence scumread, but the claimed role is high value

what

[TemporalLich]

I want to be confident a claimed neighbor is actually scum before voting, sorry

???????????????????????

-c

if we have an all town neighborhood we basically have a masonry

and a masonry is extremely powerful

pedit: read lists alone are +town because they indicate effort

it is possible to fake a read list however

also I was saying wheme was scummy because he was saying something was a joke as a defense

p^2edit: a neighbor is a role with access to a PT, it allows communication and is basically a masonry without the alignment knowledge

high value was a bit hasty to say however

p^3edit: I'm saying I doubt scum would make that neighbor claim

[Here There Be Dragons]

the alignment knowledge is the part of a masonry that is good

-c

[Here There Be Dragons]

@whemestar please make a read list so that temporallich will stop voting you

thanks

-c

[Enchant]

i am introvert

[Theta Alpine]

I'm saying I doubt scum would make that neighbor claim

i am fully under the impression that enchant would do the things they have done as either alignment