BooneyToonz XVI: Boons Ahoy! - [END]

[Peregrine]

I am bored also hoods sucks anyway.
I am in hood with 4 ppl which include Klick and only reason i am scumread by Klick is "HOODMUSTCONTAINONESCUMBECAUSE"

You know why Klick another topscumread Whemestar also in list with me?
Spoiler: Guess.

Klick while shitted long read lists about i don't care commenting, actual amount of effort they invested is zero. I also can put all my hood mates in topscumread and then vote them. Yet Klick calls me annoying for me basically mirroring what Klick themself doing.


I will bring this weeb conspiracy to the end.

I think that this! Was the moment I could actually get something of a read on Enchant because their previous posting was just a little irritating to me if I am honest, because I like when people play the game in a more serious manner but that is my preference!

This feels like a shoe drop moment in Enchant's posting that while I think is... kind of spiteful maybe? I do not know if that is too mean, but is definitely weaponized against Klick! But it is an important moment for Enchant who has floated around and given sparse content, and one that I think they would have to ride out more if he was mafia, if that makes sense? When you do something out of the norm from what you have done previously, it gets people's attention! And I am unsure if Enchant would get this annoyed if they were mafia.

[Peregrine]

My post posted early! I am sorry!

Too wounded for someone you think is mafia.

If i am mafia i am just doing my job you know?

Regardless of the color of your role PM no one's job is to actively try make the game a miserable experience for anyone

Not sure what you are about.

I called you evil and voted. I have right to do so in mafia game.

I think that these posts are righteous as well, something which I feel may not have occurred to a mafia Enchant to post! I understand that I may be excited for the first sign of more effort or explanation from them which may shift more strongly how I feel about their posting, but it just feels like an odd scenario to play out for mafia, and I am sorry that I am expressing a vague sentiment but I think that people agree with it so hopefully it's at least somewhat understood!

[Peregrine]

Also, regarding neighbors, it is a bit past the argument but! I do not think that there inherently has to be mafia in one but I understand the instinct to believe one is in there!!

I also think that there is benefit to having arbitrary pools to work with, sometimes! It gives you a spectrum of comparison!!

[Peregrine]

Okay, I am going to stop for the night and get in bed!! I will be back tomorrow! Good night!!!

[NorwegianboyEE]

I think Ranger’s content is good but i don’t like that they have me so low in their pool so i will act very Tsundere about it.

[Klick]

I am bored also hoods sucks anyway.
I am in hood with 4 ppl which include Klick and only reason i am scumread by Klick is "HOODMUSTCONTAINONESCUMBECAUSE"

You know why Klick another topscumread Whemestar also in list with me?
Spoiler: Guess.

Klick while shitted long read lists about i don't care commenting, actual amount of effort they invested is zero. I also can put all my hood mates in topscumread and then vote them. Yet Klick calls me annoying for me basically mirroring what Klick themself doing.


I will bring this weeb conspiracy to the end.

I think that this! Was the moment I could actually get something of a read on Enchant because their previous posting was just a little irritating to me if I am honest, because I like when people play the game in a more serious manner but that is my preference!

This feels like a shoe drop moment in Enchant's posting that while I think is... kind of spiteful maybe? I do not know if that is too mean, but is definitely weaponized against Klick! But it is an important moment for Enchant who has floated around and given sparse content, and one that I think they would have to ride out more if he was mafia, if that makes sense? When you do something out of the norm from what you have done previously, it gets people's attention! And I am unsure if Enchant would get this annoyed if they were mafia.

I think this is a fair point in Enchant's favor

UNVOTE:

[Students of Prudence]

Students of Prudence being a hydra def puts them in lower tier now that i know that. RH9 will likely flake in that hydra and furtive will probably fully replace in. Or both will flake. That is my prediction

Can you not start the game with a judgemental energy? ~F

I think Peregrine is town as well. I also think NorwegianBoy is town. I also think TemporalLich is town. Those are my strongest TRs.

I suspect Whemestar the most so far. If I was playing by myself I'd drop a vote. We'll see what RH thinks.

I'm seeing posturing in the creative way Whemestar is describing their thoughts, i.e. the pirate smell thing

-F

I really think TemporalLich is town here.

Can someone, maybe Norwee since you're banging the drum quite a lot, explain the case against TL?

-F

I think! That these were the posts that had me have Students of Prudence so high originally, but I don't feel as strongly about them as I did previously!

This sort of attitude felt like it wouldn't get many favors with anyone in the game, this early! And while mafia must make enemies of people eventually, opening on a sour note doesn't seem like it carries a lot of benefit!

I do not like their posting as much after the fact, though!

Hey everyone, checking in

Thoughts on main wagons: I prefer Enchant because Whemestar remains my only real scumread and is on Theta Alpine, but I think it's fairly likely both big wagons are town.

There's something about Whemestar's attitude and posting style that's screaming scum to me. It reminds me of catching scum in my chat mafia days.

I'm going into a big week at uni, but I'll try and post at least twice every 24 hours.

-F

I am bored also hoods sucks anyway.
I am in hood with 4 ppl which include Klick and only reason i am scumread by Klick is "HOODMUSTCONTAINONESCUMBECAUSE"

You know why Klick another topscumread Whemestar also in list with me?
Spoiler: Guess.

Klick while shitted long read lists about i don't care commenting, actual amount of effort they invested is zero. I also can put all my hood mates in topscumread and then vote them. Yet Klick calls me annoying for me basically mirroring what Klick themself doing.


I will bring this weeb conspiracy to the end.

I think Enchant's town here. Good luck with ending the weeb conspiracy.

As for Klick, I'm not sure I agree with Enchant's scumread there. Looking for scum in your hood partners seems like natural townplay to me. That is, it's what I'd be thinking about.

-F

The only judgement I can really come to on Frogs vs Here There Be Dragons is that it doesn't feel like town/town to me, which is hard to explain but linked to the fact I think both of their contributions are in line with scumplay of at least one of the constituent members that I've seen before, namely Alisae and Cephrir. Just style-wise. But if I had to call it I'm not sure which hydra is more suspicious.

-F

I'm not sure so many people would be townreading Whemestar if they were scum. It's possible I'm just scumreading their informal style.

I'm glad Firebringer cast some suspicion on Peregrine - when they said they had experience I started wondering if they're just some old scummer trolling as scum

Malakittens firmly in scum meta right now, waiting on anything of substance there

Those are my most relevant thoughts right now

-F

To me, it feels a little hesitant! I do not know how much weight I can put into this feeling on day one, but it feels noticeable enough that I want to point it out as reference, there is not much of a drive to push that they are making on their own.
However! Despite this I will point out that in 939, I really like the first line of that post!

And to reference 939 as well! I am really not sure why you would think I was trolling anyone here, and furthermore I do not understand what benefits you think I would receive if I was mafia who decided to do that! This doesn't feel like a real point someone would make, but if you would like to explain further I would appreciate it because I am not getting there myself!

I would move Students down from the high tier they were in in my reads previously to around null!

Did you ignore all of my posts within the hydra?
A lot of people seem to have reads more based off furtive, though. So I can't really complain.
-RH9

[Students of Prudence]

Peregrine, can you blame me for thinking you're trolling for ending every sentence with an exclamation mark?

You have to acknowledge it's a gimmick that you're choosing.

Also, if my posts feel a little hesitant it's probably because I haven't had really strong reads so far. I'd say my strongest one personally is Enchant town.

-F

[NorwegianboyEE]

I townread Enchant before it was cool, where’s my cred.

[Enchant]

Townreading me was always cool

[NorwegianboyEE]

I had 3 hours of sleep and a 12 hour work shift right afterwards yesterday. And today i’m typing this while at work again. Feels like i got brain rot so idk who scum are. But i remember feeling like Mala has been kinda scummy. I’d probably switch wagons there if anyone else is interested.

[Klick]

VOTE: Malakittens

[Enchant]

I really don't see difference between Malakittens.

If you want to pressure here well ok

[Malakittens]

Please let’s not and say we did.
I will get sorted later as this game goes on, thank you

[Enchant]

what if 14 other players also say that

[NorwegianboyEE]

Please let’s not and say we did.
I will get sorted later as this game goes on, thank you

I mean if you got the time to respond like this.
Shouldn’t you at least have the to be even remotely townie?

[NorwegianboyEE]

The time to*

[Malakittens]

Please let’s not and say we did.
I will get sorted later as this game goes on, thank you

I mean if you got the time to respond like this.
Shouldn’t you at least have the to be even remotely townie?

I’m at work right now and I’m settling down for the day. I got finished talking to a bunch of doctors.

I got to page 14 and I’m catching up as we speak, but I guess you’re just ignoring that where im giving my reads.

[Malakittens]

So the thing about Fb posts that bothered me was that his comments kinda felt like he was trying to gaslight me and then bring attention to shift wagons away from someone else and then onto me, but then I also had a lot of respect for his last post with backing off because that felt really town and not from a scum POV.

So I’m leaning more town on Fb for that.

[Malakittens]

i have to say i actually agree with klick in regards to Norwee. on page 17.

[TemporalLich]

Ranger has towny vibes especially in 960, shows real effort in solving the game

973 is a scummy post, so less confident in my Firebringer townread now

987 is ironically defensive

peregrine's hyperposting feels like reading a wallpost however I can sense a town mindset by skimming the peregrine posts. The peregrine post about Enchant does indeed vindicate Enchant somewhat (scumlean, but I still can't parse Enchant's posting style well)


oh and malakittens is worth a townread, also 1017 is a very helpful post

[TemporalLich]

oh and I'm still voting Enchant, better change that...

VOTE: WhemeStar

still scummy, and defensiveness isn't a towntell afaik

[Frogs]

V/LA through Monday

Gonna be really busy this weekend with graduation, won't be here much if at all

-Cakez

[Malakittens]

idk how 1017 is a helpful post

[Malakittens]

VOTE: cakez

i dont think enchant is scummier than frogz