Pokemon Battles 2 - Attack on Giratina [GAME OVER]

[Pink Ball]

I have a secret scumread that'll I reveal in a dramatic way in 6-7 days from now, and if I'm right that will be the lim for today

[Doctor Drew]

firebringer is town.

Nope

I agree.
But i'm gonna keep voting them anyway.

Yeeeessssss

why nope

Firebringer is always scum, they even say as much that they are scum.

Wait a damn second.....I have been duped!

[SquirtleSquad]

VOTE: Doctor Drew

[NorwegianboyEE]

Pink Ball and Squirtle seem like typical townie slots but idk if i fully trust Pink Ball.
Squirtle's Fire read is totally fire though. They can be town for sure.

[sheepsaysmeep]

Squirtle is town too

can u say more abt ur reads on squirtle/klick

I think my instinct about their exchange is very different from urs

Squirtle's read on you seems legit, not coming from scum pushing town or scum pushing a partner
Klick's defense on you seems legit, not coming from scum trying to whiteknight really early game or scum protecting a partner.

Scum!Squirtle doesn't need to do either of those things this early as scum.
Scum!Klick doesn't need to do either of those things this early as scum.

Not saying that they wouldn't but they don't have to, so I'm assuming they aren't.

mehhhh

I wifomily disagree with the middle section logic in that they both look traditionally good from being the first to say a bunch of serious stuff, so there is a reason to do this

but whatever

[sheepsaysmeep]

I think norwee is towny

[Doctor Drew]

VOTE: Doctor Drew

Oh my fat fuck pokemon is gonna ruin your little fake turtle.

[Pink Ball]

VOTE: Doctor Drew

You mother fucker

[SquirtleSquad]

the more sheep posts the more he is doing the first part of "you will show yourself to be townie or die" thing btw.

[Chandra Nalaar]

We had two whole days of pregame where presumably scum could talk and I feel pretty sure they would have discussed the battle mechanics so either this discussion on firebringers part of the battle mechanics of the game is a deliberate dumbtell designed to prompt me to have exactly this reaction, scum!firebringer completely ignored his scum team during pregame (possible ig?) or firebringer is town who has not spent any time discussing or figuring out said mechanics.

1 and 2 are possible but 3 is way more likely.

So I'm gunna need a really compelling answer to my "why" question.

They could have easily not discussed it. Towns give scum PTs too much credit. I've lost count of how many times I've assumed scum did XYZ on purpose only to learn postgame they were hardly talking at all.

Squirtle is town too

can u say more abt ur reads on squirtle/klick

I think my instinct about their exchange is very different from urs

Squirtle's read on you seems legit, not coming from scum pushing town or scum pushing a partner
Klick's defense on you seems legit, not coming from scum trying to whiteknight really early game or scum protecting a partner.

Scum!Squirtle doesn't need to do either of those things this early as scum.
Scum!Klick doesn't need to do either of those things this early as scum.

Not saying that they wouldn't but they don't have to, so I'm assuming they aren't.

If scum only ever did things they "have to" do, their win rate would be much lower.

And so begins what I presume will be a lengthy and calculated campaign of intentional uselessness. This is the most fun part of a game to read: low in density, things feel at their most fluid. If this is your response each time you view the thread, you will never post at all.

VOTE: WhemeStar

Scummiest vote so far imo.

VOTE: Chandra Nalaar

Thank you. It's good to know early who my detractors will be.

[Doctor Drew]

VOTE: Doctor Drew

You mother fucker

Like, the audacity.

Also Klick is town.

[SquirtleSquad]

We had two whole days of pregame where presumably scum could talk and I feel pretty sure they would have discussed the battle mechanics so either this discussion on firebringers part of the battle mechanics of the game is a deliberate dumbtell designed to prompt me to have exactly this reaction, scum!firebringer completely ignored his scum team during pregame (possible ig?) or firebringer is town who has not spent any time discussing or figuring out said mechanics.

1 and 2 are possible but 3 is way more likely.

So I'm gunna need a really compelling answer to my "why" question.

They could have easily not discussed it. Towns give scum PTs too much credit. I've lost count of how many times I've assumed scum did XYZ on purpose only to learn postgame they were hardly talking at all.

Squirtle is town too

can u say more abt ur reads on squirtle/klick

I think my instinct about their exchange is very different from urs

Squirtle's read on you seems legit, not coming from scum pushing town or scum pushing a partner
Klick's defense on you seems legit, not coming from scum trying to whiteknight really early game or scum protecting a partner.

Scum!Squirtle doesn't need to do either of those things this early as scum.
Scum!Klick doesn't need to do either of those things this early as scum.

Not saying that they wouldn't but they don't have to, so I'm assuming they aren't.

If scum only ever did things they "have to" do, their win rate would be much lower.

And so begins what I presume will be a lengthy and calculated campaign of intentional uselessness. This is the most fun part of a game to read: low in density, things feel at their most fluid. If this is your response each time you view the thread, you will never post at all.

VOTE: WhemeStar

Scummiest vote so far imo.

VOTE: Chandra Nalaar

Thank you. It's good to know early who my detractors will be.

add that as a fourth possibility if you want, I still think its way less likely than firebringer just being town tho.

[Chandra Nalaar]

If we could get some more votes on WhemeStar, that would be great. I would also accept patchwork. Get in on the ground floor of this scum catching opportunity! #girlboss

[Doctor Drew]

If we could get some more votes on WhemeStar, that would be great. I would also accept patchwork. Get in on the ground floor of this scum catching opportunity! #girlboss

I do like the cut of your gib.

[Firebringer]

Wow calling me town for being dumb with mechanics. That is boring.

I thought i was so town for my first post.

[Pink Ball]

If scum only ever did things they "have to" do, their win rate would be much lower.

What I meant is that scum!Squirtle is never getting town!sheep limmed with that half assed push, and they aren't looking townie while doing that either
And Klick is defending a player that I wouldn't take too much effort to defend in the first place (no offense sheep but this playerlist has a lot of other players that I would consider as a priority to get townread from)

When I say that they don't have to, is that it shouldn't be prioritized because they wouldn't get anything out of it as scum.
So the most logical conclusion is that town!Squirtle legitimately thought that sheep's entrance was scummy, and town!Klick couldn't hold the urge of get their nose in

[NorwegianboyEE]

If we could get some more votes on WhemeStar, that would be great. I would also accept patchwork. Get in on the ground floor of this scum catching opportunity! #girlboss

I think it's a fair criticism.
You're coming into the game very hard on a slot that merely posted they don't have time to read the 5 pages. If this is how you typically play regardless of alignment then i won't take too much issue. But still i find it independently to be more likely coming from scum that wants to take a grand standing early but does it by pushing an lurker slot.

[Firebringer]

Pinkie is very dirty dan right now. I wonder if anyone else can see it.

[Doctor Drew]

Wow calling me town for being dumb with mechanics. That is boring.

I thought i was so town for my first post.

I have some weird deja vu here

[Firebringer]

Wow calling me town for being dumb with mechanics. That is boring.

I thought i was so town for my first post.

I have some weird deja vu here

i know. ive been called town for not understanding mechanics too often.

[Doctor Drew]

Wow calling me town for being dumb with mechanics. That is boring.

I thought i was so town for my first post.

I have some weird deja vu here

i know. ive been called town for not understanding mechanics too often.

[Pink Ball]

Pinkie is very dirty dan right now. I wonder if anyone else can see it.

Nah you're trying to get a reaction out of me and you're not getting it.

Wait

[NorwegianboyEE]

Chandra seems more convinced than they should be when comparing it to the actual factual evidence at hand. (Or lack of)
And this discrepancy is what i find to be unnatural and scummy.

[Firebringer]

I am town this game

this is the most townie post ive ever made.
should be pretty obvious my alignment from this one post

[Firebringer]

Pinkie is very dirty dan right now. I wonder if anyone else can see it.

Nah you're trying to get a reaction out of me and you're not getting it.

Wait

Gottem
Hyper awareness is scummy too.

My case is starting to build.