@Santos:
How can we deduce that the rope is the right method?
Well, if we assume that armlx is correct about the 2 scum neighbors thing where they are on different teams then since oEJo needed a gun to lynch, then it would follow that the other scum neighbor would require a rope.
@Detspeed:
As for your ass-umption that I could be mafia and vote so aggressivly in that regard, it was my first post in my first game on this web site. I just wanted to be funny. I think I might have missed the mark, but I can see where your vote comes from. I have voted for people in other towns for less. You have every right to vote for whom ever you choose, and I would not take that right from you. That would be a very mafia thing to do.
Newbie card works only in Newbie games, and even then not for long. The fact that you replaced into a fully developed Large theme means you are confident about your ability to play well.
Right now I am on page 28 and still tring to figure out who is in the game and who is replaced with whom. It would be nice if I had some help, but unfortunatly I don't so you will just have to be a little more patient, or just kill me.
Ask and you shall receive. What information exactly are you looking for? If I can help I will.
@BM:
You had me pegged wrong. But then, i dont know how you had me pegged ATALL, given we've never played together before. :S
I dunno. It
could
have been because I had read 31 pages of this game.
You can't respond to suspicions that aren't posted. But it's always interesting to get a response to a vote before you explain it. If it makes you feel any better, your response isnt especially scummy, except that you sound like you're kissing my ass a bit.
I agree that it is a good guage of alignment to vote and watch for reactions, but I don't think leaving the reason out does anything more than contaminate the sample, since all alignments have a tendency to get irritated at unreasoned votes. And no, I was not trying to buddy up. I try to be polite as much as I can around here (until I get pissed off and start ranting endlessly).
That said, my vote should be pretty self-explanatory.
Your precursors were scum, therefore you are scum.
You've done nothing to suggest being protown to me, although i will acknowledge that you are playing much better than they did.
Bolded: Hmm. Either the mod sent you my role pm and sent me someone else's, or you are making assertions that you have no way of backing up. I would just love it if you could prove to me beyond a reasonable doubt that the role I got is wrong and I'm scum, since you seem certain enough to state it as fact.
Oh yeah, and I don't attempt to look protown. I attempt to catch and lynch scum. They are not the same thing.
Also, CarnCarn makes a very good point. Not only did you never accuse my predecessors of being scum, you never accused me of it D2, not even after the post that you say looked scummy, which I will address presently.
This query struck me as scummy. Furthermore, PutaPuta was not a sitewide flaker. It's only here he found participation difficult. And i'm naturally suspicious of players who go overboard trying to look protown.
Three problems with this post.
First, how exactly did my question 'strike you as scummy?' It helps if you explain yourself when you make an accusation.
Second, I have a fairly good idea as to why PutaPuta flaked here and not in other games. I think it's ZazieR. I remember randomly stumbling accross a game with the both of them in it, and PutaPuta expressed displeasure right off the bat upon discovering that ZazieR was there too. I believe that the accusation was something like PutaPuta accusing ZazieR of 'being a dick' to him/her in previous games. It's just speculation, but I see that as the most likely reason, especially considering no one had suspected any of them when they left.
Third, how am I going overboard to look protown? I've done nothing but post my thoughts and yell at people for lurking.
@armlx:
Anyone on the Detspeed wagon based on his single post is weak sauce.
Newbie 661. Player: Haterade. Look it up. He did
exactly
what you just did. He was right, but that's because he was the scum blocker.
@hp [leaves]: Don't use ad hom.
Because, no matter how you dress it up, that's what the world is. A community of idiots doing a series of things until the world explodes and we all die.