BooneyToonz XVI: Boons Ahoy! - [END]

[Here There Be Dragons]

Can frogs be scum yet? Please?

VOTE: Flippy and if it's drew I'm not taking the blame for the L

-c

My gut response when reading this is to feel like you have no feelings on whether Drew actually IS town or scum, but you're annoyed that he is now being considered less.

I feel like a viable response you could have made as town here would have been to have a quick skim through Drew's meta yourself and confirm whether what I was saying was true or not.

I feel like the response you've given, while still possible as town, is kind of the response you'd need to give as scum because you want to come back to Drew as an option later.

I'm annoyed because I want to be right but I think you're town and you have concluded that the meta says otherwise. I both want him to be scum and know that nothing is happening without your approval.

I've been pretty town recently, so if this is where you are, maybe you should just kill me.

-c

[Here There Be Dragons]

Mala has a 1-shot Tracker left
Flippy has Weak modifier

Okay not that busted but still we get quite a lot of info in theory

And there's also a jailkeeper.

It is almost as though there's no fucking way all these roles are real.

[Here There Be Dragons]

It's like fucking mala or something and this is all completely pointless.

I would like to give up now. Just tell me where to vote even if it's myself.

[Klick]

Can frogs be scum yet? Please?

VOTE: Flippy and if it's drew I'm not taking the blame for the L

-c

My gut response when reading this is to feel like you have no feelings on whether Drew actually IS town or scum, but you're annoyed that he is now being considered less.

I feel like a viable response you could have made as town here would have been to have a quick skim through Drew's meta yourself and confirm whether what I was saying was true or not.

I feel like the response you've given, while still possible as town, is kind of the response you'd need to give as scum because you want to come back to Drew as an option later.

I'm annoyed because I want to be right but I think you're town and you have concluded that the meta says otherwise. I both want him to be scum and know that nothing is happening without your approval.

I've been pretty town recently, so if this is where you are, maybe you should just kill me.

-c

It's not about *being right* it's about actually being at the correct answer

There is one correct answer for everyone's alignment in this game and ultimately whatever lens you use if you're using it properly should point to that alignment instead of the wrong one

If Drew's scum, then something about how he is playing fits his scum meta instead of his town meta. He isn't somehow perfectly emulating his town game. There should be evidence that he's scum through that lens.

I can't find any. I see the opposite.

I'd be interested in seeing you do the same thing - looking at a few of Drew's games, seeing how he typically plays and the differences between his alignments, and then coming back to this game and seeing which fits his play here better. I feel like if you did, you'd either more comfortably see Drew as town, or you'd see the opposite and we could have a conversation along those lines and come closer to the truth of the situation.

I feel like the more confident I get in my solving, the more dejected you feel. I don't like sapping the fun out of things, but I feel like I'm just trying to do my job in this game same as you're trying to.

[Here There Be Dragons]

VOTE: Dragons
For their shade on me

Yeah that makes so much sense. Town never question the assumptions! After all they're performing so well for us. Maybe you should try scumhunting if you don't want to be questioned. Sitting there like a lump and only bothering to participate when I annoy you is a great way to lose if you're town

It's funny how we pretended the ranger mislim was going to make us think and then came right back to me like we were lining up if she flipped scum. Good thinking team 10/20

[Klick]

I feel like anyone that gets any amount of pressure in this game just goes 'wtf y'all I'm town why are we still suspecting me I guess you can kill me but I'm town and it's on you for getting it wrong'

Like this game DOES have an answer. Out of all the people pulling that card, there has to be at least one scum. If you think you're obvious town and suspicion on you is unreasonable, spell that out for the class.

[Here There Be Dragons]

I mean sure I could do that. But first I'd have to give a shit and I currently don't. Ask again later

[NorwegianboyEE]

Oh nooo~
How could i scumread you woe is me.

[Klick]

VOTE: Dragons
For their shade on me

Yeah that makes so much sense. Town never question the assumptions! After all they're performing so well for us. Maybe you should try scumhunting if you don't want to be questioned. Sitting there like a lump and only bothering to participate when I annoy you is a great way to lose if you're town

It's funny how we pretended the ranger mislim was going to make us think and then came right back to me like we were lining up if she flipped scum. Good thinking team 10/20

I'm trying to solve mate. Tell me where my solve is failing and why instead of telling us all we're playing badly.

[Klick]

Who is scum that I am saying I cannot see as scum

[Here There Be Dragons]

Oh nooo~
How could i scumread you woe is me.

Yeah that is basically what your response was to a slight question. Glad you have that self awareness

[Here There Be Dragons]

I'm not solving right now I'm being mad I can't turn it off instantly

[NorwegianboyEE]

Like Klick is saying you kinda need to prove that our assumptions on some slot being town is wrong before any progress can be made at all assuming you’re not scum.

You’re saying we’re not solving when in reality we have solved already and the result of our thinking is that all other slots are more likely town than yours.

[Here There Be Dragons]

Like Klick is saying you kinda need to prove that our assumptions on some slot being town is wrong before any progress can be made at all assuming you’re not scum.

You’re saying we’re not solving when in reality we have solved already and the result of our thinking is that all other slots are more likely town than yours.

"Our" as though you did anything

[Here There Be Dragons]

Oh nooo~
How could i scumread you woe is me.

isn't this literally what you acted like in response to being slightly sr

~std

[Here There Be Dragons]

Enchant is never scum
Norwee is never scum
Frogs is like 99% never scum, and if they're scum it's with exactly flippy
Mala and Drew are very very towny

Flippy/Dragons/Peregrine.

why did you come to these conclusions

sorry i'm kind of jumping all over the place so if you answered let me know and i'll try to find it

~std

[Here There Be Dragons]

I've scumhunted this game. I've pushed where I think scum are. What has peregrine done besides emanate vibes

[Here There Be Dragons]

norwee is so slimey why is he clear

~std

[NorwegianboyEE]

I think i’ve been very townie in this game.

[Here There Be Dragons]

cool

~std

[Klick]

Enchant is never scum
Norwee is never scum
Frogs is like 99% never scum, and if they're scum it's with exactly flippy
Mala and Drew are very very towny

Flippy/Dragons/Peregrine.

why did you come to these conclusions

sorry i'm kind of jumping all over the place so if you answered let me know and i'll try to find it

~std

Which ones do you disagree with in particular?
What's your position? Who is viable/particularly likely scum from your perspective?

I'm not interested in arguing all of my reads to you I'd rather argue the ones that matter

[Here There Be Dragons]

i mean you can probably surmise the norwee one from recent posting

talk to me about that one

~std

[Frogs]

Even Night Weak Hider/Odd Night Simple Doc

N1 Ranger, N2 Enchant

Hold up, you claiming Enchant is clear?
Why did you hide behind Enchant?

Ok so Drew claims they already copped Ranger noght 1 yet voted them day 2? An confirmed town to them?

VOTE: Drew
???

Oh wait it’s doc. Holy shit i’m stupid.

UNVOTE:

this sequence of posts is probably townie ig?

[Here There Be Dragons]

I find that so massively unconvincing

I had the same thought process, I just figured it out before posting

-c

[NorwegianboyEE]

What i don’t like about StD is that they seem to mainly just complain about townreads on me rather than actually explain why i’m scummy and should be eliminated.