Normal 2302: Magical Girls | GAME OVER

[geraintm]

Ugh I'm sorry. Been busy with survivor meet prepping and work is hectic as well so I can't do what I normally do which is play at work

I'm a novice doctor.

You knew you were a likely elimination today, and you wait till now to make this claim.

I don't buy it at all

[OopsieDaisy]

Ok yea I think I see your logic. StD's alignment will become indicative from what happens tonight anyways (well, either that or our vig survives), so why waste our vote on em right now when we could vote another one of our suspicions. I've got a strong x to doubt on there being two separate mafia doctors so either StD is telling the truth and is town, or is bsing and scum.

The issue is I'm not sure if I believe it, the claim is mighty convenient.

[sheepsaysmeep]

yes I agree with everything towwl

[towwl]

Yeah I think we just vote out STD on D3 if Emp dies N2.

VOTE: Firebringer

[sheepsaysmeep]

std claim is more likely fake than not fake but we can try to play "follow the vig" for a bit

yea

[sheepsaysmeep]

VOTE: tweet

poke

[towwl]

poke is good

[Emperor flippyNips]

tbh im very tempted

[Emperor flippyNips]

Ugh I'm sorry. Been busy with survivor meet prepping and work is hectic as well so I can't do what I normally do which is play at work

I'm a novice doctor.

Oh I see

[Emperor flippyNips]

I don't believe STD but at the same time I don't want to vote him out today, I think we can look elsewhere.

Basically I'm thinking is doc!STD should just protect Emperor and die tonight, giving us another vig shot from Emperor. And then we figure out what to do Day 3 if STD is still alive. In the meantime we can look more into MT, DGB, or FB

Then if I die we know std was in fact not a doctor and lied, like a liar and vote them tomorrow

[Emperor flippyNips]

Ugh unless roleblocking fucks things up? Like say Emp dies N2 and STD survives and says he was roleblocked. I don't think I'd believe him. I feel like Emp getting a shot off last night indicates scum doesn't have a roleblock. Or at least they didn't have a roleblock N1. aargh

Well shit

[Firebringer]

Yeah I think we just vote out STD on D3 if Emp dies N2.

VOTE: Firebringer

i would find it hilarious if StD is scum, i had the chance to hammer him. Then didn't and then i got elimmed instead.
So i extremely approve of this just because of the entertainment value

[Firebringer]

I don't believe STD but at the same time I don't want to vote him out today, I think we can look elsewhere.

Basically I'm thinking is doc!STD should just protect Emperor and die tonight, giving us another vig shot from Emperor. And then we figure out what to do Day 3 if STD is still alive. In the meantime we can look more into MT, DGB, or FB

Then if I die we know std was in fact not a doctor and lied, like a liar and vote them tomorrow

true, unless roleblocker
but w/e we can give StD another day

[Emperor flippyNips]

Well shit. Now I don’t get to shoot fire tonight

[towwl]

Anyways a quick review of why I think fb is scum:

1. Merlyn questioning CKD during CKD's early push on Elements (178)
2. Firebringer very vaguely arguing in favor of not killing Elements (866)
3. Firebringer and Elements openwolfing together (891, 924)
4. Firebringer arguing against scumhunting d2 (1080, 1158)

As far as point 4 though I was kind of feeling similar vibes with how the game was going at the time. That being said though now that we're not going after STD and D2/N2 doesn't seem like as sure of a thing as it did before, I'd like FB to tell us why we should vote for MT instead of FB.

[towwl]

Well shit. Now I don’t get to shoot fire tonight

Eh, maybe

[towwl]

When I first read FB's nka in 962-968 I first was thinking it was pretty townie, but reading it again now I'm pinged by the short amount of time between the posts, particularly saying he's going to investigate who Emp was going to kill in 964 and then doing that analysis and coming to a conclusion 2 minutes later in 966. At the very least, I'm not capable of thinking that fast. Makes me think premeditation is involved and the thought process isn't so natural.

[Firebringer]

As far as point 4 though I was kind of feeling similar vibes with how the game was going at the time. That being said though now that we're not going after STD and D2/N2 doesn't seem like as sure of a thing as it did before, I'd like FB to tell us why we should vote for MT instead of FB.

didn't i tell u im not a salesman

also u not townread me is a u problem. i don't care to convince u ur wrong

[towwl]

You don't even need to try to convince me about anything. I'd just like to know what pings you about Tweet

[Firebringer]

she feels unnatural. i saw she was getting ragey earlier and i had no idea why town her would get raged
and theres the fact she isn't invested in solving this game at all atm which to me town her would always be interested in doing the fact it isn't present could be she is busy with rl shit but i feel her solving this game has left much to be desired for a town mt.

[towwl]

Ok thank you ty thanks

[curiouskarmadog]

I'm a novice doctor.

I dont believe it. At all. LOL, fun game, everyone has a power role.

[curiouskarmadog]

As lose as Fire is playing, Wouldnt FireScum have hammer STDtown?

[curiouskarmadog]

Ugh I'm sorry. Been busy with survivor meet prepping and work is hectic as well so I can't do what I normally do which is play at work

I'm a novice doctor.

You knew you were a likely elimination today, and you wait till now to make this claim.

when do you think I good time to make the claim would have been?

[curiouskarmadog]

so either StD is telling the truth and is town, or is bsing and scum.

tee hee...

you just described EVERY claim.