I don't think we need to know if there's 2 scum or 3 today in order to lim fire
I don't really want to comment on scum claiming strategy in the event that there's only 2 scum at this stage because they could easily make a mistake when massclaim comes, be it today or tomorrow
i think i probably am generally too accepting of people suspecting me bc im like "yea sure i probably deserve that"
and ive let scum get away w it before
except this time i do still think the main people pushing me are town. so. maybe now isn't the time for applying those lessons. or maybe i haven't learned. idk
idk i guess i kinda am philosophically opposed to the "where's the CASE" mentality bc sometimes people are just scum and it's sometimes kinda easy to pick apart cases
but also it's probably not such an unreasonable thing to request one
i mean maybe scum mena is smart/bold/unashamed enough to believe that he can get away with playing dumb
i just kinda thought it would be too embarrassing for him. and i do still think the initial reaction to me was towny. and i do buy that he would genuinely think that koba's approach is a good way to play the game
but it is kinda weird to go from believing enchant is scum off something that i still don't really get why he was so confident in, to trying to solve the whole game off it preflip (and showing no regret or shame at having done so after the flip came)
to then being way more confident in me being scum (in a manner that i think does actually make sense from town mena) to... doing literally nothing to solve the game off it preflip
there's been like two posts about slots unrelated to me in the last 2 weeks
In post 1878, fireisredsir wrote:
can't the third scum just claim a role that makes the math be mathing correctly to fool us into thinking there's 2 scum
No, it would shift us from 2 scum to 2 scum and a SK. And the likely conclusion from that is that there is no SK and one of the pr claims are lying.
Mafia would need two people to claim to make it seem like there were 3 mafia - but if they do this, it is again clear that somebody is fake claiming when the mafia don't win at 5 people alive.
But at least I figured out the possible scum teams. Because they're like, written out plainly and even though I noticed most of them had Godfathers I just didn't actually count how many roles were in them all. ._.
Still haven't figured out why the setup seems to assume that it's impossible to roll in the same PR's block of numbers more than a certain amount of times though. I want to see a 7Vs game!
"Yeah after a point it felt like Aureal was the only one talking sense despite being a goose so I just followed."
-furtiveglance
ok after a more thorough reading of aisa scum and town meta i feel a bit better here actually
she is good at scum (and good at replicating some of the energy that i was vibe townreading) but i think there's noticeable differences in the directions she chooses to take. pretty much every post is advancing her position and pushing agenda she has goals in mind when she's doing things and i think they're visible
as town there's a sort of nervous excited energy of let's solve the game. maybe bc of the pfp i picture a bunny who has just been dropped in the middle of an open field and is really excited to go find the carrots or whatever but doesn't know where they are and also is a little intimidated by the open space surrounding them. so there's a lot of eager jumping around and sniffing at things and changing course and things not going how they were planned bc there never really was a plan in the first place. it still comes across as relatively composed but the energy is underlying things
this game does have a good amount of that, i think, and it's something implosion talked about earlier when he was saying why he was willing to townlock her. i think i agree. she feels inquisitive, pushing things because they're fun to push and she wants to see what it will do, and not bc it will get her anywhere necessarily. fundamentally, she feels driven primarily by a desire to solve the game
admittedly it is... hard to guess at seeing if there's agenda in things when we have no idea what the scumteam is rn. and that's probably something to assess after flips. but i feel like at least ive done a more diligent check here and am more okay with calling her town
In post 1455, fireisredsir wrote:
yea i mean if you're town then i will be less confident in my ability to read you and ill also feel pretty bad for replacing in here and then getting you killed
and if you're town then sheep and aureal would probably be the first places im looking but id also be worried bc i would not really have a clue who the third would be
this post would be hilarious in hindsight if it's a 2 person scum team with sheep and aureal
kinda thought going in that i was gonna scumread him more but im not as sure of that, some of the mid day 1 posting swayed me a bit. but i think if he is wolf he is just aiming for playing a super pure game where he is generally on the right side of things and is just kinda chilling to set up for endgame. which is a hard wolfgame to find. i think his posting today hasn't been as pure though, and some of the stuff surrounding skitter maybe
part of me does just want to sheep skitter on sheep idk. i wish she was still here. whos idea was it to kill her. not mine
was really feeling like dunn's scumgame in that was recognizable until i got to endgame where he flipped a switch and started playing more aggressively and confidently and it was v effective, i would have been fooled by it probably
"Yeah after a point it felt like Aureal was the only one talking sense despite being a goose so I just followed."