Weird Dreams Mafia Redux [Finished]

[usesPython]

I think the methodology is flawed and that if we're looking to be accurate on who did it we should be looking at people who normally post in that time period but didn't (Especially if they then posted a few hours later)

[usesPython]

I also think talking about this during the day like this is pretty unproductive and that either we'll get information from night abilities and can do stuff then or we don't and it's something to deal with when the number of players has been narrowed down enough through lims/ICs to accurately predict who did it

[Radical Rat]

In this case it's relevant to the Nightmare. We have seven people without her, I think she's a liability, so even if it's just to sate my paranoia, can we like. Not have her in? That's all I'm asking at this point.

[usesPython]

So Doctor Drew, Abnegation, Aureal, Radical Rat, usesPython, DragonEater70, Titus? Also

HEAL: Doctor Drew, Abnegation, Aureal, Radical Rat, usesPython, DragonEater70, Titus

It's Python's proposal, minus Ranger.

I officially no longer want to eliminate Drew (today), but Ranger is a big enough question mark for me that if we ARE trying to make a pure Nightmare, I don't want her in it yet.

Please use the hurt tags to submit a proposal or to vote for an already existing one. Please use the heal tags to unvote a proposal, or to withdraw your proposal.

You're not actually voting for a proposal there

[usesPython]

UNVOTE: Drew

[Radical Rat]

Oh my bad, I got mixed up on hurt/heal lol.

HURT: Doctor Drew, Abnegation, Aureal, Radical Rat, usesPython, DragonEater70, Titus

[usesPython]

HURT: Rats proposal

[sheepsaysmeep]

I think your proposal has a low chance of being completely pure and you might as well include us all

[sheepsaysmeep]

DragonEater70
Ranger maybe I havent processed the recent stuff
Radical Rat
usesPython
Rautherdir??????????
Kyoko Kirigiri??????????????????
camelCasedSnivy?????
sheepsaysmeep

8 names that I would support a pool of 7 from

[Save The Dragons]

what's the tl;dr reason for not putting everyone

[usesPython]

what's the tl;dr reason for not putting everyone

7 person PT to co-ordinate night actions

[usesPython]

7 person PT to co-ordinate night actions

Also there was some worry about scum being able to counter stuff if they knew what's happening but given that the BP IC invention can't be blocked/redirected I don't think that's a problem

[Korina]

Random Nurse replaces biancospino effective right now!

[Rautherdir]

7 person PT to co-ordinate night actions

Also there was some worry about scum being able to counter stuff if they knew what's happening but given that the BP IC invention can't be blocked/redirected I don't think that's a problem

.... wait do kills happen before invention awards. Well I guess if we just target people that are scummy and that are probably elim targets like the original idea this shouldn't matter.

Anyways there are other reasons to have a smaller group. There's a chance that there's a role that will be able to just outright know if there was no scum in the previous Nightmare.

[usesPython]

.... wait do kills happen before invention awards.

Is this really a question you should be asking in the main thread? Like we also have a few mech questions on how exactly BP IC inventions work but you don't see us asking that where scum can see

VOTE: Rautherdir

[usesPython]

And no, if NAR is being followed then kills happen after the invention is handed out

[Rautherdir]

I tend to assume a degree of competence in scum. They can already see what our plan is, they're going to have to develop a counter-strategy, we might as well discuss any particulars. I asked though cause I legit could not find it in the wiki for some reason.

[usesPython]

We should get more votes on Rauth

[Merlyn]

I tend to assume a degree of competence in scum. They can already see what our plan is, they're going to have to develop a counter-strategy, we might as well discuss any particulars. I asked though cause I legit could not find it in the wiki for some reason.

we don't have to make the job easier though, you know?

[Merlyn]

We should get more votes on Rauth

Yeah okay: VOTE: Rauth

[Rautherdir]

I tend to assume a degree of competence in scum. They can already see what our plan is, they're going to have to develop a counter-strategy, we might as well discuss any particulars. I asked though cause I legit could not find it in the wiki for some reason.

we don't have to make the job easier though, you know?

I mean in one sense yes. But if scum already know and have discussed these topics on their end which... I am assuming is the case then getting this information clarified for everyone should actually help town make sure they have a solid plan themselves as well?

[Rautherdir]

Or is this wrong, in which case yeah, sorry, I'll refrain from trying to figure out any way this plan for town's benefit can go wrong within the space where I know town can see it.

[usesPython]

Literally all you had to do was PM Korina about it. Even in the scenario where the kill happens before the invention the sheer fact that the kill happened at all tells you there's someone good at mech on the scum side and rules out possible team compositions

Unlimited votes on Rauth please

[WhemeStar]

I’m having trouble getting into this game I think it’s cause all the mech stuff but I’m staying caught up

VLA til Monday gf coming over for weekend sorry every1

[Rautherdir]

Literally all you had to do was PM Korina about it. Even in the scenario where the kill happens before the invention the sheer fact that the kill happened at all tells you there's someone good at mech on the scum side and rules out possible team compositions

Unlimited votes on Rauth please

And personally I'm of the opinion doing this doesn't help town as a whole. Scum should do this because they want to find flaws that town doesn't.