Weird Dreams Mafia Redux [Finished]

[Abnegation]

and another post 1000 is mine.

[Abnegation]

Not buying a lot of the logic related to traitor/lawyer signaling. Way more indicative ways to do it in a game with two voting mechanisms, imo?

it almost feels too obvious to me.

[Aureal]

But does it really count when you're on an alt?

[KatyKimFanClub]

Making 999 and then reading 977 is wild. Just when you thought the book was closed... ?

I think I'm going to sheep StD.

VOTE: DragonEater

[camelCasedSnivy]

and another post 1000 is mine.

oh my fucking god I should've been paying attention

also can someone tell me what lawyer you're talking about?

[Abnegation]

lawyer would be a 3p role who has to protect their "client" and keep them from dying/getting executed, not quite sure of the specifics. that would more likely be called saviour here though.

[Radical Rat]

I thought I had worked it out, but it has now become apparent I was wrong. I haven't decided what that means about you yet.

Can you do me a favor and make the connection you originally missed obvious to me? I remember remarking at the time that your logic was tenuous but hopefully I can see why it's totally broken at this point in the game.

Here I'm referring to figuring out what Ranger meant by a glaring hole in my logic.

The conclusion I came to was that I'd overlooked the possibility of a Mason or something similar. Ranger explicitly saying she has no connection to Drew though means that isn't what happened though, so I'm more or less back where I was originally, but leaning more in favor of killing Drew

[Abnegation]

i don't understand why de70 is getting voted. ranger has a gut feeling and the rest of you are voting there because...why?
i don't think they've done anything scummy so would appreciate if someone would explain.

[Doctor Drew]

VOTE: Abnegation

[Abnegation]

VOTE: Abnegation

what's that for?

[Aureal]

i don't understand why de70 is getting voted. ranger has a gut feeling and the rest of you are voting there because...why?
i don't think they've done anything scummy so would appreciate if someone would explain.

I'm showing my support for dragonkind in this high-stakes deathmatch. Dragons are friends, not food.

[Doctor Drew]

Like last game scum!KKFC flew under the radar with pretty much 0 pressure on him so we wanted to see what would happen if there's votes on him

The votes on me were the most obvious reaction bait ever considering besides you the other two people who voted had a combined one relevant post at the time.

Not buying a lot of the logic related to traitor/lawyer signaling. Way more indicative ways to do it in a game with two voting mechanisms, imo?

I thought I had worked it out, but it has now become apparent I was wrong. I haven't decided what that means about you yet.

Can you do me a favor and make the connection you originally missed obvious to me? I remember remarking at the time that your logic was tenuous but hopefully I can see why it's totally broken at this point in the game.

Katy,

Do you understand how the multiquote function works?

Not trying to be an ass, just a genuine question.

[KatyKimFanClub]

Yes haha. I like to make separate posts because it makes it easier to go back and reread them as different ideas.

[Abnegation]

i don't understand why de70 is getting voted. ranger has a gut feeling and the rest of you are voting there because...why?
i don't think they've done anything scummy so would appreciate if someone would explain.

I'm showing my support for dragonkind in this high-stakes deathmatch. Dragons are friends, not food.

have you tried dragon though? they taste pretty good.

[Doctor Drew]

Yes haha. I like to make separate posts because it makes it easier to go back and reread them as different ideas.

Except that you don't.

11 is funny. At least I thought so first when reading and then in 285 usesPython decides they wanted 7 people? Shouldn't this thought have come immediately or at least during the discussion of inventions?

Don't like Abnegation game start such as 28.

I don't get all the people saying it's town!dragon. Any links to read where he does this as town? In fact, 43 and 47 seems like a specific evolution of this trope to make him look towny. Not really a scumread but more of a at this point.

I like Ranger's chain of logic in 97.

Did previous game have cult? Maybe the name of the cult is the same from both games.

Mechanics talk seems +town. I like 215.

Why doesn't Titus want to use pick invention Night 1 in 255? What is a better alternative?

I think usesPython is town.

HURT: KKFC, usesPython, Radical Rat, Ranger, Rautherdir, Morning Tweet, biancospino

VOTE: WhemeStar

I notice a lot of talk about finding trustworthy people to put in the Nightmare. I would like to say that I am town, thus feel free to put me in there, coach(es).

Yuck.

I like we were are on the same page Titus, a whole lotta yuck here.

Was just trying to have a fun intro into the game as a replacement (also it would be nice to be in the Nightmare sort of like how it was fun to be picked on the dodgeball team in 5th grade)

---

Why does Ranger think I'm the most towny person here? I've never played with Ranger, Titus, Doctor Drew, or Wheme before, so it's interesting to see the range of reactions to my few posts.

Idk why people think my removing Rauth from nightmare list is scummy. It seems like their usefulness in the mechanics debate as a foil/devil's advocate against IC is over now.

I was very null on Doctor Drew before 560. It's definitely doesn't very town for him to get added to the nightmare but also I am confused since he was at N-2 (heh) and it was super likely he was going to get into anyways? Maybe it's a paired ability or something?

I know part of 577 was a joke but it makes sense for Radical Rat to scumread me after a couple of my failed mechanics posts.

It's +town for Abnegation to notice Drew wasn't at 10 votes to Run the Nightmare in 590. Maybe Abnegation/Doctor Drew are opposite teams?

Also still pretty skeptical of people saying they do or don't get townvibes from me. I've completed one game on this site.

I think I want to see the VCs before I make more comments.

Finally able to get onto the site to post.

I like how Radical Rat is trying to figure out who put Drew into the Nightmare, but isn't it more likely that scum were talking in their own PT about doing this? I could see how if they're talking in there they would intentionally not talk in here during the time Drew was added to the Nightmare.

Interesting "neither confirm nor deny" post from Ranger though. The discussion around the post reads either like 1) a game starved for progressing posts or 2) post that actually hit scum?

You and Alianna had a chat in your PT to make sure she could get post 1000?

[KatyKimFanClub]

Honestly now I'm confused because I was pretty sure I was consistently multi-posting when rereading. Maybe it's a question of real life setups? I don't mean anything intentional by it.

[Aureal]

Oh my gosh, is Drew actually trying to scumread KKFC and Abnegation over whether multiple posts are made or not??? Maybe this is town Drew after all. XD

[Doctor Drew]

Oh my gosh, is Drew actually trying to scumread KKFC and Abnegation over whether multiple posts are made or not??? Maybe this is town Drew after all. XD

What's so crazy about it?

I just pointed out a hypocrisy, and Alianna always wants post 1000.....there is a smoking gun.

[Abnegation]

ok, i am never voting drew this game.

[KatyKimFanClub]

Oh my gosh, is Drew actually trying to scumread KKFC and Abnegation over whether multiple posts are made or not??? Maybe this is town Drew after all. XD

What's so crazy about it?

I just pointed out a hypocrisy, and Alianna always wants post 1000.....there is a smoking gun.

I don't think hypocrisy is the right word here?

[Random Nurse]

I'm going to attempt reading through this game from day 1. I'm at work so that makes things difficult.

[KatyKimFanClub]

I just reread all of my posts and posting habits. Whether I'm posting a bunch of replies or responses in one post versus a chain of multiple has nothing to do with game state. Feel free to read over my posts (I actually encourage this because so far there's been a pretty wide range of reads on me?) and look for signal in my posting patterns but there definitely isn't an intentional one.


As for why Drew is pointing this out, I think this is even more tenuous than the original RR post about timing and Ranger putting Drew in a nightmare. I feel like it's supposed to be tongue-in-cheek? Then again, he is voting Abnegation and his vote on me in 516 does exist.

[Merlyn]

Oh my gosh, is Drew actually trying to scumread KKFC and Abnegation over whether multiple posts are made or not??? Maybe this is town Drew after all. XD

What's so crazy about it?

I just pointed out a hypocrisy, and Alianna always wants post 1000.....there is a smoking gun.

Why not vote KKFC instead of Abnegation then if you're for real about this?

[Random Nurse]

Does Merlyn normally ignore questions, or accidentally gloss over them?

[Korina]

Lorem