Veiled Committee Mafia: List Mods Edition [game over]

[Save The Dragons]

Koba probably town

[KatyKimFanClub]

personally i dont see the point in it but I'm assuming ranger has a good reason

The way I see it, it's highly likely that the mods who submitted roles put in themes for each of their roles, like they put in all millers, or all roles that only do things when they die, and so on, so a massclaim might reveal these trends and break the setup or at least force scum into a really awful position.

Also it sounds like a few of our roles fucking suck so there's probably less downside to claiming than normal?

[Cook]

std koba buddying? might have to modify my viewpoint

[DragonEater70]

UNPOPULAR OPINION (please read):

We

shouldn't

massclaim. We also

shouldn't

have a fight between team Koba and team AniX.
I think scum is in the lurkers. Let's wait for them to show up and then vote whoever is scummiest.

[Cook]

dragoneater scum?

[DragonEater70]

btw I'm not opposed to EVER massclaiming, but there's no deadline so we can wait with the massclaim until after lurkers have a chance to contribute

[DragonEater70]

dragoneater scum?

Because?

[DkKoba]

Oh, I was going to make a post detailing all the instances where Koba "gave advice" in a stilted post restricty way but I ended binning the post and my vote change with it. I'll still make the post when I have a moment (hopefully later tonight because I'll be gone from midday tomorrow until midday saturday), but let me get the vote change out of the way first.

Unvote DragonEater70
Vote DkKoba

I have the 'tism and am intentionally putting in an effort to not sound rude/condescending while still trying to get my point across. There's your explanation for "stiltedness".
I will inform you that many a scum player has seen my playstyle, thought it would be an easy slam dunk miselimination, then had it bite them in the ass


For you to get defensive and attempt to deflect onto me instead of explaining yourself in response, is a horrible look. I'm trying to get answers out of you. You still have not given them and then have the audacity to then go as far as to pretend like my speaking style is "scummy".

[DkKoba]

std koba buddying? might have to modify my viewpoint

Or maybe dragoneater is a very easy read and I know they're new and want to help them?
Please don't forget to consider the plausible towny reasons for people doing things b4 you go " super friendly to player = Mafia"

[Save The Dragons]

I wouldn't try to buddy koba lol

[DkKoba]

UNPOPULAR OPINION (please read):

We

shouldn't

massclaim. We also

shouldn't

have a fight between team Koba and team AniX.
I think scum is in the lurkers. Let's wait for them to show up and then vote whoever is scummiest.

Ok well I have a role that specifically can catch out liars wrt role claims so I'm a little biased here towards some level if claiming + the setup isn't balanced at all ergo low power roles should be happy to just claim

And there's a potential of breaking the setup

[xyzzy]

votecount 1.03

a stick, a stone, it's the end of the road

2 players voting for Ranger (Doctor Drew, Alisae)
2 players voting for AniX (DkKoba, Save The Dragons)
2 players voting for DkKoba (camelCasedSnivy, AniX)
1 player voting for Skygazer (Cook)
1 player voting for Ircher (KatyKimFanClub)
1 player voting for Doctor Drew (Ranger)
1 player voting for Alisae (Aureal)
1 player voting for camelCaseSnivy (Ircher)
1 player voting for Aureal (Skygazer)
1 player voting for Save The Dragons (Bingle)

4 players not voting (Random Nurse, JasonWazza, Theta Alpine, DragonEater70)

with 17 votes, it takes 9 to eliminate.

mod notes: Random Nurse has noted an ongoing Thursday through Sunday V/LA.

[Theta Alpine]

it is true that we are in a nonreviewed game

we can consider a massclaim day 1 as there is a potential for a gamebreaking strategy for town

my role would not be part of it but

i think i would advocate for a mass softclaim right now and if we feel like we might have the potential to break the game from that then we can continue into a full claim

i will state again that i do not believe my ability would contribute to a gamebreaking combination though
it is more of insurance at best assuming i could actually use it on town

[Cook]

theta alpine is baiting scum into checking her role

[Cook]

(pgo)

[DragonEater70]

dragoneater scum?

All I'm saying is there's probably at most 1 scum in:

DkKoba
Save The Dragons
AniX
Bingle

There's probably no scum in:

Skygazer
lowercase rautherdir
Katy
Snivy?? (tbh no idea why they're in this category)
Cook?? (I didn't like 327 and 329)

And I think there are several scum in:

Alisae!
Aureal!
Ircher!!
Drew
Ranger
Nurse


Now I might be totally off, but that's what I am thinking.

Pedit: can we please stop rolefishing? It is strictly anti-town to say that someone is baiting scum.

[DragonEater70]

UNPOPULAR OPINION (please read):

We

shouldn't

massclaim. We also

shouldn't

have a fight between team Koba and team AniX.
I think scum is in the lurkers. Let's wait for them to show up and then vote whoever is scummiest.

Ok well I have a role that specifically can catch out liars wrt role claims so I'm a little biased here towards some level if claiming + the setup isn't balanced at all ergo low power roles should be happy to just claim

And there's a potential of breaking the setup

Then we can do that later. We have plenty of time.

[Theta Alpine]

would be pretty bold of me to ask to be turned into a miller as pgo

though for the sake of theory desperate pgo i am not sure how best that would be played since no way to kill any town except millers with that
at that point it would probably just be either playing it straight and saying i have a very powerful role and asking for protection
or going the wifom route and doing much like i have done
just you know
not asking to be turned into a miller since that would turn that role into a terribly anti-town one

[Cook]

I have the 'tism and am intentionally putting in an effort to not sound rude/condescending while still trying to get my point across.

noted

yippee

[Theta Alpine]

also i would prefer to just be called theta
i try to play rather differently across the two accounts

[DragonEater70]

Okay I tell you what. I'm freaking exhausted of this D1 and I don't feel I'm getting anywhere reads wise so I am going to sleep and you guys are probably going to be very active suddenly (because that's how timezones work) and hopefully by tomorrow there will be a wagon I am happy with.

[DragonEater70]

also i would prefer to just be called theta
i try to play rather differently across the two accounts

Sorry

[Cook]

also i would prefer to just be called theta
i try to play rather differently across the two accounts

alrighty theta

[Theta Alpine]

was in response to dragon

it would probably make more sense if i portrayed me and rauth as plural but i do not think i actually qualify as such so we get the complicated way of doing it instead

[Ranger]

I'll catch up and respond properly to everything in about six hours

Canceling this, apologies.

Friend emergency.
I’m in crisis mode to help them,

Indefinitely V/LA