mystery box of silver 15: i'm killing hostages (negotiated)

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

you never know in the world of tommy edman

[Ranger]

which posts radiate scum?

Honestly, all of them. (I really hate that response, yet it applies.) Everything I've seen has made me think scum, not town. It's possible I'm biased. Still, I see what I see and I don't see anything town about you rn.

[DkKoba]

maybe ranger is just chilling in the scum PT with me and we're trolling you

im getting very trolled, by looking a lot better in this interaction, yes

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

bc YOUR pov is so much different from my own POV in how i am seeing these slots and either u are TMIing or u just arbitrarily assigned those reads. seems like an anti-spew method to not explain so its not clear which it is

imagine claiming the POV of someone scumreading you is very different from your POV

like rofl what even is this

[DkKoba]

which posts radiate scum?

Honestly, all of them. (I really hate that response, yet it applies.) Everything I've seen has made me think scum, not town. It's possible I'm biased. Still, I see what I see and I don't see anything town about you rn.

thats bullshit tbh, now i think i got it. pooky told u to tunnel me no matter what in scum pt.

no need for elaboration, pooky likes to openly gloat sometimes.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

if ranger is town and koba is town then obviously ranger's POV is different from koba's POV because Ranger can't see Koba's role PM but Koba can see koba's role PM so what even is this

[DkKoba]

bc YOUR pov is so much different from my own POV in how i am seeing these slots and either u are TMIing or u just arbitrarily assigned those reads. seems like an anti-spew method to not explain so its not clear which it is

imagine claiming the POV of someone scumreading you is very different from your POV

like rofl what even is this

do u think all of rangers reads are preflipped off me then?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

thats bullshit tbh, now i think i got it. pooky told u to tunnel me no matter what in scum pt.

true I told my entire scum team we just had to yeet koba right away or else they will kill us all with their giant death laser

[DkKoba]

do u think ur case against me was that good that ranger should be citing it as a good case?

[DkKoba]

the more BS high standards you try to throw at me, the harder i will throw them back at your weak posts

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I think ranger thinks I'm awesome

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

the more BS high standards you try to throw at me, the harder i will throw them back at your weak posts

lol ok

[Doctor Drew]

This whole back and forth can be summed up by only one thing:

[Ranger]

can't explain ur reads bc theyre not real and just arbitrary tbh

Depends on perspective, honestly. I make snap judgement calls and place people accordingly. Anything can change at any time. None of my reads are particularly solid, not even the scumread on you. I don't see the town vibes from you and see consistent scum vibes. Despite this, you're far weaker a scumread than players I've scumread in other games who I

did

see the townvibes of. There's players I've seen as more town than you who I scumread more than you. In that sense they're very arbitrary.

This said, you've seen my games before. I know you have. You're pretending you haven't. So rn, you're being disingenuous. You already know the process I operate by.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I think the quality of the case doesn't have much to do with whether the target of the case is mafia or town

I'm not here to get my PhD

this is a mafia game on the internet and I don't even think it's that serious to begin with

[DkKoba]

can't explain ur reads bc theyre not real and just arbitrary tbh

Depends on perspective, honestly. I make snap judgement calls and place people accordingly. Anything can change at any time. None of my reads are particularly solid, not even the scumread on you. I don't see the town vibes from you and see consistent scum vibes. Despite this, you're far weaker a scumread than players I've scumread in other games who I

did

see the townvibes of. There's players I've seen as more town than you who I scumread more than you. In that sense they're very arbitrary.

This said, you've seen my games before. I know you have. You're pretending you haven't. So rn, you're being disingenuous. You already know the process I operate by.

what is different this game from ur scumgames?

and no, you actually do detail reads in your towngames, dont BS me.

[DkKoba]

I think the quality of the case doesn't have much to do with whether the target of the case is mafia or town

I'm not here to get my PhD

this is a mafia game on the internet and I don't even think it's that serious to begin with

if ur case is poo poo in basis then its no better than throwing darts

[Skygazer]

this is a mafia game on the internet and I don't even think it's that serious to begin with

hey!! i am taking things very seriously

[DkKoba]

i am going to become the joker

[Doctor Drew]

I do like a good night at the theater from time to time

[Ranger]

393 and 394 are just tautologies
"Why do you scumread me"
"Because you look like scum"

Well yeah. We're still in early game. If someone claims they've got a slam-dunk case for scumreading someone, they're lying. Everything's weak rn. Gut's the most valid reason for a scumread at this stage. We're slowly transitioning out of that with posts like this though, as I believe this was a bad faith argument.

[DkKoba]

viewtopic.php?t=66605&user_select%5B%5D=26805 ranger scumgame, u can see they do the same silly "just trust me" reads where they just say call things "towny" or "scummy"

[DkKoba]

Ranger feels NAI at best to me, I'd want the top tier in 930 explained

Peregrine's play has impressed. I don't see any hints of being informed on aspects of the game, any agenda, or any scum motive/intent behind their posts. I do see signs of solving. I believe the claim, and think it +town.

WhemeStar's been looking progressively more +town as the game unfolds. I've seen evolution in WhemeStar's thoughts and contributions, producing nuanced posts.

Here There Be Dragons are both displaying promising approaches in their perspective. While both are longstanding players capable of faking their contributions thusfar as scum, I've vibed with their...well, vibes, fairly consistently.

an example of town ranger actually capable of elaborating on a read

[Ranger]

I think ranger thinks I'm awesome

Eh, I guess. You're respectably competent. You've excellent knowledge on particular players. You've good insights. You had a read I resonated with. I suppose that qualifies as thinking you're awesome.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I think the quality of the case doesn't have much to do with whether the target of the case is mafia or town

I'm not here to get my PhD

this is a mafia game on the internet and I don't even think it's that serious to begin with

if ur case is poo poo in basis then its no better than throwing darts

nah