mystery box of silver 15: i'm killing hostages (negotiated)

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

at least koba is hilarious so I guess we keep them around for the lulz

[ofrhz]

Ok, I paid attention to ofrhz. Mostly the things It's Highness pointed out in #472.

I read Ranger and ofrhz combined ISOs. From #15 to #91 it's all Ranger (including her readlists). From #97 to #112 it's all ofrhz talking about things other than Ranger. The next post from either of them is ofrhz's "serious" vote on Ranger, which he later explains was because of Ranger's readlists.

I agree, this development makes 0 sense. ofrhz voted without a reason, and then invented a reason when questioned.

VOTE: ofrhz

The omgus within me must respond to this. How much trajectory do you think I should have had from 97 to 112?

[DkKoba]

viewtopic.php?t=86228&hilit=fbi

this is a game that shows how pooky treats my slot as town when i am actually scum, for reference, huuuuuuge difference.

[DkKoba]

also you can see he is actually poking around other slots and all that there to get to that conclusion, he just decided i was scum here and just kept calling me scum. he is capable of showing reasoning for reads

[Doctor Drew]

also you can see he is actually poking around other slots and all that there to get to that conclusion, he just decided i was scum here and just kept calling me scum. he is capable of showing reasoning for reads

Isn't this the issue you had with Ranger? Which now somehow you two townread each other????

[DkKoba]

oh wait i misremembered that was tunneling morph but still a good example of how pooky actually treats scumreads lol

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

you mean I tunnel them right off the bat and offer them a bop just like i'm doing to you

great example

[DkKoba]

also you can see he is actually poking around other slots and all that there to get to that conclusion, he just decided i was scum here and just kept calling me scum. he is capable of showing reasoning for reads

Isn't this the issue you had with Ranger? Which now somehow you two townread each other????

ranger's play and pooky's play is like miles apart so kinda obvious how i townread ranger and not pooky

[DkKoba]

you mean I tunnel them right off the bat and offer them a bop just like i'm doing to you

great example

that wasnt my point, nice try tho

[Doctor Drew]

also you can see he is actually poking around other slots and all that there to get to that conclusion, he just decided i was scum here and just kept calling me scum. he is capable of showing reasoning for reads

Isn't this the issue you had with Ranger? Which now somehow you two townread each other????

ranger's play and pooky's play is like miles apart so kinda obvious how i townread ranger and not pooky

Yet you use the same vernacular in your defense.

Gotcha.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I don't really care about your read on me because

(1) if you ever elim me then town will see i'm town and probably deadsheep me and kill you next and trading 1 for 1 is fine in nightless
(2) if the town doesnt they deserve to lose and i wont care either lol

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

but it is entertaining to watch you flail tho

[DkKoba]

also you can see he is actually poking around other slots and all that there to get to that conclusion, he just decided i was scum here and just kept calling me scum. he is capable of showing reasoning for reads

Isn't this the issue you had with Ranger? Which now somehow you two townread each other????

ranger's play and pooky's play is like miles apart so kinda obvious how i townread ranger and not pooky

Yet you use the same vernacular in your defense.

Gotcha.

ranger stop reading, explain your progression on my slot. now.

Recency bias. I've not seen xyzzy post more recently to see their scumminess. I hadn't seen HighPrincessErinys post recently to see their scumminess. I did see you and ofrhz post. I also have seen the interactions of you with other slots, and the caliber of the players who scumread you, as well as their cases. In particular, I believe Pooky's was good.

xyzzy will likely plummet down the moment I see them post again and am reminded why I put them so low.

or u know maybe pooky lacks analysis and a broader view on the game like this, crazy thought amirite

[DkKoba]

that one post is townier than pooky's entire ISO

[DkKoba]

town pooky is NEVER this narrowminded in a game, especially when he has so many slots he can sort. dude is shallower than a dry puddle, and if you dont believe me, go through his iso, and prove me wrong.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

town pooky is NEVER this narrowminded in a game, especially when he has so many slots he can sort. dude is shallower than a dry puddle, and if you dont believe me, go through his iso, and prove me wrong.

mmhmm

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

VOTE: koba

my only goal in this game is to somehow get to be the first person to be knocked out of the park by my boy Tommy Edman come hell or high water

I'm not going to give reads on anyone

its almost like I said I was going to do this :eyeroll:

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

if anything this is actually p townie because scum want to look townie so people dont ask why the hell they haven't been hit by a home run but I'm town so I don't give a shit

[Doctor Drew]

ok im just gonna park VOTE: ranger

this game's vibes are insufferable bc there is so much bad faith going around, impossible standards for slots being tunneled(yeah maybe think about whether the person you are pushing, if you applied the standards you are giving them to anyone else, how would you feel about that slot?), and no interactivity with anyone


also drew quite frankly, i am very insulted that you called my genuine reasoning not explaining anything.
the fuck am i supposed to say? i gave my genuine reason. accept it or dont, dont accuse me of not explaining anything just because you failed to comprehend what i said

ranger stop reading, explain your progression on my slot. now.

Recency bias. I've not seen xyzzy post more recently to see their scumminess. I hadn't seen HighPrincessErinys post recently to see their scumminess. I did see you and ofrhz post. I also have seen the interactions of you with other slots, and the caliber of the players who scumread you, as well as their cases. In particular, I believe Pooky's was good.

xyzzy will likely plummet down the moment I see them post again and am reminded why I put them so low.

there is no case against me

"zomg why is koba not pushing for an optimal speedrun strat" is a really shit case lmao wtf

like u clearly havent actually read what pooky has said bc he didnt actually have a scumread when he initially pushed me LMAO so wondering where the trust came from

koba is like outted scum atp for real

koba is like outted scum atp for real

i know this looks like a read but if its wrong its scummy af so I have to go for it

also the reason I think koba is town is because they know enough about setup and they are ruthlessly good at abusing setup quirks so the fact they didnt lead off with the speedrun strat is p lolscumclaimy to me

also popping in and claiming they've seen enough from me when im spamming the shit out of this thread is pretty ? like id imagine if they were town they'd at least be fighting me for thread control instead of just popping in saying three words and disappearing on me

ranger, please explain to me why you thought this was a good case

lol talking to a bunch of walls

ngl i also dont get the strong townread on pooky bc pooky has not towntold yet

Hi Ranger, would you like to put your read of me into words?

I know nothing of you, yet you look like scum.

vague, no evidence, also counter argument, their posts are townier than several players you put in your upper half, including alisae for instance:

Pooky, you cannot pocket me, not least because 3/5ths of me did not exist before late 2022, and Ad (the other one who did) has all the emotional depth of a puddle of concrete.

Did pooky do something that makes you think they're pocketing you?

VOTE: ranger

like the most obvious play is to just speedrun the shit out of this game to increase the homer to lim lim ratio

i wasnt going to say this broken strat because i think this setup is broken but then i remember schadd trolling me when I was scum with a "disloyal vig" in a game with 2 protectives and the mafia literally had no way to block the vig or anything and I remembered Schadd just makes townsided nonsense setups and we should abuse it as much as possible.

I think pooky is town

Why is the dr. drew town for instance?

It's weak, but he vibes town so far.

This is basically a non answer

like i kinda like the vibe behind these posts tbh and their point about ranger makes me wanna go into ranger now

why is meuh so much higher than me

Meuh naturally vibes as town.

You radiate scum.

which posts radiate scum?

VOTE: ranger
yeah im not buying this actually

Annnddddd these were your next posts after the one you quoted koba.

Where exactly did you feel better about Ranger?

[DkKoba]

"scum want to look townie" like youre doing now by trying to justify your play as townie?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

"scum want to look townie" like youre doing now by trying to justify your play as townie?

no cuz schadd is the only person deciding who is scummy or not when he tommy edmans someone and this line of reasoning doesnt work with him

[DkKoba]

thats like page 1 and it doesnt mean shit pooky, we're here, the gamestate is clearly way past that, and clearly you changed your mind later about "making reads" because you decided to push me as a read. so no, sorry, shit excuse.

and now we got an implicit admission that pooky knows that he as scum would be this shallow at this point

[Doctor Drew]

ou stui

"scum want to look townie" like youre doing now by trying to justify your play as townie?

You literally didn't explain the whole truth.

Fuck off with this bullshit.

I can go on if you would like?

When exactly did you town read Ranger?

Quote that for me please.

[DkKoba]

"scum want to look townie" like youre doing now by trying to justify your play as townie?

no cuz schadd is the only person deciding who is scummy or not when he tommy edmans someone and this line of reasoning doesnt work with him

ok but ur not selling that your "im not making reads" thing is genuine lmao

[DkKoba]

ou stui

"scum want to look townie" like youre doing now by trying to justify your play as townie?

You literally didn't explain the whole truth.

Fuck off with this bullshit.

I can go on if you would like?

When exactly did you town read Ranger?

Quote that for me please.

read my iso genius, you quoted a bunch of posts for a gotcha, theres a very obvious point where i did