Only if I were one.In post 1123, Civil Scum wrote: If you were one of the top elimination targets in D-1 as a scum, would you ever consider claiming JK and claim a strong read on a townie based on a lack of vigilantes, such that you would be in essence fishing for two counter claims at once?
You’re being a roleblocker AND a docIn post 1126, Civil Scum wrote: Why is it hard to fake claim?
how confident are you that bob is town?In post 1103, Hu Tao wrote:I disagree. He seems similarIn post 1050, Random Nurse wrote: Bob feels more... different... this game.
Can you explain this a bit more. In what ways might a person tip off scum to their being a PR?In post 889, Naerys wrote: I was trying to avoid attention. Especially the scum, since i didnt want to get nked at n1. It doesnt really matter, does it?
In post 1086, Civil Scum wrote:What I said about PC mentioning his own rereading while not feeling like saying much is completely out of line with his personality and style.In post 1075, Save The Dragons wrote: CS can you give a short case of why you think PC is scum
VOTE: Bella for now
I believe this assessment will resonate strongly with KKFC who has played with him recently.
In post 904, Naerys wrote:Not everyone is as creative as you.In post 903, Save The Dragons wrote: I think
A
More
Tactical approach to crumbing
Ought to be used
When crumbing
Now
Yeah I’ve been overboard but almost no one has posted in like two days so…In post 1134, Political Clout wrote: There is something to be said about letting the thread breathe and allowing for interactions between other players. At present someone is allowing scum to hide.
I'm not that confident. I think my other town reads are stronger. But he sounds like last game and he was town then soIn post 1129, Political Clout wrote:how confident are you that bob is town?In post 1103, Hu Tao wrote:I disagree. He seems similarIn post 1050, Random Nurse wrote: Bob feels more... different... this game.
at the very least I don't want him today
In post 1125, iamveryhappy wrote:Only if I were one.In post 1123, Civil Scum wrote: If you were one of the top elimination targets in D-1 as a scum, would you ever consider claiming JK and claim a strong read on a townie based on a lack of vigilantes, such that you would be in essence fishing for two counter claims at once?
jk is not an easy role to fakeclaim, bear that in mind
In post 1126, Civil Scum wrote: Why is it hard to fake claim?
Yep easier for scum just to claim something like doc/bg, so if naerys was scum it would far more likely that it would be a true claim. And if the player was fishing for roles before their flip then there are better claims too. So either naerys is scum 2 shot jk or rookie town 2 shot jkIn post 1127, iamveryhappy wrote:You’re being a roleblocker AND a docIn post 1126, Civil Scum wrote: Why is it hard to fake claim?
I'm not sure what you want me to explain further, sorryIn post 1128, Civil Scum wrote: I’m pretty new to a lot PRs. Can you explain this further for a PR newb such as myself?
whats is the airspeed velocity of unladen swallow?In post 1143, Looker wrote: Hello, I'm here - is there anything I should know? Or are you willing to wait until I read all 46 pages? UNVOTE:
Spoiler:
I'd like you to read up yourself and tell us you think.In post 1143, Looker wrote: Hello, I'm here - is there anything I should know? Or are you willing to wait until I read all 46 pages? UNVOTE:
Spoiler:
I still don’t understand why it’s harder to fake claim JK than BG or Cop.In post 1142, iamveryhappy wrote:I'm not sure what you want me to explain further, sorryIn post 1128, Civil Scum wrote: I’m pretty new to a lot PRs. Can you explain this further for a PR newb such as myself?
So let me get this straight, JK can also be a scum role, therefore Naerys might have “truly” claimed complex JK. This means she might have done so without realizing that it ran counter to her assumption about vigilantes.In post 1141, bob3141 wrote:In post 1125, iamveryhappy wrote:Only if I were one.In post 1123, Civil Scum wrote: If you were one of the top elimination targets in D-1 as a scum, would you ever consider claiming JK and claim a strong read on a townie based on a lack of vigilantes, such that you would be in essence fishing for two counter claims at once?
jk is not an easy role to fakeclaim, bear that in mindIn post 1126, Civil Scum wrote: Why is it hard to fake claim?Yep easier for scum just to claim something like doc/bg, so if naerys was scum it would far more likely that it would be a true claim. And if the player was fishing for roles before their flip then there are better claims too. So either naerys is scum 2 shot jk or rookie town 2 shot jkIn post 1127, iamveryhappy wrote:You’re being a roleblocker AND a docIn post 1126, Civil Scum wrote: Why is it hard to fake claim?
being a jailkeeper fakeclaim is 100% harder than being a cop/doc/bg fakeclaimIn post 1146, Civil Scum wrote:I still don’t understand why it’s harder to fake claim JK than BG or Cop.In post 1142, iamveryhappy wrote:I'm not sure what you want me to explain further, sorryIn post 1128, Civil Scum wrote: I’m pretty new to a lot PRs. Can you explain this further for a PR newb such as myself?
So let me get this straight, JK can also be a scum role, therefore Naerys might have “truly” claimed complex JK. This means she might have done so without realizing that it ran counter to her assumption about vigilantes.In post 1141, bob3141 wrote:In post 1125, iamveryhappy wrote:Only if I were one.In post 1123, Civil Scum wrote: If you were one of the top elimination targets in D-1 as a scum, would you ever consider claiming JK and claim a strong read on a townie based on a lack of vigilantes, such that you would be in essence fishing for two counter claims at once?
jk is not an easy role to fakeclaim, bear that in mindIn post 1126, Civil Scum wrote: Why is it hard to fake claim?Yep easier for scum just to claim something like doc/bg, so if naerys was scum it would far more likely that it would be a true claim. And if the player was fishing for roles before their flip then there are better claims too. So either naerys is scum 2 shot jk or rookie town 2 shot jkIn post 1127, iamveryhappy wrote:You’re being a roleblocker AND a docIn post 1126, Civil Scum wrote: Why is it hard to fake claim?
That’s interesting and might mean that I need to adjust my scum pool for PC-Naerys-X since the third scum no longer need be a mastermind. I think I got on that idea based on how newbie the earlyness of the claim seemed coupled with someone saying they thought the complex modifier running counter to her vigilante assumption was further evidence of her newbie-ness.
And you´ll not see it this time either.In post 1147, iamveryhappy wrote: tbh I have never seen a mafia jk in my mafia career, not even in closed setups