Mini Normal 2314 - The Mafia Have a Cop [END]

[Hu Tao]

Doctor Drew - seems similar to usual, so possibly town

Could you also go into your Drew read?

Maybe you just aren't reading me. Cause I've posted about this as well but I'll quote it

[Gamma Emerald]

"reaction to everything" is rather vague, could you try to distill that thought? I think I've already covered why I approached FL's claim the way I did much earlier.

[Gamma Emerald]

Doctor Drew - seems similar to usual, so possibly town

Could you also go into your Drew read?

Maybe you just aren't reading me. Cause I've posted about this as well but I'll quote it

I was hoping for a brief recap of your progression ftr

[Hu Tao]

Can it be as simple as some sort of combo of Hu/Bulge/Gamma?

No way you think this as an actual read. Drew might be scum here.

Can it be as simple as some sort of combo of Hu/Bulge/Gamma?

u forgot to include urself

drew if thats ur solve why r u on gera

He's scum that's why

Should I just hammer without a claim for the funny?

I'm gonna say no

Did this as a test for gamma. She's likely scum who knows bulge is town. Otherwise would have unvoted after

Like, how would Hu know that Gamma would be the one to respond to their post?

VOTE: Hu

This is CLEAR scum post as fake reasoning to vote someone when it's obvious the answer

suuuure

Should I just hammer without a claim for the funny?

I'm gonna say no

Gonna do it

Look at the time of these posts

Can it be as simple as some sort of combo of Hu/Bulge/Gamma?

Should I just hammer without a claim for the funny?

I'm gonna say no

Did this as a test for gamma. She's likely scum who knows bulge is town. Otherwise would have unvoted after

Like, how would Hu know that Gamma would be the one to respond to their post?

VOTE: Hu

Imo these two posts don't make sense. Is he saying that I made it up with my scum partner?

[Gamma Emerald]

Can it be as simple as some sort of combo of Hu/Bulge/Gamma?

I challenge you to justify that as "simple"

while on this subject, I think this post is weird to make if me and Drew are aligned?

[Gamma Emerald]

Can it be as simple as some sort of combo of Hu/Bulge/Gamma?

No way you think this as an actual read. Drew might be scum here.

Can it be as simple as some sort of combo of Hu/Bulge/Gamma?

u forgot to include urself

drew if thats ur solve why r u on gera

He's scum that's why

Should I just hammer without a claim for the funny?

I'm gonna say no

Did this as a test for gamma. She's likely scum who knows bulge is town. Otherwise would have unvoted after

Like, how would Hu know that Gamma would be the one to respond to their post?

VOTE: Hu

This is CLEAR scum post as fake reasoning to vote someone when it's obvious the answer

suuuure

Should I just hammer without a claim for the funny?

I'm gonna say no

Gonna do it

Look at the time of these posts

Can it be as simple as some sort of combo of Hu/Bulge/Gamma?

Should I just hammer without a claim for the funny?

I'm gonna say no

Did this as a test for gamma. She's likely scum who knows bulge is town. Otherwise would have unvoted after

Like, how would Hu know that Gamma would be the one to respond to their post?

VOTE: Hu

Imo these two posts don't make sense. Is he saying that I made it up with my scum partner?

this isn't really what I was looking for, it's just a summary of your thoughts as of now

[Doctor Drew]

Won't quote the post tree Hu......but like I have said the way you got super defensive when I postulated based off the posting by you and Gamma and the timing of it as Bulge was about to be hammered is what became the real read on you.

Me wondering if this could be the scum/traitor combo was simply stream of consciousness while reading the thread in real time.

[Doctor Drew]

Especially since Gamma was working to get the vote back on Dann.

And then after that Gamma launched a tiny offensive my way, and then, as stated you got real defensive and launched a big offensive my way.

All around the time Bulge was about to be hammered.

So, objectively speaking, how couldn't I wonder if you three are connected?

[Gamma Emerald]

my Dann vote was only to test Hu

[Roden]

It would be really cool if the people who are town reading Bulge could actually town case him instead of just whining about the votes

neither here nor there but this is pretty backwards, if there's a wagon on someone without hardly any reasoning then the onus is not on the anti-wagoners to towncase them.

The people voting you explained why they were voting you by scum casing you. The people claiming that you're town have given zero explanation and just keep repeating "Bulge is obvtown" or are pre-flipping other slots to "confirm" you as town.

If I already believe that you're scum and given my thoughts on why by pointing out certain things, I'm not going to suddenly change my mind because people are spamming "obvtown" over and over. I'm baffled that you think it's somehow my responsibility to town case you in this scenario and not the people who are calling you town.

[Doctor Drew]

my Dann vote was only to test Hu

So you two are just going to 'test' each other when deadline is fast approaching and someone is about to be hammered?

[Gamma Emerald]

This is why I specifically challenged you to prove the alleged simplicity of your solve
I think seeing me and Hu Tao interacting that way and concluding we’re associated is a reach, and other evidence points against that solve imo

[Roden]

On the other hand, Hu Tao saying "why would I do X as scum, that's such a bad play and the best thing would be to do nothing" isn't a good look since I used that exact defense last time I rolled scum. It's giving "caught for the wrong reason" vibes.

VOTE: Hu Tao

[Gamma Emerald]

UNVOTE:
I want to hash things out with Hu before the day ends

[Doctor Drew]

This is why I specifically challenged you to prove the alleged simplicity of your solve
I think seeing me and Hu Tao interacting that way and concluding we’re associated is a reach, and other evidence points against that solve imo

It was a simple observation, I don't know how many other ways I can say it wasn't a hardcore 'lock it in' read.

But how you two acted AFTER that, make it much more serious and hardcore of a read.

[Doctor Drew]

On the other hand, Hu Tao saying "why would I do X as scum, that's such a bad play and the best thing would be to do nothing" isn't a good look since I used that exact defense last time I rolled scum. It's giving "caught for the wrong reason" vibes.

VOTE: Hu Tao

Mute point since I believe this was a hammer anyways.

[Gamma Emerald]

On the other hand, Hu Tao saying "why would I do X as scum, that's such a bad play and the best thing would be to do nothing" isn't a good look since I used that exact defense last time I rolled scum. It's giving "caught for the wrong reason" vibes.

VOTE: Hu Tao

Mute point since I believe this was a hammer anyways.

Hu was at 5 last VC and Roden’s was the only new vote I saw

[Doctor Drew]

On the other hand, Hu Tao saying "why would I do X as scum, that's such a bad play and the best thing would be to do nothing" isn't a good look since I used that exact defense last time I rolled scum. It's giving "caught for the wrong reason" vibes.

VOTE: Hu Tao

Mute point since I believe this was a hammer anyways.

Hu was at 5 last VC and Roden’s was the only new vote I saw

In other news, I can't count

[Dannflor]

hu tao i don’t think you expected to actually stop the bulge’s wagon going through?

[Hu Tao]

Yes? I've done it before, why try something I don't think will work?

[Gamma Emerald]

Hu I would appreciate if you would continue our dialogue

[Hu Tao]

What is there to continue?

[Hu Tao]

Can it be as simple as some sort of combo of Hu/Bulge/Gamma?

I challenge you to justify that as "simple"

while on this subject, I think this post is weird to make if me and Drew are aligned?

If you mean this, then I don't think its something that can't come from partners. But I usually don't associate read especially this early. I just look for who I think are scummiest

[Gamma Emerald]

I still want your full progression on Drew

[Hu Tao]

I've played with town Drew before and at the start of the game he looked similar to what I've seen before, so I wrote him off as town. But I don't like his reasoning for his reads lately. Especially the post where he said me bulge and you were scum together. Also he tried to give a reason for a scumread which was able to be countered by just looking at the posts and the timing of the posts. I don't think he would do that if he truly believed what he posted.