In post 77, Dunnstral wrote:
I believe I've played 1 game with them before. I don't like that they voted for somebody who hadn't posted.
We’ve played 2 games together before (Invictus also happened), I tend to vote for non-posters when opening, I like broadening our horizons rather than laser focusing on the handful of slots present at game start, especially if I’m not going to be super present in the few hours after game start
I don't really understand what you mean by parallel or why their read on me would even be relevant to you, you've heavily implied you townread me and it seemed like you townread Dann as well but it looks like you're chipping away looking for weaknesses.
In post 77, Dunnstral wrote:
I believe I've played 1 game with them before. I don't like that they voted for somebody who hadn't posted.
We’ve played 2 games together before (Invictus also happened), I tend to vote for non-posters when opening, I like broadening our horizons rather than laser focusing on the handful of slots present at game start, especially if I’m not going to be super present in the few hours after game start
I don't agree with the philosophy here but appreciate the explanation.
Do you think it's a normal question when you have two townreads who are generally doing the same thing to ask them what their reads on each other are? Do you think I shouldn't be a little skeptical of that line of questioning, Taly?
Isn't it normal to question people you townread if you're trying to prepare for the mercy route? Well, even though it isn't confirmed cause we need to think on Dunnstral but still. To say that's not a townie pov is pretty harsh words!
are you trying to say that you are deducting points from the mandate house
or are you just questioning their read
See, at first it was the former but then I thought it could just be that they're overly analytical and a bit thorny as a personality thing so it became a question to consider if I should take away points from their house.
In post 132, Dunnstral wrote:
We're not preparing for the mercy route yet though, we're trying to figure out who to eliminate for today and tomorrow.
You know I had a really stupid question but instead of embarrassing myself I'm going to simply say you are correct. Do you also townread everyone or does no one give you reason to vote them?
In post 100, Keyleth wrote:
Plus with the whole mercy route that works in favor cause all you gotta do is find the super duper obvious people and yay! You win.
Although I guess you could go the fight route but I just assumed everyone like me joined for the mercy route.
Look at this:
In post 2, Isis wrote:
If Mercy is chosen, for the rest of the game subsequent eliminations are flavored as sparings and town wins if town spares four townies and loses if it spares two mafia.
In post 2, Isis wrote:
The day 3 elimination is Toriel.
This is what I initially missed, if we spare then I end up as one of the spared people, rather than simply leaving the game. So you're not supposed to know what route we are going for yet.
Is this confirmed? I thought toriel went no matter what. 'eliminations are flavored as sparings' , so even if you're spared you're still out right?
In post 132, Dunnstral wrote:
We're not preparing for the mercy route yet though, we're trying to figure out who to eliminate for today and tomorrow.
You know I had a really stupid question but instead of embarrassing myself I'm going to simply say you are correct. Do you also townread everyone or does no one give you reason to vote them?
In post 100, Keyleth wrote:
Plus with the whole mercy route that works in favor cause all you gotta do is find the super duper obvious people and yay! You win.
Although I guess you could go the fight route but I just assumed everyone like me joined for the mercy route.
Look at this:
In post 2, Isis wrote:
If Mercy is chosen, for the rest of the game subsequent eliminations are flavored as sparings and town wins if town spares four townies and loses if it spares two mafia.
In post 2, Isis wrote:
The day 3 elimination is Toriel.
This is what I initially missed, if we spare then I end up as one of the spared people, rather than simply leaving the game. So you're not supposed to know what route we are going for yet.
Is this confirmed? I thought toriel went no matter what. 'eliminations are flavored as sparings' , so even if you're spared you're still out right?
Yes but if we spare I count towards one of the sparings. So it would be bad if I were mafia. Mechanically, that's the only reason we would not spare in this setup.
In post 100, Keyleth wrote:
Plus with the whole mercy route that works in favor cause all you gotta do is find the super duper obvious people and yay! You win.
Although I guess you could go the fight route but I just assumed everyone like me joined for the mercy route.
Look at this:
In post 2, Isis wrote:
If Mercy is chosen, for the rest of the game subsequent eliminations are flavored as sparings and town wins if town spares four townies and loses if it spares two mafia.
In post 2, Isis wrote:
The day 3 elimination is Toriel.
This is what I initially missed, if we spare then I end up as one of the spared people, rather than simply leaving the game. So you're not supposed to know what route we are going for yet.
Is this confirmed? I thought toriel went no matter what. 'eliminations are flavored as sparings' , so even if you're spared you're still out right?
Yes but if we spare I count towards one of the sparings. So it would be bad if I were mafia. Mechanically, that's the only reason we would not spare in this setup.
I think that mandate is likely not scum with anyone who has misunderstood the setup (Dunn, Dann, Key, Merlyn). This is also slightly likely for implosion, Alisae, and potentially Shirou.
