I guess that makes sense. I think I just find the conviction in your read and lack of interaction unnatural but it's probably just a playstyle clashIn post 797, Titus wrote:My biggest SR is the last person I want to engage with. It gives them the opportunity to look town. Doubly so when it's the absence of things that's scummy.In post 793, Black wrote:What makes you think this? I felt that earlier but it has kinda weakened lately. Her last 40 posts have been about K + T3 + mystery partner and she townreads the other 10 players which kinda seems like a town tunnel but I can see a world where Titus is just using this theory as a way to seem busy. It doesn't really feel like she's trying to solve anyone. I would expect her to engage with Kurtapika at some point considering he's her biggest SR but she doesn't seem to have any interest in doing thatIn post 792, Skygazer wrote: Titus seems town
1) Your main reason for SRing me that you've stated is because of my push on you. If I was pushing someone else, interactions would be completely different - how can you say that you'd be SRing me even if I was pushing someone else without knowing how those interactions would go?In post 667, JupiterXV wrote: also you haven't pushed anyone besides me. if you were pushing someone else i would still be scumreading you. i've been asking you about your reasoning and you've just let those responses drop. there's no reason for me to rescind my scumread when your responses on me are still scummy
So (fully acknowledge I am 48 hours behind commenting on this) I think the whole debacle is kinda bizarre, but upon reflection I think I still townread JupiterIn post 520, Bellaphant wrote: I can't work out if Jupiter admitting to lying twice in like five pages is as scummy as it seems....
Yup, I actually asked Kurtapika if they had any scumreads and they didn’t even answer (I think you were actually there for that)In post 774, Titus wrote: If you look at K's posting, K still won't call anyone scum. People could be scum. He'd want a flip on AK but yet doesn't vote.
K completely deflects the fact that there's no follow up on T3.
Why do you townread Kurtapika again???
I’m also tired of him but I’m still a little bit sure he’s town. Can you explain your scumreadIn post 783, Black wrote: VOTE: Afrayed Knott
Kinda just tired of this dude and I think there's a decent chance he flips scum
Someone wagon this with me
1. Iirc, you called my push on you OMGUS or something along those lines. What I’m trying to say is if you made that push on literally anyone else for the same reason I’d also find it absurd.In post 802, shaddowez wrote:1) Your main reason for SRing me that you've stated is because of my push on you. If I was pushing someone else, interactions would be completely different - how can you say that you'd be SRing me even if I was pushing someone else without knowing how those interactions would go?In post 667, JupiterXV wrote: also you haven't pushed anyone besides me. if you were pushing someone else i would still be scumreading you. i've been asking you about your reasoning and you've just let those responses drop. there's no reason for me to rescind my scumread when your responses on me are still scummy
2) So am I letting my responses drop, or are they scummy? You may not like them and SR them, but saying I'm not responding is disingenuous at best. In 420 I respond to your 288, in 470 I respond to your 233.
Already asked this question, Titus said she thought they’re independently scummy as well and would continue to push themIn post 804, shaddowez wrote:@Titus- Do both of your other reads change if the first of any of them to flip are town?
There seem to be a lot of associative reads in this game, which is great until they're not.
People who aren’t voting me have also talked about it and I think Afrayed has been a bit shitty to me so I don’t know how you expect me to react to this in a winning fashionIn post 796, shaddowez wrote:I've been asking myself the same question - they could be AtE, but more of them do feel genuine than not. My problem is they have two votes on them, and seem to be lashing out about one particular item that only the two people currently voting them have even really brought up.In post 769, Afrayed Knott wrote: I am not sure about Jupiter's outbursts, are they genuine or an act
I was engaged but I'm finding the last few pages hard: I don't know if black is scum but she is sure seeming to be jumpy at /everyone/.In post 809, Aisa wrote: Bella's posting this game feels a bit different from what I am used to frombothher town game and her scum game! Granted it's been a few months since we last were in a game together, I think
She seems a bit more engaged than what I am used to and looks a bit more towny
I feel a bit less indignant about her read on me now and am talking myself into townleaning her
I think I initially underestimated how similar Black's posting is between Open 888 and here and assumed Afrayed was being stubborn. I;ve just tkaen another look and at least superficially there are similaritiesIn post 413, Afrayed Knott wrote:Not sure on this to be frank. I was liking their recent posts, But I'm more centred on exploring Black as a choice.In post 401, Dannflor wrote: I would appreciate it if people who think I am likely to be town would also vote kurtapika
we haven't had an actual wagon of more than like 3 votes take off and I think kurtapika is someone who has a very decent chance of flipping red
I will try to explain.
I was reading Black's earlier posts and I just got feeling I have seen this before. You will probably recall the game I am talking about, as you replaced her. The slot was scum and this is the game I referred to as your capable and very skilled attempt to confuse town and mislead them during the closing play of the game which nearly paid off but fortunately for town it didn't, the game was Open 888. (viewtopic.php?t=91754) That is why I asked the question in 325 . The posts she makes in that game and their content are very similar to her play in early in this game.
Then Bella's response and your response to that question, pretty much have started to confirm this thought in my mind. I know you both don't fully commit to saying she is scum, but your replies do push my thought that way. Am I right? I am beginning to feel I am, and would say it maybe worth a go.
VOTE: Black
In post 819, Bellaphant wrote: Like it's a fine for day one read? It's probs as strong as my knot read, which is very mid.
This was referring to BellaIn post 821, Aisa wrote: Yep that makes sense, sorry the post wasn't meant as a direct response to you, just similar timing
