Eminence in Shadow: Season 1 [Game Over]

[jjh927]

Additional powers could have been bestowed with more developed reads, and also Alisae would have been a bulletproof IC

Also, increasing likelihood of scum finding conclusively who Cid is due to an action failing

[jjh927]

Like, that just should have happened day 3 or maybe even day 2

[T3]

Ohhh never mind I'm stupid

[Sakura Hana]

I think it's entirely possible that this game contains bullshit

Do you think we're doing well? We only got 1 miselim left and we're at evens you know, despite having caught 2 scum N1...

I think Alisae should have revealed earlier based on the role PM

While i agree, day 2 we couldnt have eliminated Alisae and Day 3 we went onto Pooky, which if Pooky hadnt used vig shot it was probably the correct way to go either way.

[jjh927]

But I'm saying that with the hindsight of Alisae having just died so that maybe colours my perception and perhaps I am being harsh there

[Sakura Hana]

Well, do we not know that Gamma specifically did the gladiate? How would Klick getting the power from Cid mean that Gamma does the gladiate?

That's how he got caught, STD tracked him specifically to both Klick and Luka

Well yes, but did you not say that you're suspicious of Klick because you think he got the gladiate power?? Or am I misunderstanding something.

I did.
If scum has to put a teammate in the gladiate that means one of Klick or Luka would be scum and Luka flipped town.
But once again that's me outguessing the mod, and im probably still alive for doing stupid stuff like that.

[jjh927]

I actually misunderstood that then

I thought Cid could just reveal as shadow without having to get eliminated first

[Sakura Hana]

Ugh, this game is starting to get on my nerves i should probably stop playing so seriously.

[Sakura Hana]

I was kinda hoping to be dead already

[T3]

Oh I didn't realize that either wrt Alisae having to be limmed

[jjh927]

It might be that pooky did use the vig kill on Alisae and it failed

[jjh927]

Anyway, I'm gonna go to bed

Please make sure wheme claims because he definitely needs to

[Sakura Hana]

It might be that pooky did use the vig kill on Alisae and it failed

Pooky wasnt multitasking so no.

[Klick]

As for the other half, i just think it's more balanced if scum has to include a teammate in the gladiate, of course i guess that might just be me trying to outguess the mod.
Ugh

Firebringer had to include a disclaimer on this game to say that balance was not guaranteed

Do you have opinions on my play that back up your thoughts on the setup?

[Sakura Hana]

Please make sure wheme claims because he definitely needs to

I dont think he

needs

to, but i dont think there's a point in hiding anymore if he's town. Scum already know all PRs

[jjh927]

It might be that pooky did use the vig kill on Alisae and it failed

Pooky wasnt multitasking so no.

I just assume multitasking generally speaking but sure, if we go down that route then why do you think pooky didn't use both of his vig shots
Did he vig on n1 and then do the scum nightkill on n2 without using his vig?

[Sakura Hana]

Do you have opinions on my play that back up your thoughts on the setup?

I thought your entrance to the game was a bit one dimmensional, and other than your case on kawaii I havent seen anything that jumps at me that says "wow so town". And literally the only reason i had for townreading you was "Why would scum eliminate a potential miselim in Kawaii like that"

[Sakura Hana]

It might be that pooky did use the vig kill on Alisae and it failed

Pooky wasnt multitasking so no.

I just assume multitasking generally speaking but sure, if we go down that route then why do you think pooky didn't use both of his vig shots
Did he vig on n1 and then do the scum nightkill on n2 without using his vig?

Either that, or he used his 2nd vig shot on N2 and the scum factional kill went missing, which is looking likelier now that i think about it.

[Klick]

Okay but is there any reason I'm scum

I feel like my interactions with Pooky on D1 are more clearing than the D2 nomination thing frankly

[Sakura Hana]

Imagine this scenario, scum shoots the 2 people that got guilties, but one of them survives and uses that info to guilty more the other person. Scum has no reason to shoot me again and expect it to succeed so they vanillize me instead coz they dont know where the interference is.
Now that Alisae dropped all the PR'd players, scum knows.

There's 2 scenarios.
Whemestar is a roleblocker that blocked Gamma N2 making the factional kill.
Whemestar is a doctor that healed me N2.

And i'm gonna be very mad if it's the former and you'll know why later.

[Sakura Hana]

Okay but is there any reason I'm scum

I feel like my interactions with Pooky on D1 are more clearing than the D2 nomination thing frankly

You're right, I forgot i townread you for that as well.

[Sakura Hana]

I probably mentioned it somewhere and forgot coz i started doubting my entire reads

[jjh927]

Your spec is off

Also, new question

Why didn't pooky just claim the vig

[Sakura Hana]

Your spec is off

Also, new question

Why didn't pooky just claim the vig

He didnt know the nature of the guilty, coz i was very vague D2 and he just claimed VT instead.

[jjh927]

He claimed vanilla in a game where cid literally gave him a role and there are last wills