JOAT uPick | FIN!

[Relativistic Harmony]

but apparently it is impossible to perspective slip as town so pooky is apparently scum

like what in the universe is this mercury logic (not even moon logic at this point)?

-TL

Where did Pooky perspective slip?

nowhere

I never say pooky perspective slipped, I said pooky was spewed as town by Bell's perspective slip

-TL

[Dunnstral]

Well then I don't get what you are saying in 1748.

[Relativistic Harmony]

Well then I don't get what you are saying in 1748.

apparently I should scumread pooky because if bell is town then bell did not perspective slip so pooky is not spewed town

-TL

[lemon.tangerine]

Well then I don't get what you are saying in 1748.

apparently I should scumread pooky because if bell is town then bell did not perspective slip so pooky is not spewed town

-TL

and why is it not t/t violence?

[Dunnstral]

Well then I don't get what you are saying in 1748.

apparently I should scumread pooky because if bell is town then bell did not perspective slip so pooky is not spewed town

-TL

Who said this?

[Sakura Hana]

I don't even know what a perspective slip is, i thought people's issue with Bell was the claim.

[Sakura Hana]

But why are you treating Bell like he already flipped scum?

[Firebringer]

perspective slip means you let it slip you know X is town when you shouldn't know that

[Sakura Hana]

Isn't that just a scumslip

[Sakura Hana]

Why do people change the names of things, it confuses me

[Relativistic Harmony]

When catching up I was leaning scum on Pooky because I don't think Bell is mafia and I do think the push has been looking like how Pooky plays as mafia, as Bell has pointed out.

However I think the last few pages where they are pointing out the flaws in Relativistic Harmony's logic looks like Pooky's town game instead.

Well the last game I played where I spoke to a player about their internal logic not making sense they just didn't "get it" when I explained it to them and instead got defensive about their alignment. This happened here

I'm seeing something similar from Relativistic Harmony here. In post 1694 they talk about how, even without the perspective slip, Pooky is obvious town to them, but I say this is them being confused of what they are being accused of here. They initially said there was a perspective slip and so why would they be voting for Pooky. Basically what they are responding with here is trying to defend themselves but not really addressing the points being made... and from my experience this disconnect means they are more likely to be mafia. I was also souring on them while catching up.

VOTE: Relativistic Harmony

probably this post

if not then i have no idea and should probably just sleep

pedit: bell's evolving claims are also something I scumread bell for

also if bell was confirmed scum I wouldn't be asking bell to explain the vote on pooky

-TL

[Dunnstral]

I certainly did not say that Pooky is mafia because Bell perspective slipped in that post

[Sakura Hana]

Anyway, if slipping that you know someone's town when you shouldn't is a perspective slip, and the quoted posts are the ones where Bell perspective slipped i'm not putting much stock into it, from personal experience i've made similar posts multiple times as town in the past, it comes from a mindset of assuming good faith with another player thinking it's possible they are town and wrong.

The reason i voted Pooky was because his posting early in the game and then the tunneling came from a mindset of assigning Bell the alignment 'Scum' and then finding evidence to fit it, Pooky having a shock at Harmony and disengaging from the tunnel leads me to believe that he was just probably just tunneling and not scum trying to miselim the "hard to miselim Town-Bell", the fact that i thought Firepup was TMI'ing Town-Bell at the time Pooky engaged to try to eliminate Bell didn't help matters either.

I haven't played with Pooky outside of his Hydra on Anything Upick, and that time he didnt tunnel anyone as far as i remember, and was pretty fun to play with and kept forming reads, so I figured this change in attitude meant a different alignment.

Anyway, my next bet for potential scum.
VOTE: Harmony

[Sakura Hana]

bell's evolving claims are also something I scumread bell for

Bell's claim didn't evolve tho?

[Sakura Hana]

We are in a JOAT game, we all have more than one 1-shot ability, Bell just claimed the rest of his kit.

[Firebringer]

pedit: bell's evolving claims are also something I scumread bell for

[Maid Cafe]

RH is a fine vote they fit in the same place as like, Doctor Drew and I don't get why they're playing so appealy. Lemon's posts at Dunn are legit trash

[Maid Cafe]

VOTE: Dunnstral

well i don't feel bad

alot of things i do don't make sense to others, im also busy rn so this is my last post for now

cya

Like the unwarranted emotional reaction into just leaving when Dunn just proves them wrong doesn't feel like someone trying to solve them. I could put a pin in this and say it's ego but given how Lemon has played I don't get that from their posting it feels deliberate.

[Maid Cafe]

I don't think RH's posts are helping I think they're agreeable. (Yes there's a difference)

[Maid Cafe]

I still wanna be more right on Drew then I do on RH because this largely feels like Town yelling at Town but if Rh has more support welp.jpg

VOTE: RH

[Titus]

if i trust a townread on Titus, Ircher, Lto, Bell, Pooky, Hst, Hutao, Joyboy, Other hydra rh Harmony smth (forgot name), Sakura, Firebringer, Laplician

That leaves
Doctor drew
lightski
Maid cafe

though i doubt the game is this easy

Someone's fitting their scumteam into trs

[Hu Tao]

Why do people change the names of things, it confuses me

so true

[Titus]

Meh, I

still want Bell

but RH has been in my list of potential partners. So I will vote RH necause my biggest TR is making a decent case. Meanwhile, I'll note how much easier this is.

Please lim Bell tomorrow.

VOTE: RH

[lemon.tangerine]

if i trust a townread on Titus, Ircher, Lto, Bell, Pooky, Hst, Hutao, Joyboy, Other hydra rh Harmony smth (forgot name), Sakura, Firebringer, Laplician

That leaves
Doctor drew
lightski
Maid cafe

though i doubt the game is this easy

Someone's fitting their scumteam into trs

you caught me

[Titus]

Why do people change the names of things, it confuses me

so true

I'm changing SH's name to Secretly Heavenly so she thinks about being awesome.