In post 90, Bellaphant wrote:
Ok, talk to me about leek and Nora? I have one tr and it isn't either of them.
As I said, these are mostly intuitive reads. Just forcing people into an ordered list based on how I feel about their posts. The only 'real' argument I have for it is Notas's vote on Leek, which I read as opportunistic Mafia jumping on the bandwagon of a suspected Town player.
Also, if you allow me a guess, is your town read Gypyx?
what prompted you to make this guess if i'm like in the middle of your reads?
You would notice that i corrected myself afterwards
Hm. Why do you think wanting to progress game but not being sure how is a scum trait?
we agree that town rarely wants to fabricate thoughts that they don't actually have right? At most they play up their reads for getting reactions and stuff
if they don't have anything, such as during RVS, they need to fish, which is extremely different from actually expressing a read
and, an easy way for scum to stumble is to try to express reads that don't actually have any substance behind them since "we're in RVS i need to push the game fowards that's what i would do"
Obviously they're aware of it so an easy way to do it is in the shape of jokes / undermine themselves / whatever, but them mindset stays here
oooh this is a really creative read
Creative? Does that mean you think it's made-up?
Leading question, your honor But no lol, I was just impressed. Talked about it in my next post ^^
In post 90, Bellaphant wrote:
Ok, talk to me about leek and Nora? I have one tr and it isn't either of them.
As I said, these are mostly intuitive reads. Just forcing people into an ordered list based on how I feel about their posts. The only 'real' argument I have for it is Notas's vote on Leek, which I read as opportunistic Mafia jumping on the bandwagon of a suspected Town player.
Also, if you allow me a guess, is your town read Gypyx?
what prompted you to make this guess if i'm like in the middle of your reads?
My reads at the time had "Leek, Nora, Gypyx", in this order. I wonder if Bella stoped at Nora because their town was next in line.
In post 90, Bellaphant wrote:
Ok, talk to me about leek and Nora? I have one tr and it isn't either of them.
As I said, these are mostly intuitive reads. Just forcing people into an ordered list based on how I feel about their posts. The only 'real' argument I have for it is Notas's vote on Leek, which I read as opportunistic Mafia jumping on the bandwagon of a suspected Town player.
Also, if you allow me a guess, is your town read Gypyx?
what prompted you to make this guess if i'm like in the middle of your reads?
My reads at the time had "Leek, Nora, Gypyx", in this order. I wonder if Bella stoped at Nora because their town was next in line.
do you honestly think bella would obfuscate one of her reads like that? and if so what would be the point
In post 90, Bellaphant wrote:
Ok, talk to me about leek and Nora? I have one tr and it isn't either of them.
As I said, these are mostly intuitive reads. Just forcing people into an ordered list based on how I feel about their posts. The only 'real' argument I have for it is Notas's vote on Leek, which I read as opportunistic Mafia jumping on the bandwagon of a suspected Town player.
Also, if you allow me a guess, is your town read Gypyx?
what prompted you to make this guess if i'm like in the middle of your reads?
My reads at the time had "Leek, Nora, Gypyx", in this order. I wonder if Bella stoped at Nora because their town was next in line.
do you honestly think bella would obfuscate one of her reads like that? and if so what would be the point
It's clear that she is hiding one town read. This is my best guess as to who that town read might be.
i think this had the chance to be a very towny post from you but the lack of curiosity about the motivations was really what imo would distinguish between a newbtown who's having ideas that are a bit out there but is earnestly trying to figure out people and just like, you making an assumption that's a bit out there, which i'm viewing as NAI
Definitely an awkward entrance. Her push on NotAscum doesn't feel like a towny SRing, more like scum looking for a reason to vote.
I really would like to see more from her.
what's so akward about her entrance? she's being a bit extravagant but that's it
In post 137, Little Will o' Wisp wrote:
Well... You're right! I'm not curious about why Bella would conceal her town read. I just wanted to see if I could guess who her town read was.
Are you not curious about the
why
because you think you understand it already?
"Yeah after a point it felt like Aureal was the only one talking sense despite being a goose so I just followed."
-furtiveglance
Definitely an awkward entrance. Her push on NotAscum doesn't feel like a towny SRing, more like scum looking for a reason to vote.
I really would like to see more from her.
what's so akward about her entrance? she's being a bit extravagant but that's it
I expect if he wasn't confirmed town I'd be inquiring into why he thinks I was looking for a reason when I didn't even give a reason. But no point here
"Yeah after a point it felt like Aureal was the only one talking sense despite being a goose so I just followed."
-furtiveglance
What do you think of literally no one following up on your scumread of me and gypyx specifically ignoring it?
Do you think ‘creative’ reads/lines of thought are inherently scummy, towny, NAI, or need to be judged on a case by case? If the last, what do you think about this one and why?
But no lol, I was just impressed. Talked about it in my next post ^^
