Open 908: Aureal Is Hoarding All The Game Names | Game Over

[the worst]

[Aureal]

You find another game name underneath the first game name: isn't this easy? Surely you'll be done finding everything in no time!

True Stories of the

McDonald's

Mafia

1.01

Votecount 1.01

Bingle (2)

-> Black, ceejayvinoya

Klick (2)

-> implosion, the worst

ceejayvinoya (2)

-> Klick, Bingle

Not_Mafia (1)

-> Not_Mafia

Black (1)

-> Dannflor

Not Voting (1)

-> Political Clout

With 9 seekers, it takes 5 votes to remove someone from play.

The day deadline is 10 days ((expired on 2024-04-04 21:13:32) remaining.

[the worst]

why

when Bingle posted again I remembered that wagoning Bingle for tenuous reasons early on day one is kind of like, a tepid approach to solving Bingle's alignment

I also didn't really like cjv joining that wagon w/o really engaging with anything else and honestly I could vote cjv but I don't think it's time yet.

which leads me to look for a better option and I haven't worked either you or Klick out yet so joining you seemed like a treat

wbu

[Klick]

[Klick]

What is a better approach for solving for Bingle?

Atm I'm leaning town but my memory of Bingle's scum range is that it's very very wide

[the worst]

not sure rn I'm not sure I have a formula for Bingle. I just know that pressuring him in this gamestate isn't likely to accomplish anything.

[Klick]

I somewhat agree
I felt meh about doing it at the time but wasn't sure what else to do and wanted to do something productive
And then ceejay came up and made himself a much better option

[Black]

Eh. I'm not particularly interested in confronting Dann yet, no

What I meant was I would expect you to question the validity of the scumreads on me when multiple people joined the wagon for little to no reason. You didn't seem interested in sorting my wagon at all despite thinking I might be town

[Black]

I will say, the reason I'm townreading you is that my impression of your town game is that you're aggressive and pushy and don't really have a thing you want to be doing behind that and my impression of your scumgame is that you're aggressive and pushy and have a goal. This feels more like the former, and so I think you're town

It wouldn't be a game of Mafia if someone didn't try to meta read me in the first several pages

Like I'm happy you reached the right conclusion but it's just such a weak reason to stand on and I'm not even sure if I believe that you believe this

[Black]

I somewhat agree
I felt meh about doing it at the time but wasn't sure what else to do and wanted to do something productive
And then ceejay came up and made himself a much better option

Why is ceejay scum?

[Klick]

VOTE: Klick

I kind of don't like that vote

also aside from a maybe Black town am not getting much out of this yet

This wasn't 'why did you vote Bingle', or 'I don't understand Klick's Bingle vote', but 'VOTE: Klick, I kind of don't like that vote'

Then he follows it up with this

I kind of don't like that vote

y

need more y bingle bad

If he was town and this was all he had to say then I would have expected that to be posted in the first place
I think ceejay was forcing out an opinion because he's scum and wanted to take a stance
Instead of being curious town seeing an odd vote and having legitimate thoughts on it

[Bingle]

What is a better approach for solving for Bingle?

Atm I'm leaning town but my memory of Bingle's scum range is that it's very very wide

Klick calling me fat up in here. I’ll have you know my scumgame is just big boned.

[Bingle]

Eh. I'm not particularly interested in confronting Dann yet, no

What I meant was I would expect you to question the validity of the scumreads on me when multiple people joined the wagon for little to no reason. You didn't seem interested in sorting my wagon at all despite thinking I might be town

Sure I did. Ducky is town looking for a scumread to believe in. I don’t want to confront Dann yet. Implo is putting enough weight on my reads that he thinks they’re automatically consensus and thought I was scumreading you, and I think his “oh huh, only one person was towning tw” while ignoring the correction came across as natural.

There isn’t much left there to push at meaningfully.

[Bingle]

Like I'm happy you reached the right conclusion but it's just such a weak reason to stand on and I'm not even sure if I believe that you believe this

I have little reason to lie about the cause for a weak meta read and if you examine the punnet square of our alignments that should be obvious to at least you. It’s probably best to just accept that I see you as a weird intersection of active and charismatic yet likely to get shitwagoned and try and figure out if the pocket attempt here is me trying to read what you do when pocketed, me trying to pocket you as scum, or me genuinely reaching out because I think you’re town and I want your help in narrowing down the gamestate.

[Bingle]

the worst
implosion
Black
Political Clout
Klick
ceejayvinoya
Dannflor
Not_Mafia

Klick and ceejay probably isn’t S/S.

[ceejayvinoya]

VOTE: Bingle I like this more right now

I still want you to explain why your gut reaction to Black was town

duckkk

I liked her post 33 at that point

I can't say if what PC did there comes more from scum or town but seeing what I'm thinking on PC posted by someone else feels nicee

[ceejayvinoya]

not sure rn I'm not sure I have a formula for Bingle. I just know that pressuring him in this gamestate isn't likely to accomplish anything.

[ceejayvinoya]

VOTE: Klick

I kind of don't like that vote

also aside from a maybe Black town am not getting much out of this yet

This wasn't 'why did you vote Bingle', or 'I don't understand Klick's Bingle vote', but 'VOTE: Klick, I kind of don't like that vote'

Then he follows it up with this

I kind of don't like that vote

y

need more y bingle bad

If he was town and this was all he had to say then I would have expected that to be posted in the first place
I think ceejay was forcing out an opinion because he's scum and wanted to take a stance
Instead of being curious town seeing an odd vote and having legitimate thoughts on it

do you really believe this?

[Bingle]

not sure rn I'm not sure I have a formula for Bingle. I just know that pressuring him in this gamestate isn't likely to accomplish anything.

Can you explain this? Are you agreeing that wagoning me early is useless? Are you calling out tw somehow? Do you disagree with the premise?

[ceejayvinoya]

not sure rn I'm not sure I have a formula for Bingle. I just know that pressuring him in this gamestate isn't likely to accomplish anything.

Can you explain this? Are you agreeing that wagoning me early is useless? Are you calling out tw somehow? Do you disagree with the premise?

not sure how helpful this will be though

I got pretty mixed feelings on this so I thought I'd quote it and look at it again later

I found it curious that the go to method for solving your alignment is pressure but I don't really know enough to agree or disagree with that.

[Black]

I'm liking ceejay I think. I like 167 in particular because I also felt like Klick's read was a little forced so it's nice to see that ceejay is also finding an issue with it

Bingle's responses to me have been fine. Good enough to want to move on for now

VOTE: Klick

e-2 I believe

[Klick]

VOTE: Klick

I kind of don't like that vote

also aside from a maybe Black town am not getting much out of this yet

This wasn't 'why did you vote Bingle', or 'I don't understand Klick's Bingle vote', but 'VOTE: Klick, I kind of don't like that vote'

Then he follows it up with this

I kind of don't like that vote

y

need more y bingle bad

If he was town and this was all he had to say then I would have expected that to be posted in the first place
I think ceejay was forcing out an opinion because he's scum and wanted to take a stance
Instead of being curious town seeing an odd vote and having legitimate thoughts on it

do you really believe this?

yes

[Klick]

Black is there anything you like about ceejay besides him taking issue with my scumread on him

[implosion]

UNVOTE: Klick

[Dannflor]

I don't think it's particularly unreasonable that someone might see "aggressive and pushy" and think scum though.

this isn't the reason i scum read black