Scummies 2008 Nominations! (Deadline: 1/15)

[Max]

What about an award for "insulting logic"

[Max]

explain

People's whos logic is so crap they deserve an award for it, I propose three seperate awards

Insulting Logic Individual
Insulting Logic Town
Insulting Logic Game

[Max]

Even a player that has used insulting logic that has been acted upon deserves an award.
If we don't award mediocrity then only a few people will ever get an award.
Insulting logic is basically an award for using bad logic. Maybe not individual one but general

[Max]

Well I think most likely lynched on day one is not right, it is not a deserved award, insulting logic and convincing people of that, that truely does. Maybe not that, maybe, "best convincer", "most convincing lie", "best argument for bad reasoning". Anything but it still deserves an award

[Max]

It could be worth the best Newbie Player award though

[Max]

I've been rattling by brains for a while to think of people who deserve the last to awards but I can't think of anyone, can anyone else?

[Max]

I'd like to nominate

Korlash

from
This game
for best play as

individual (scum)

Before I'd replaced he fooled me, and even as scum he fooled me,.

[Max]

morph, I think it should be done as well, but I agree with K9, it should not be a part of the scummies

[Max]

The mods don't really do anything, some judges are picked, general members then mith posts the results. The mashies would have to be organised by a regular "Masher"

[Max]

You don't have to judge, mith doesn't judge, create a thread for next year, get some ideas for mish mash awards then in Nov next year delegate some judges and then post the results

[Max]

I'd like to nominate

Korlash

from
This game
for best play as

individual (scum)

Before I'd replaced he fooled me, and even as scum he fooled me,.

Me and Pokerface have nominated and seconded respectively, any more extras?

[Max]

The Inventor Award for Best Role?

[Max]

Are there any more nominations for korlash as scum in Eddie Izzard?

[Max]

No, I'm more concerned about the professor mafia, etc. the site awards because I'm not entirely sure about whether people who run queues entirely deserve it