Tajo wrote:I suspect everyone that jumped against afatchic. I assume one scum was aggressive (Juls) and the other is trying to be subtle. Thats why its hard to decide between you and Crazy. There is some subtle defending of Juls in some posts. Im not too sure about that arguments that have been far-reaching. Could you point me to them?
I'm subtle? I'm actually more assertive here than I am in most of my games. I don't think Artem is really subtle either.
Artem wrote:I still think Crazy is trying to appear townie like he would in a non-vengeful game.
Umm, yeah. Trying to appear like scum usually doesn't help you regardless of alignment. (And yes, finding scum is a higher priority, of course, but who says you can't do both?
afatchic wrote:What happened to afatchic?
He's there... I see both him/you and him/Artem as likely scumpairs. Him/Juls is not, for obvious reasons. Just because I think Artem/Juls make a really likely scumpair doesn't make them my top suspects (Juls in particular, since tbh it's hard to see her as scum with anybody
but
Artem.)
Juls wrote:Can afatchic be town playing poorly? Sure...but of the people in this game I think he is the most scummy. Why can't you open your eyes up to that instead of having me bend to your will? I put forth a lot of effort to try to show you where I am coming from and all I see from you is excuses for him. And being that I think you are the other scum, why would I trust your instincts on afatchic?
I see your case on afatchic. But why the vote on Tajo? That's what's not making sense to me.
Oh, and an Artem/Juls scumpair is actually looking less likely now than it was before. The association between them is very high (both suspect Tajo and either me/afatchic as the other person, right?), but if I remember correctly, neither of them really have the
scum
-tells that set them off. (Townies often show links between each other.
Really, this just occurred to me because of Artem's early post here; and the rest just kind of followed in when I realized that both of them seem to think the other is town.
Artem wrote:Because there was nothing particularly scummy about his response, and because you and Tajo became more interesting with your "It's worthy to note...". It's almost like you're hinting at something I've done being suspicious, without explicitly stating that it is. The fact that you haven't said why something is interesting or noteworthy worries me.
It also bugs me that Slicey doesn't post. In my experience, lurkers tend be the godfather.
Unvote; Vote: Silcey to get him participating.
You'll see I commented on this as soon as he posted it. What bothers me is that Artem thinks a vote is going to be more effective than a prod. When Slicey was replaced, he unvoted. Well,
why not just ask for a prod?
Did you really think that Slicey was purposely lurking
that
much?
It just looked like a pathetic distancing attempt to me... but well, I could be wrong. *shrug*
I should reread the thread more...
![Razz :P](./images/smilies/icon_razz.gif)