Sorry, I've been putting my efforts into the other game, since its time-based. I'm not going to be claiming in this post, since I haven't properly defended myself from the attacks on me, though. Warning, this will be a fairly long post, as I PBPA the game thus far.
0 - Mod post
1 - Mod post
2 - Mod post
3 - Mod post
4 - Mod post
5 - Mod post
6 - Random
7 - Random
8 - Random
9 - Random
10 - Votes Pesco Light for using a post to vote the Mod, calls it a 'mega scumtell', which is almost certainly a huge exaggeration
11 - Votes Wishbone since he has never played/modded with anyone in that hydra
12 - Asking a confirmatory question to Poker, trying to set up the basis for a read on Poker
13 - Random
14 - Uses a post for a "Yes, I have", which seems like a waste
15 - Another waste of a post, asking about PF's info on them, that invites yet another wasted post in the answer
16 - Mod post
17 - Random
18 - Random
19 - Posts he can't read hydras, which seems odd considering he signed up for TWO hydra games simultaneously
20 - Points out what he thinks is an SK slip, in what was just a random vote
21 - Starts the theory discussion about signing posts, explains the SK 'slip' was just random posting
22 - Posts mixed opinions about the signing posts, makes a random vote, and uses the same post to ask for less fluff.
FoS: Wishbone
23 - Pointing out the above hypocricy in 22
24 - Commenting on the heads vs hydra discussion
25 - Continuing the heads vs hydra discussion
26 - Continuing the heads vs hydra discussion, points out he'll be signing posts
27 - Continuing the heads vs hydra discussion, points out he'll differ to his other head. At this point, it feels like his posts are being made for the sake of posting.
FoS: Trotsky
28 - Completely useless, waste of a post.
FoS: Poker
29 - Votes me for "discussing semantics without scumhunting"; :goodposting:
30 - Double-posts less than an hour after 29, which seems like a waste, but at least uses the post well
31 - Strawmans my argument about heads vs hydras, and votes me for it, even though he claims to have a "gut scum read" on a RW post.
FoS: Pesco Light
32 - Points on that 31 seems to vote on the weaker of the two points
33 - Keeps strawmanning my point, and calling it scummier than a gut read
34 - Continuing the heads vs hydra discussion
35 - Plays off 15 as "playful banter"
36 - Responds well to 33 and 35
37 - Uses a post for the sole purpose of asking if random votes are a waste of a post.
FoS: Ortohoops
38 - Responds to 37 nicely, though I feel it would have been better to keep this response saved until he had more to post
39 - Wasting another post, as he defends the fact he wasted a post
40 - Makes what looks like a random vote on Trotsky, which would be out of place in a NORMAL game, let alone one where its best to conserve post count
41 - Votes me for "simultaneously wasting posts and providing a reason to lurk", even though lurking isn't bad in this game
42 - Very nice post where he compiles points against Poke, comments on the heads vs hydra discussion, and points out his thoughts on lurking vs spamming in this game
43 - Mod post
44 - Pointing out the strawman in Pesco's logic, following Yos' vote on Poke
45 - Comments on how many NKs we should aim to allow, comments on heads vs hydras, joins the Poke wagon
46 - Another waste of a post, as he answers a question from the random stage, tries to explain that a "Yes, I have" post isn't a watste, and asks a question about something shafted pointed out
47 - Removes his partner's vote on me, voices his opinion on how many action phases
48 -
Yet another
absolute waste of a post from Poke; very happy with my vote at this point
49 - Another strawman at my argument, a ridiculous FoS to anyone who signs their posts. I'm getting a bad vibe from Pesco Light.
50 - Finally a post from Poke that isn't a waste
51 - Points out he dislikes not being able to post a lot, and says he dislikes the rules, when he knew what he was signing up for. Possible excuse to either not post very much of post more than needed.
52 - Very nice post, comments on all the players
53 - Mod post
54 - Reasonless wagon jump onto Poke
55 - Votes Poke for bad logic. He wastes posts, THAT'S scummy. Making an analysis on the game thus far, not so much
56 - Asks about my wagon thus far, points out no original thinking on my part thus far, which is a valid point
57 - Jumps back on my wagon
58 - Votes me for jumping on the Poke wagon, points out KScope's meta allows him to jump on wagons, when my meta is someone who often votes without giving reasons, and wagons a ton Day 1. Ortohoops, who made this post?
59 - Undoes his other head's vote, jumps back on my wagon. This is the same person that said there should be no perceivable difference between the heads.
60 - Talks about the wagon on me without commiting for or against it, points out he finds Poke very scummy
61 - Questions Frog about his reasons for not posting much
62 - Points out that he doesn't see the case on me, he doesn't like Ortohoops wagon-hopping and hypocrisy. :goodposting:
63 - Pressures Poke, asks Orto how the Poke wagon was any more opportunistic than mine
64 - This was a bad post by me, where I waste a post asking a question about one thing shafted said
65 - Explains the rationale for his list/comments of everyone
66 - Points out how bad of a post 64 was
67 - Lurker-votes Hogfather
68 - Explains that he thinks wasting posts isn't scummy, and that Scum actually probably won't do it...WHAT? I think he knows exactly if the Scum are or aren't wasting posts.
Unvote, Vote: Ortohoops
69 - Mod post
70 - Claims I "make a fine lynch today"
71 - Explains the SK/Vig thing from earlier, votes Zaphod, points out my "wagon is good too", which just looks like paving the way to jump on down the road
72 - Wastes a post correcting what looks like a nice freudian slip in 73
73 - Very nice, concise, post which sums up their views in the past page or so. This is what the Town should strive for all posts to be, in my opinion.
74 - Another post similar to Frog's 73, commenting on a few things
75 - Jumps on my wagon
76 - Mod post
77 - Another reasonless wagon post, jumping on to the new biggest wagon, right after the vote count, and attemps to put me at L-1
78 - Unvotes me to create a buffer in case of a scumkill
79 - Double post, since 78 wasn't under the hydra account
80 - Posts under the J-Scope account, doesn't vote me
81 - Revotes me.
82 - Pipes in out of nowhere, having done shit all in terms of posting all game, that she is willing to hammer me
83 - Useless double-post, since she didn't vote
84 - Points out how they think its better to hammer rather than unvote and start a new wagon, something I think is preposterous.
85 - Asks other people about how they feel about my wagon
86 - Points out how I'm active lurking, which I don't deny, but that he's waiting for something from me before voting me again
87 - Mod post
88 - 'I'm replacing in!' post
89 - Talks about wanting me hammered in 24 hours
90 - Thinks I'm Scum since Scum haven't killed someone to try and kill me, despite the fact I think I'm off of L-1.
91 - Wants me lynched for not posting
92 - Points out its probably better to focus on Alpha, yet votes me for not having said much in this game, putting me at L-1
---
All in all:
FoS: Poke, Zaphod, Wishbone, Pesco
Unvote, Vote: Ortohoops