Well then talk to vollkan about it because he put it in this set-up. If I get lynched because of my claim, I'm going to have a GREAT time during post-game giving you and anyone else who voted me some shit for trying to out-guess the mod and failing miserably.Post 875, charter wrote:Incog's claim really doesn't mean anything if you think he's in a three person group with Ether (Xdaamo is included because he's prolly scum) because then he could have just bussed Ether day two, knowing she could never make it long. His Korts result means nothing because Korts said that's what he did first. The watcher in here is just too good for town.
That's awesome.charter in MD wrote:Whenever someone is on the lynch of scum, and accuses someone else on the lynch of bussing, it makes me wary of the acuser. You need to come up with other reasons than 'suspected bussing' if you want anyone else to listen to you. I think subjective is fine for your own opinions, but then you need to dig up/invent objective points for others to go on.
Not every game contains a protective role. The only previous vollkan game I've played in didn't, so it doesn't seem like a safe assumption.GC wrote:I have no reason to think that we don't have at least a single doctor-esque role out there.
I can see scum choosing to claim bodyguard on day 1, it's less likely to draw a counterclaim and if he fears another scum faction, it's also less likely to draw a nightkill. But mainly it's because I think we likely have 2-1-3 and if he's town I'm struggling to think of a two person team I believe in.GC wrote:Outside of his actual claim and apart from my D1 squabble with him, he never really registered on my scumdar again - yet another reason why I am inclined to believe him. I actually don't understand you persistent suspicions of Korts, so I'm all ears as to why he's still not confirmed for you.
Nyeh, I'm aware of the fact that you were on both cases; but the argument against Xd on D1 seemed slightly overhyped, and largely by you--it could be bussing. Then again, you wouldn't push his case now, when you likely need your hypothetical partner for endgame purposes...GC wrote:The third mafia with Xd and Ether? After I have pushed heavily for both of their lynches (Xd for both D1, D2 and D3; Ether for D2)? That... makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.
This is annoying, and made me consider replacing out. Mafia sucks here because of the meta that you have to have no life to play it.Patrick wrote:Xdaamno needs to post something with actual substance. He's hanging back, and it doesn't take a genius to work out why.
Fairly scummy quote, but not representative of my feelings I think.Green Crayons wrote:Incog: In light of all of this, who would you like to see lynched today as of this moment?
No, that's bullshit. You're not being asked anything unreasonable, you've largely avoided posting substance all game. The most you post is when you come under heavy attack, and even then you seem to defend yourself more than you look for scum.Xdaamno wrote:This is annoying, and made me consider replacing out. Mafia sucks here because of the meta that you have to have no life to play it.
It pretty much has to be, since everyone in the game except you has expressed suspicion of you.Xdaamno wrote:The mutual suspiscion on me in the last few posts is, objectively, from my point of view, scum-driven and has gone unnoticed because of a tired, bloodthirsty town.
pffffftPatrick wrote:No, that's bullshit. You're not being asked anything unreasonable, you've largely avoided posting substance all game. The most you post is when you come under heavy attack, and even then you seem to defend yourself more than you look for scum.Xdaamno wrote:This is annoying, and made me consider replacing out. Mafia sucks here because of the meta that you have to have no life to play it.
I'm not talking about that. I'm talking about the 'xdaamno is obvscum, here's our plan to deal with him' position that only a couple of people have expressed.Patrick wrote:And to expand on that, a prod and request for content is quite reasonable when all your posts today up until your last have been fluff and not said anything about your suspicions. To say that you're being asked to have no life is an obvious exageration.
It pretty much has to be, since everyone in the game except you has expressed suspicion of you.Xdaamno wrote:The mutual suspiscion on me in the last few posts is, objectively, from my point of view, scum-driven and has gone unnoticed because of a tired, bloodthirsty town.
Yeah, I did consider this. The issue I have with this hypothesis is it doesn't explain whyPost 888, Korts wrote:Incog, since we've pretty much established that Yos' miller role was a red herring, why discount the possibility that Ether's "red mafia" role is a red herring as well?
You were gone for three days without leaving any indication that you were on V/LA. It's a perfectly necessary prod to make.Post 890, Xdaamno wrote:That prod was unnecessary.Incognito wrote:Thank you, Patrick, for bringing some sense into this thread. Much appreciated. Still not sure if you're scum though whereas GC is almost certainly scum.
Mod:prod Xdaamno, please?
Ha. I have quite a busy life, and I still make time to post at least once a day. What's your excuse?Post 891, Xdaamno wrote: Mafia sucks here because of the meta that you have to have no life to play it.