It's time.
First off, he replaced Cyberbob, who I definitely found scummy in his short time with us.
He's been talking about darkfriends and the "darkfriend team" a bunch.
Benmage wrote:The global roleblock should block any NK from the darkfriends so we won't be losing back to back townies if we vote wrong.
Benmage wrote:He wasn’t AS he was Forsaken. He may have acted rashly without confirming with fellow AS. The darkfriend team may not know all their members.
While on day 1 it was a reasonable assumption that the mafia would be a darkfriend team, Fabian flipped "Survivor Mafia". Something seems off about the way Benmage is discussing Fabian's death after the fact.
His initial vote on day 2 was on SpyreX.
Benmage wrote:Let's vote the MC now.
Seems to me like a blatant attempt to waste the day. Note also that he's the only one going so far as to consider this:
Benmage wrote:My only reconsideration is in the mini the dark friend team gained an extra gift with the death of the MC. (Pretty sure that is how I read it. My memory is failing me now… If someone from the mini wants to give further insight feel free).
Bespeaks a player viewing things from a scum perspective as opposed to town.
Why didn't he go after Spyrex on Days 3 and 4? Day 3 would have been just as good of a time to do it, as we had just gotten rid of an SK. Now on Day 4, he's aiming at ABR, which in my opinion classifies as an "easy wagon".
Benmage has been insisting for the entire game that there are Black Ajah AS.
Benmage wrote:However I have had and have an underlying eerie feeling that in a game of this magnitude the odds of Black AS are high.
Feels like someone trying to score "told you so" points when a Black Ajah buddy flips. This is a guy who apparantly likes "told you so" points.
Benmage wrote:who was it who thought twilight and thus night kills wouldn't of been blocked by KoC...i guess...i told ya so
Trys to end the day without all necessary info coming out:
Benmage wrote:I still don’t see the point of waiting for replacements. Than we have to wait for them to declare where they stayed and catch up on the game… Can’t all this be done tomorrow? Aren’t replacements informed of any actions their character previously did…How beneficial is this location thin anyways when its clear people are lying?
Also, why is it clear that people are lying about their locations?
Benmage wrote:As far as scum possibilities. Kairyuu is my leading candidates. Kaiyruu motivating Issac and trying to have the two confirm each other through their roles seemed really sketchy. Since then he has seemed rather obstinate. His butler claim is weak. His stress against there being Black Ajah seemed to detract from the game. His scum hunting is nearly nonexistent. I’m trying to look at others in iso to get some more reads. Perhaps if others answer these questions it can give me some direction to refer back to.
This is a crap argument, since Isacc was a serial killer.
I can't for the life of me figure out the argument for ABR saying who he roleblocked. We're nowhere near certain as to the set up, so we can't use the roleblock to confirm town or scum, so I see this only as an attempt to figure out if he or a scumbuddy would need to lie about an action.
Benmage wrote:We haven't mislynched, and I still feel like were losing...two deaths. What do you guys think caused the extra deaths?
a.k.a. The "Oh whoa is us, these nightkills are awful" scumtell.
There's a bunch of other stuff too, though maybe more minor, but I'm kind of done for right now. More than enough evidence for a vote.