Percy wrote:Firstly, townies shouldn't lie. What if he was asked to protect someone later? Secondly, this could have outed an actual protective role if they were tempted to counterclaim. This sentence doesn't sit right with me at all.
'Or something', in a big closed setup game like this I think you can afford to be a bit... Creative with your claim if you're something like BP townie. You wouldn't claim bomb if you were a bomb.
He obviously didn't think he was claiming vanilla at the time. What are you talking about whoot? Was that in response to my question?
I want more from Whoot. I want his rationale at the very least before we move on to anything else. After that though, I agree that we should look at Starbuck. Coasted through the day without a vote or even an FoS, much less a case.
I didn't go through all of Day 1 without saying anything. I was reading the other games to try and see where they were at, just like everyone else did, before posting in ours.
That's quite an accusation to make also when your first real post wasn't until yesterday.
Starbuck wrote:I didn't go through all of Day 1 without saying anything. I was reading the other games to try and see where they were at, just like everyone else did, before posting in ours.
That's quite an accusation to make also when your first real post wasn't until yesterday.
Who is that directed at?
Why would you make this game a lower priority than the others?
Starbuck wrote:I didn't go through all of Day 1 without saying anything. I was reading the other games to try and see where they were at, just like everyone else did, before posting in ours.
That's quite an accusation to make also when your first real post wasn't until yesterday.
Who is that directed at?
Why would you make this game a lower priority than the others?
That is directed at you, and since these games are inter-linked, it's good to know what's going on in the other ones.
You confirmed and then didn't post anything until yesterday, so if you want to accuse someone of not being here for Day 1, you need to look at yourself before you point any fingers at anyone else.
Then that is simply incorrect. I appreciate the suggestion that I direct my accusations at myself but that seems somehow less fruitful.
It's not bad to know what's going on in the other games, but that is not what I asked. I am not questioning your activity even, just that you seemed to avoid posting any content regarding this game.
Mufasa wrote:I think we have scum groups classified as the following:
Slivers, Goblins,
Each of these in the card game has a king or lord.
Sliver Overlord/Sliver Queen with Sliver Queen being a Mafia Recruiter because she has the ability in the card game to make new slivers (Scum)
Goblin King gives all goblins mountain walk so they can directly attack the life points of people who control red mana, in this game I think he has the power to move his fellow scum team.
The Third scum team I'm not sure of right now could be rats, elves, clerics, not sure... but seeing that we had a sliver flip scum I am almost certain that there is a Sliver Queen that is a Scum Recruiter....
The NK's have been very odd lately. I'm starting to think that scum don't kill at night but instead send people to other games...
I really doubt this is accurate. This might be true for Tempest/Weatherlight and Time Spiral, but it doesn't make sense with Kamigawa. Kamigawa is supposed to emphasize the spirits/gods warring with the humans over That Which Was Taken. I don't see why you would think that there are leaders to each group. Or why you chose goblins.
Yes, but they aren't quite the same - a bulletproof is not quite the policy lynch that VT is. To be fair, VT probably isn't a very good policy lynch anyway.
Finished reading this game. Boxman looks a little more town to me now that Percy flipped scum. I would definitely vote qwints right now. First, put him at L-1 because he's not playing like a bulletproof. Does zwet ever play pro-town? No, he doesn't. And this is right after Starbuck posted what card he was. At that point it should have been obvious he was town. That plus the fishing for info. Whoot is hella scummy now as well. Policy lynch VT's? What the hell are you smoking? And he wasn't even a VT. He was a bulletproof, something completely different.
I haven't read Tar's game yet, but I really don't feel like it. I don't think it's really going to affect us that much. I may skim it every now and then but I don't plan on fully reading either game. Now that I'm in the game, I can fully understand why people aren't reading the other games.
Taking a temporary retirement from playing mafia games... damn you invitationals.
Coming in Summer 2010: Yu-Gi-Oh: The Abridged Mafia. The most nonsensical game of mafia you'll ever play.
Note: V/LA most weekends, sorry.
We have one dead scum and he's guessing, just based on one and only one scum, three different scumteams. Way too much guesswork involved based on little information.
Taking a temporary retirement from playing mafia games... damn you invitationals.
Coming in Summer 2010: Yu-Gi-Oh: The Abridged Mafia. The most nonsensical game of mafia you'll ever play.
Note: V/LA most weekends, sorry.
