lol. No they shouldnt claim at all. I read a discussion on itMonkeyMan576 wrote:@Jordan: No one should claim vanilla? What if they ARE vanilla? They should lie?
Vanilla claim doesnt do anything except help mafia. It lowers the chances of them not lynching a power role. If they decide to guess which player had a power role, you just increased the chances of them getting it right.
Also, they know you aren't a threat. You want the mafia to overestimate you as much as possible, especially if ur vanilla.