Newbie 829 - Game Over.

[Cobalt]

I was waiting to see if d3x had anything he wanted to say. Still willing to hammer if he's done. I think F_C is scum.

[Zorblag]

Vote Count 3.3

The numbers by the voters indicate the order in which the vote was cast. If two or more players are tied for the most votes to lynch at the deadline the tiebreaker will be the player who has the earliest active vote.

Far_Cry: 2: Einlanzers (1), Zhero (2)

Not Voting: Cobalt, d3x, Far_Cry

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch. Currently Far_Cry would be lynched at deadline. Deadline is 12:00 PM EDT/ 9:00 AM PDT on Friday, October 16th, 2009.

-Zorblag R`Lyeh

[Zhero]

Yeah, I'm having trouble thinking of anything to say that hasn't already been said. I'm comfortable with my vote where it is, and I think I've explained my stance well. Not opposed to a hammer, but d3x mentioned further discussion in his most recent post, so we may want to wait on that. More discussion definitely trumps a hammer, but I'm not sure we have much left to say.

[Far_Cry]

Yeah, I'm having trouble thinking of anything to say that hasn't already been said. I'm comfortable with my vote where it is, and I think I've explained my stance well. Not opposed to a hammer, but d3x mentioned further discussion in his most recent post, so we may want to wait on that. More discussion definitely trumps a hammer, but I'm not sure we have much left to say.

Just a question: I don't remember if I asked you this before (I may have, srry if I am repeating myself), but who is your second suspect?

By the way, I'm still waiting for something from d3x.

[Cobalt]

Can we get a prod on d3x?

[Zorblag]

d3x let us know ahead of time that he'd be V/LA from the 1st to the 5th. He won't be getting any prods till after then.

-Zorblag R`Lyeh

[Cobalt]

Oh right.

[Zhero]

To be honest, I could see a case on either Ein or Cobalt for my second choice.

So let's get some conversation going while waiting for d3x to return.

Cobalt - you believed Ein hammering a week early was a bad thing Day 2, but are willing to hammer Far_Cry 2 weeks early Day 3. What changed?

Ein - if Far_Cry isn't our last scum, who is, and why?

d3x - you mentioned in post 410 that you were holding off on a detailed list until later. When you return, could we see one?

[Cobalt]

ein's hammer was in the midst of a whole bunch of discussion, with votes changing relatively often. now the game has stalled and there also seems to be a consensus for F_C's lynch. QED

[Einlanzers]

Ein - if Far_Cry isn't our last scum, who is, and why?

As I have said though I am not 100% sure that F_C is scum (though I am 99.999% sure). I have an overly town read from d3x. A moderately town read from Cobalt. And a neutral read from Zhero. Technically any one of them could be scum, but that is the order in which I find their "towniness"

Does that answer your question?

[Far_Cry]

ein's hammer was in the midst of a whole bunch of discussion, with votes changing relatively often. now the game has stalled and there also seems to be a consensus for F_C's lynch. QED

Than why is nobody hammering me?

[Cobalt]

we're waiting on d3x

[Far_Cry]

we're waiting on d3x

Huh, I'm waiting, too.

In the meantime, does anyone have any questions for me?

[d3x]

This is me, being back from V/LA. I have a few games running atm, so I'm trying to get caught up in all of them at the same time. Thanks for the patience!

~d

[d3x]

So, I would like a better response on exactly what d3x, before you hammer me, Cobalt.

So, I'm guessing that this is one of the points where discussion stalled out, right? This is the 'unfinished business' that everyone keeps going on about and is using to not further discuss anything? Honestly, I'm not even sure what this statement means, F_C. Can you ask me again, maybe in a different way. I'd be happy to respond.

I must say that being gone 5 days, I had expected to see something more than "prods on the guy who's V/LA'. Zhero tried to start some more discussion, but everyone else pretty much just waited for me to return. Ein and Cobalt, are you that sure that F_C is the remaining Scum? You both had no more questions for anyone else? F_C, you answered the last round of questions, but where is your case on anyone else? You're this close to lynch but you're really not using the opportunity to Scum Hunt. You don't have a Vote down on anyone. If our positions were reversed, would you find that odd?

[Einlanzers]

Yeah I'm pretty sure that F_C is scum. He seems to just keep stalling for more time to live before a hammer, which could be town...but it'd be more towny to defend yourself properly. Cobalt seems to be stalling for time aswell...but it isn't scummy when he isn't the one being attacked AND he is someone that could easily hammer someone else. Zhero and I seem to just be waiting patiently for you and Cobalt to either:
A) Hammer F_C
B) Bring up a good point against someone else or against the F_C case.

[Cobalt]

I have no problem hammering now, I just wanted to make sure I wasn't cutting off any discussion.

[Cobalt]

It's been 6 hours and d3x was online at least once. We're not getting anywhere.

Vote: Far_Cry

[d3x]

What do you mean, "d3x was online at least once"? I've been online all day waiting for answers to my questions. Did you miss them? p489. Have you been waiting for me to post just so that you could Hammer?

[Cobalt]

I've already made it clear I think FC is the last scum, and your questions haven't really addressed anything we haven't already talked about. I was hoping you'd post any final thoughts if you felt the case on F_C was incomplete, but you never did, and Zhero and Ein haven't posted either.

[Zorblag]

Vote Count 3.4

The numbers by the voters indicate the order in which the vote was cast. If two or more players are tied for the most votes to lynch at the deadline the tiebreaker will be the player who has the earliest active vote.

Far_Cry: 2: Einlanzers (1), Zhero (2), Cobalt (3)

Not Voting: d3x, Far_Cry

With 5 alive it takes 3 to lynch.

Far_Cry, Mafia Goon

is lynched day three.

Town wins.

I'll have some comments this evening. I encourage everyone to post their thoughts respectfully.

-Zorblag R`Lyeh

[Cobalt]

YAY

[d3x]

Good job, guys. Go Town!

[Cobalt]

Bummer for F_C. He was the only scummy person left. Killing OMT was a poor move: would've been way better to kill Zhero and then sit back and let us mislynch OMT, then kill Ein and let me and d3x fight it out in endgame.

[d3x]

Bummer for F_C. He was the only scummy person left. Killing OMT was a poor move: would've been way better to kill Zhero and then sit back and let us mislynch OMT, then kill Ein and let me and d3x fight it out in endgame.

+1

In response to your

I was hoping you'd post any final thoughts if you felt the case on F_C was incomplete

That's what my questions were for. From my perspective, we just didn't have enough from F_C. Trust me, though. When I came back and read what had been posted, I almost Hammered him myself. I stopped because if I was wrong, that'd look crazy scummy and we'd lose when I inevitably got mislynched tomorrow.