Mini 852- Crayola Catastrophe Game Over (Post 1158)

[Kirbyoshi]

All my games seem to be stalling. Socio does need to answer the question. Why did you say you were going to get yourselves lynched, just because EK wanted to lynch a doc that survived the Night?

[elvis_knits]

I'm pretty much ready to lynch Pome, especially since deadline is tomorrow, I think.

But I was waiting for socio to answer that.

[Jahudo]

e_k, Pome isn't at L-1. Are you worried someone would quickhammer?

@Socio: What do you think of the possibility that e_k is scum and let Pome survive the night in order to lynch her the next day? Didn't she tell you that Pome should be lynched if she survive the night? And aren't you following her suggestion today?

Note that I do not believe e_k is scum, but I am interested in hearing Socio answer those questions.

[elvis_knits]

I guess I'm worried about socio hammering without answering.

Also I never looked at you like I promised, so I was holding out.

I'm not sure why pome isn't voting anyone or trying to get anyone else lynched. Makes me wonder if she's the lone scum like we think and has sort of given up or if her buddy is bussing her and she's taking one for the team.

[SocioPath]

Because EK and I have been towards the top, or at the very top of the towns lists pretty much the entire game.

It seems very odd that the scum wouldn't try to take out either of us to limit the number of townie players.

I also told EK there was about a 60% chance of me outing us and trying for the lynch.

Because I said it depended entirely on the night kills.

Yankee being NK'd, and then being the exact role he claimed is what 'changed the plans.'

D2 I was TRYING to draw suspicion towards me, to avoid NKs, and trying to avoid the very obvious buddying between me and EK. I mean just look at D2, the fact that no one called us out on it is strange enough.

At this point EK doesn't even need to appear townie to any of you, she only needs to appear that way to me, because essentially, we control the other's fate.

[Jahudo]

e_k, is what Socio said true? When you described your night conversation you didn't mention Socio saying he might depending on night kills, you said he would claim and you didn't meantion 60%.

[elvis_knits]

He did say 60%, that is true. I didn't remember he said it depended on the NK's, but I looked back and he did say that. However, he didn't tell me what NKs meant what to him, so I really didn't pay much attention to that part of it.

I PMed him after that asking him why he thought I was scum and never heard back from him. I took that as a sign that either he reallyreally thought I was scum and didn't even want to talk to me, or that he was scum that couldn't come up with good reasons. Either one was bad... seeing as he's wrong if he thinks I'm scum, and I was in trouble if he's scum (since I had been thinking he was town all game and didn't tell the town the truth).

Whole game I was trying to figure out if I thought he was town or not. Thinking that if I thought he was town it was better for the town to lie to you all, preventing a 2for1 nightkill. But I always felt the burden of deciding on my own and potentially protecting a scum if I say he's town and he's not.

[elvis_knits]

So basically, Jahudo, what he says is true, but when he stopped PMing me I just assumed that the probability had risen. I thought he would probably do it. Then when he didn't, I was very mindfucked.

[Pomegranate]

It seems very odd that the scum wouldn't try to take out either of us to limit the number of townie players.

Scum must've gone for EK N2, so I don't understand this.

[elvis_knits]

But pome, even if you're town, couldn't it have been a doublekill on zazie though?

[Pomegranate]

You're right, "must" was the wrong word, I just see scum as far less likely to target scum as he was under quite a bit of suspicion.

[elvis_knits]

Pome, you know if we lynch you today and you're town we might lose.

Why aren't you trying to lynch anyone?

[Pomegranate]

Well, I'd like to hear Socio's response to 1133 before voting for him.

Also, I do admit that I have a bad tendency to lurk more when I'm about to be lynched.

[elvis_knits]

So you think socio is scum.

Do you think he has any buddies? If so, who?

[Pomegranate]

I'd probably say Kirb then Chibo, but I feel a lot less confident in that than I do regarding Socio. Or possibly SK.

[Jahudo]

Pome, you voted me at the start of this game day. Why do you think Kirby or Chibo over me?

[Pomegranate]

Pome, you voted me at the start of this game day. Why do you think Kirby or Chibo over me?

Because I've done a reread of you in iso, and though GD didn't do

anything

, you have made consistent sense.

[SocioPath]

You're right, "must" was the wrong word, I just see scum as far less likely to target scum as he was under quite a bit of suspicion.

Scum killing Zaz N2 is not any more odd than scum killing a 1 shot vig N3.

[Pomegranate]

Socio, please address 1133. Specifically, you said that you found it strange that scum had never targeted either you or EK, because you both appeared townie. I then said that it was likely that scum

had

targeted EK, but you replied that it was also strange that Yankee was killed last night. What point were you trying to bring out?

As you haven't replied to 1133, and more...

Vote: Socio

.

[Jahudo]

Pome, do you still think that e_k was the scum's night 2 target?

[Pomegranate]

I find that that makes more sense than scum targeting Zaz, and it fits together. Yes.

[Battousai]

Vote Count

Pomegranate (2)- Kirbyoshi, Jahudo
Jahudo (1)- ChiboSempai
SocioPath (1)- Pomegranate

Not Voting (2)- SocioPath, elvis_knits

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch!

Deadline is Nov 17th at 6pm (GMT-5hrs)!

[Kirbyoshi]

Hm. Well, Pom's actually making sense now. Making sense is not a towntell, but she brings up good points against Socio. His play D2 was also...strange, to say the least, when compared to his play in Days 1 and 3 (so far). I hate that I'm always the one to bring up role possibilities, but could this be a cultist setup? Simple speculation that I think fits with Socio's playstyle change from D1 to D2, and with him and EK claiming Lovers, if EK is also a cultist. Something to think about...

[Jahudo]

@Kirby: Cult would only be possible if recruits weren't revealed as recruits when they're killed. Otherwise a cult would have had the majority by day 4.

Pome is not making any sense. She believes Socio is scum, and scum tried to kill e_k night 2. Why would scum kill his lover? That is beyond WIFOM. Scum wouldn't commit suicide. I still feel good about my vote.

Deadline is tomorrow. Anyone else have anything to say before today ends?

[Kirbyoshi]

Thanks Jahudo, didn't take that into account. Still happy with my vote. Nothing much else to say.