VP Baltar wrote:@Thesp-can you quantify why you are so assured of Talilan's towniness? What do you think of his decisions this game (particularly Scene 7)?
Part of it's a best guess, some of it is their thought process in claiming what Grey told them (or didn't tell them) regarding the endgame. I feel like they're actually trying to do the best they can with what they have, and I get the feeling that they don't have the whole picture and they're trying to piece it together. They come across as genuine (even if one half is occasionally aggravating, I think their effort is townlike). I think they're less likely to be scum than some others. I've pondered a lot about their offstage decision on the last day, and while it's a touch suspicious in the results it achieved, I have a hard time killing them for it, at least in part for the fact that it's possible (if they and Orbots are town) that they're picking from seven players, 4 of whom would be scum.
Mighty Orbots wrote:@Thesp: Opinions on things that didn't happen Scene 1 plz?
Anything in particular that strikes your fancy? My opinions are based more than on Scene 1, but I thought that was worth exploring.
Let me give you the rundown in the notes I'm showing by player (re: onstage decisions, Scenes 5-7 are excluded for their utter uselessness, probably could have excluded Scene 1 as well):
Talilan
Scene 1: Wiggin (Good choice, onstage)
Scene 2: Door 1 (Good choice, onstage)
Scene 3: Bizarre - I have a hard time following, though did have post that helped push to Crone onstage (uncertain, offstage)
Scene 4: Not Push (Good choice, onstage)
Mighty Orbots
Scene 1: no choice reflected (no indication, offstage)
Scene 2: Door 1 (Good choice, onstage)
Scene 3: neutral (no indication, offstage)
Scene 4: Push (Bad choice, onstage)
Starkiss
Scene 1: Wiggin (Good choice, onstage)
Scene 2: neutral (no indication, offstage)
Scene 3: Crone (Bad choice, onstage)
Scene 4: Push (Bad choice, onstage)
Panzerjager/zu_Faul
Scene 1: Wiggin (Good choice, onstage)
Scene 2: neutral (no indication, offstage)
Scene 3: Mother suggested offstage (nonBad choice, offstage)
Scene 4: Push (Bad choice, onstage)
Hewitt
Scene 1: No vote (no indication, onstage)
Scene 2: Neutral (no indication, offstage)
Scene 3: Crone (Bad choice, onstage)
Scene 4: Neutral (no indication, offstage)
VP Baltar
Scene 1: Wiggin (Good choice, onstage)
Scene 2: leaned towards switching to Door #2 (leaned to Bad choice, offstage)
Scene 3: Crone (Bad choice, onstage)
Scene 4: neutral (no indication, offstage)
Thesp
Scene 1: No vote (indicated Good choice, onstage)
Scene 2: neutral (no indication, offstage)
Scene 3: suggested Crone might be best, but asserted Mother was the pick to make (Nonbad choice indicated, offstage)
Scene 4: neutral (no indication, offstage)
I really, really wish I could table-ize and/or color-ize this. It looks much prettier that way.
As an FYI - my birthday is next Friday, and the party is next Saturday. I probably will not be useful around the deadline, which I hope we won't be running into.
Also, I'm not liking hewitt's last post.
Vote: StarKiss
, [Mighty Orbots, hewitt, zu_Faul], [Talilan, VP Baltar], No Lynch, [Thesp]