Mini 910 - Empire Records Mafia ~Over~

[Papa Zito]

<3 Reck.

Hey Nik.

Liamisobvscumguyswhyisnthelynchedyet {snipped for sanity}

Vote: CallMeLiam.

Nope. I'm more sure that Reck is scum than CML being scum, anyway.

How did Reck become more scum than obvscum CML?

[Starbuck]

Vote Count

CallMeLiam (5) - Papa Zito, RayFrost, kyle99, DragonsofSummer, wolframnhart
Papa Zito (2) - xRECKONERx, CallMeLiam
Andromina (1) - Excedrin
kyle99 (1) - semioldguy
xRECKONERx (1) - Nikanor


Not Voting: Andromina, Kise


7 to lynch

Deadline is February 17th at 6 am EST

Nik, I'm a shitty mafia player. That's not AtE, it's true, goddammit.

He speaks the truth with this. Just read back on his previous games!

<3 you, Reck!

[semioldguy]

CML needs to be lynched before too long regardless. If that is indeed his post restriction, then town loses in lylo if CML is town.

Unvote; Vote: callmeliam

FoS: Nikanor

For the breadcrumb. Several reasons why. In my experience, most breadcrumbing seems to come from mafia as an early way to set up 'evidence' for a role when they might need it later in the game. Town doing this is bad because it allows scum to find out about your role (as already mentioned here). This is bad if breadcrumbing as town because it lets scum know what not to claim and lets scum know what out there to be wary of.

Also, if you are breadcrumbing a role name in a themed game, it doesn't necessarily indicate power or alignment. It does prevent scum from using that as a potential fake-claim that you might have been able to catch them in. Also scum might themselves have that name as a safe-claim and thus breadcrumbing their safe-claim. Also there may be other disadvantages to having your powers or role name publicly known (see Mini 857 for an example of such instances).

Bottom line is that breadcrumbing is not helpful to town and is often scummy.

[Andromina]

Papa Zito wrote:

CallMeLiam just voted someone for claiming a useful townie role!

Do you think the claim was serious?
Should we lynch CallMeLiam?

vote: CallMeLiam

Aye. To both.

(And I'm no longer a voting virgin.)

[Starbuck]

Vote Count

CallMeLiam (7) - Papa Zito, RayFrost, kyle99, DragonsofSummer, wolframnhart, semioldguy, Andromina
Papa Zito (2) - xRECKONERx, CallMeLiam
Andromina (1) - Excedrin
xRECKONERx (1) - Nikanor


Not Voting: Kise

Looks like Corey isn't bringing Rex his lunch today....or any day for that matter.




Corey (CallMeLiam), Vanilla Townie, Lynched Day 1

Night Actions are due by Thursday January 21st, 2009 @ 5 pm EST

[Starbuck]

Well, Sinead O'Rebellion shocked too many people with her deviant behavior...

Debra (semioldguy), Town Weak Doctor, Murdered Night 1

Day 2 Begins. With 10 players alive, it takes 6 votes to make a lynch.

Deadline is February 21st, 6 am EST

[wolframnhart]

Alright Andromina I want an explanation on your hammer. You didn't vote at all before hand or even contribute to scum hunting, yet the first real thing you do is hammer someone? Explain.

[Nikanor]

Vote: xRECKONERx.

Obviously. He should have been lynched yesterday instead of the VI, but you know, people don't like to listen to Nikanor.

[Starbuck]

A Shot rings out of no where and you find...



Warren (Andromina), Mafia Goon, dead on the floor.

Votes have been reset. With 9 players alive, it takes 5 votes to make a lynch.

Deadline is still February 21st, 6 am EST

[Nikanor]

Hahahahahahahahaha.
Question: Is the guy in the picture Warren?

[Nikanor]

Never mind! I found the picture myself.

[wolframnhart]

Well I guess that explains her hammer LoL

What is so obvious about Reck Nik?

[xRECKONERx]

Hell yes, vigilante. Day-vig, at least. PS: if you're a one-shot dayvig, claim now. Otherwise, I guess stay hidden.

Wolf: who should we lynch? And I know it was neither you nor Nikanor who killed Andromina. Who is your strongest town read?

[Excedrin]

semioldguy, why did you say that you didn't think CML was scummy for voting for joking masons, then put him at L-1? It sucks that day 1 ended when it did, kyle99 didn't answer my question.

Here's the CML wagon:
CallMeLiam (7) - Papa Zito, RayFrost, kyle99, DragonsofSummer, wolframnhart, semioldguy, Andromina

It seems like, aside from Andromina, there's a few people here who never really explained their reasons for voting CML. I know that DoS doesn't like to explain why he does things, so he gets a pass. It's weird that RayFrost doesn't mind the link Papa Zito created (or he agrees with PZ that CML was scummy for his mason vote?). I'm not sure if wolframnhart said anything about why he thought CML was scum or if his vote was based on CML post restriction.

Finally, there's kyle99, I think he's probably scum. I was right about Andromina so lets lynch kyle99.

[Excedrin]

Vote: kyle99

[xRECKONERx]

I'm ALWAYS up for a kyle99 lynch. Like, always. But I want to hear wolf's answer to my questions first.

[wolframnhart]

@Excedrin

I explained my vote on CML:

I doubt that is a post restriction, if it is it's a horrible one that would make anyone look scummy. I think CML is trying to seem like he is scum hunting without hunting. Really not liking his play at all with his horrible deflecting.

vote CML

His posts after that never gave me a town impression, and after andromina's quick hammer on him I thought he would flip scum with Andromina bussing him, turns out i was wrong, but not about Andromina.

@Reck
I will admit it is a bit hard to get much of a town vibe. Day one was very short, with posts that didn't hold a lot of info to get reads on, however I like Excedrin for town right now. He hasn't posted much, but he was right about Andromina for one, and he also brings up some decent points on the CML wagon (but why does DoS just get a pass?). As this day goes on though I hope to get better reads here.

[RayFrost]

total ^5 dayvig

[wolframnhart]

Oh also @ Excedrin
semi-old guy is dead, so i don't think he will be answering your question.

[Excedrin]

DoS might be scum, but he typically plays without revealing much of his thoughts, that fits his current play. So, if someone else wants to explain why he's scum that's fine with me, but he's not my preference for today's lynch.

To say it another way, I'm OK with having a neutral read on DoS.

Thanks for pointing out that semioldguy's dead.

[xRECKONERx]

Wolf, who should we lynch?

[wolframnhart]

@excedrin

Ok i thought you were just completely passing him off, i understand better now.

@Reck
Really not sure at this point, Day just started, and my suspect for today was vigged.
Hopefully once others start posting I can figure it out.

Who do you believe we should lynch?

[kyle99]

Finally, there's kyle99, I think he's probably scum. I was right about Andromina so lets lynch kyle99.

Hey, sorry, I was busy, what was your question again?

[xRECKONERx]

I believe any of the following are lynch candidates for today:

Nik, Ray, DoS, Kise, kyle.

It will take me awhile to narrow it down to who exactly should be lynched. Zito was a suspect yesterday, but I have a hunch about him.

[Papa Zito]

loooooooool

A Shot rings out of no where and you find...

Warren (Andromina), Mafia Goon, dead on the floor.

I mean, the irony, amirite? ^5 vig.

vote: DragonsofSummer

obv lurking scum.