Did jack ever answer why he voted for Tony over the other 2 players that picked 1/1?
Why is jack dodging this question in post 18?
Soc even if the scum doubled up on 1 number that doesnt' mean they still wouldn't stick out.
porkens: Why do you think soc is arguing?
FeFiFoFum post 28 seems like fake surprise
Jack post 29 keeps refusing to answer this simple question and turns it around on anyone who does ask
Fate post 53:
Vote: FeiFiFoFum For speculating/voting about number picking right after Jack pointed out how counterproductive it is...
Does this make sense? Where did Jack point out that it was couterproductive and how is it counterproductive?
@everyone who commend that number speculation is useless. Now that we know that scum could communicate before they picked their numbers how does it not make sense that number specualation has some value?
@RedCoyote in regards to post 73: Tell me why would scum not want to communicate their number picks?
Lets not forget bouncy post 104 saying he voted for fate for something no townie would say and that was: Hmmm... Any scum want to claim and tell us?"
RedCoyote post 140: Feels like a 180 degree turn from post 73
Jack post 153 his interpertation of Wolf's post looks like a big stregth on what was actually said.
Scorates post 152: I find this post a bit idk what a good word is but soc seems to change his mind almost about what scum would do and bases this on Hoopla's push to lynch those higher in the line. It almost feels a bit OMGUS
Jack post 154: I reread the game and still see no reason to signal out TM. Geez stall much?
Cobalt why would you go for a hoopla lynch?
Jack post 162: I really want to just smack the guy at this point. Sorry just need to say it. So what if wolf had a theory on your vote should you state your own flipping reasons?
post 173: I think debotress is forgetting that scum didn't know each other before the number pick when referencing the other PYP game.
@POM: Why would you think scum would not check their QT to try and get themselves sorted out on their number picks so they could have a better chance to be higher on the list?
Wow and a contratiction all in the same postI don't think that there is that much to learn from draft numbers. I think that scum probably did spread their numbers out, but CKD brings up the good point that it's likely that not all the scum checked the QT (or whatever) before submitting numbers. We can't learn much from the numbers now. Possibly later in the game- we'll see.
I really hate people that keep saying this:pom wrote:Um, isn't there every reason scum want to pick different numbers? Like, say, to get PRs?
pom wrote:Everyone wanted to be highest on the draft. Scum did too. I agree with the numbers 1-1-1-1-1 and 1-1-1-2. Scum did know what their buddies were going to pick- or at least could have known (they only had 24 hours, and I'd bet that at least one sent in numbers before checking the QT). But scum only knew their five numbers (collectively), not the seventeen other players' numbers. I guess this doesn't look like much. But there's something else:
It's like inside information almost on scum
FeFiFoFum: Well post 227 OMGUS post all aboard!!!
I really don't get why fate is voted for dramonic in post 242
Porkens post 263 looks horribly scummy. He wants to FOS everyone for unvoting Fate when he has offered little to nothing this game in leu of the talks or reasons Fate is being voted on.
Hoopla I love you when I say this and I'm not saying your numbers analysis is shit at all but I think we should use a combo of scumhunting and number analysis to find scum. I would like you to actually read the game and point to those you think are scum and why that have nothing to do with the numbers right now.
My scum suspects are bouncy, jack, porkens and most especally pom. Pom and one other person expressed this desire to state that mafia didn't talk during the numbers talk. It's like an inside information into a scum chat that no one but scum should know.
Then she completely contradicts that comment in the same post pointing out that scum would like a top spot. Wishy, washy mmmmmm
unvote:
vote: Pom
vote: Pom
fos: bouncy, Jack and porkens
)
