Mini 904 - Narnia: LWW Mafia (Game Over)

[evilsnail]

What kind of role

would

counter a Reviving ability? And it makes sense for Aslan to have a powerful role of some sort. He's basically Narnia's God.

[HackerHuck]

If we hadn't lost our jailkeeper, I'd vote to lynch you just so we could test out your ability. I'm just not ready to risk LYLO from trying to outguess the mod.

So had we roleclaimed yesterday, we could have lynched you as a test. If you survived, the jailkeeper and doc could have targeted you - guaranteeing your survival and basically confirming everyone except for me, manho, and the vanilla townies.

I pretty much believe Manho, Riceball, and Papa Zito, so that just leaves you and the two vanillas - assuming three scum. I don't see how there could be only two scum with all of the town power roles that have been confirmed and claimed.

[Kdub]

Vote Count

Riceballtail (0)

-

pwnman (0)

-

HackerHuck (0)

-

Papa Zito (0)

-

Narninian (0)

-

manho (0)

-

evilsnail (0)

-

No Lynch (0)

-

Not Voting (7)

- Riceballtail, pwnman, HackerHuck, Papa Zito, Narninian, manho, evilsnail

7 votes available, 4 votes needed to lynch.

Deadline is March 18, ~ 5 pm MST.

[Papa Zito]

Papa Zito - why did you choose to protect Narninian last night?

Knowing my role, I figured all the Pevensies are PRs, so I decided to pick one of them. I thought kiku would live since she was the target of so much hostility, and I thought Aslan would have some kind of revive feature since he does in the book. I just flipped a coin between manho and Narninian.

And now that Narninian has claimed VT I feel like I protected scum last night.

[HackerHuck]

Why not riceball? I would think it important to keep alive the one person who could confirm you.

[manho]

RBT is our rolecop, as you'll recall.

i was fishing for a slip there.

i believe PZ and RBT, so there are 3 scums among the other 4.

i think HH is the most likely scum, followed by Narninian, snail and pwnman in decreasing order of scumminess.

[Narninian]

I am a straight up vanilla townie - I know the other Pensevies are in game and I know they have powers as part of my role text.

That being said, With this knowledge I would say to lynching any of the non-pensevies should yield good results. I'm leaning torwards Hackerhuck or pwnman though

[Narninian]

*I'm not is what the first sentence should read.

[Narninian]

What role have we seen that could possibly counter the reviver?

Considering he only gets revived if lynched it seems a pretty limited role. with A scum roleblocker, lovers, 2 obscure roles as townies, it doesn't seem far fetched to have this power for Aslan who comes back to life after being killed in the closest thing to a lynching in the book (not in daylight but in front of a bunch of sentients). Then again the field is quite narrow as I know the pensevies are town.

Which means 3 out of the 4 (Hackerhuck, Evilsnail, Riceballtail, Pwnman) are scum.

Hackhuck has a weird role, but pwnman is yet another vanilla townie so I'd say we lynch pwnman.

[Kdub]

pwnman and Riceballtail have been prodded.

[Papa Zito]

Why not riceball? I would think it important to keep alive the one person who could confirm you.

Confirming me isn't the point. I was trying to guess what the scum were going to do.

but pwnman is yet another vanilla townie so I'd say we lynch pwnman.

This is hilarious coming from a claimed VT.

I really need to reread this game. I'm already outed so there's no point lurking anymore.

[Riceballtail]

I'm already outed so there's no point lurking anymore.

Honestly, surprised the scum would have let you live being that Lucy has a fairly strong flavor standing for doc.

[Papa Zito]

I'm already outed so there's no point lurking anymore.

Honestly, surprised the scum would have let you live being that Lucy has a fairly strong flavor standing for doc.

I tried to WIFOM them a bit with my soft VT claim yesterday.

Who knows.

The lack of voting tells me I'm right that we're in lylo.

Narninian, you want pwnman or the Huckster dead. K. Is there anything in thread that tells you these two are scum?

[Narninian]

process of elimination. I know the Pensevies are town, which leaves 4 people, of which there is likely 3 scum. Hackerhuck's role seems odd, and yet another vanilla townie Pwnman seems unlikely considering I have no powers (just a little knowledge) and we had 2 vanilla townies already.

[HackerHuck]

process of elimination. I know the Pensevies are town, which leaves 4 people, of which there is likely 3 scum. Hackerhuck's role seems odd, and yet another vanilla townie Pwnman seems unlikely considering I have no powers (just a little knowledge) and we had 2 vanilla townies already.

So your role indicates that all of the Pevensies are town? That's a little different from what you first said.

I am a straight up vanilla townie - I know the other Pensevies are in game and I know they have powers as part of my role text.

Knowing they are in the game and knowing they are town are two different things.

[Papa Zito]

^^^
Win

Let's lynch Narninian Y/y?

[manho]

i still think we should lynch HH first.

[HackerHuck]

That's a terrible idea. I'd like to know why you think it isn't.

[Riceballtail]

I'm leaning towards HH or Narnian for today's lynch. Pwnman's lurking isn't reflecting well in my mind either. Since I highly doubt Aslan would be a fake-claim, I'm expecting these to be our scum. That said, I'll probably be flinging my investigation on one of these three tonight.

Also, me dying last night would have made PZ confirmed town, so it's not completely in his worst interest.

[Papa Zito]

I'll be confirmed town tonight, one way or another.

Manho, why lynch HH first?

[Papa Zito]

I just re-read the game. Narninian is scum.

vote: Narninian

[HackerHuck]

I would like to see one reason to lynch me that isn't related to my name.


I could be on board with a Narninian lynch, but I'd like to see his response to my post 764 above.

[Narninian]

Susan Claim

Well, That is quite the claim. I definitely expected to see her in the game, and

her allegiance is solid

.

I . I don't think the role implies any particular power, and could be strong or weak, for all we know. Susan was obviously a Pevensie, but far and away the least pivotal to the plot. Frankly, I'd have believed a VT Susan claim every bit as much.

I'd be quite suspicious of a vanilla Susan myself.

I'm not comfortable voting for an un-counterclaimed pensevie child

Consistent from the start that pensevies are town, and they have power roles. I don't see the issue with your quotes.

[evilsnail]

Narninian, does your role flavour say the other Pevensies are pro-town or that they are PRs?

[manho]

i didn't trust my scum-hunting skill in this game since kiku and pz claimed Pevensies, so there is nothing other than the role name that i want to lynch HH.

pz is confirmed Pevensies. RBT has a really convincing claim. so i'll believe this 2 as town.

so that left snail (Aslan), HH (Father Christmas), pwnman (Mr. Tumnus) and Narinian (Edmund). Edmund will be the traitor if he is scum, so we can leave him alive for now. although i really think Aslan is a fake claim, but i don't see enough people having this idea to get him lynched. finally, Father Christmas is supposed to be the one who gave presents to the Pevensies, but he didn't have a role related to it. Therefore, HH should be today's lynch.