With 8 players alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch.
Let me know, if I made any mistakes.
SaintKerrigan (2): Pie_is_good, Cyberbob
not voting (2): Thor665, Socrates
The deadline is:
Countdown
His actions make sense if he was scum (more sense than if he was town), therefore he is more likely to be scum than town. One follows from the other.MichelSableheart wrote:@Cyberbob: I'm a bit surprised to hear that your vote for SK is genuine, actually. If I look at the post where you vote him, I see you arguing how SK's behaviour would make sense if he were scum (SK scum -> actions), but as far as I can see, you fail to argue why SK is actually more likely scum then town (actions -> SK scum).
I would like to point out that Cyberbob's scum suspect and likely partner are both of the remaining claimed PRs. 3 scum vs. 8 town and 1 gunsmith doesn't seem likely to my mind.Cyberbob wrote:No kidding, you'd be in the firing line if SK died and flipped scum.
I can provide cases;Steam-Powered Shovel wrote:I'm not sure if I'll have enough time to read the thread before deadline hits (fairly sure I won't, actually), so cases would be appreciated.
It's the only thing that specifically points to SK-Thor that I've noted so far. (I'll probably take a closer look at the possibility when I finish my read assuming my suspicions don't change dramatically.)SaintKerrigan wrote:Hey SPS. First of all, SK-Thor pairing? Is your only support for this reasoning the fact that Thor failed to mention my no-result of Pie in his summary to you, or is there additional reasoning?
SaintKerrigan wrote:Incidentally, could you also elaborate on at least your top three suspicions?
I didn't even know you had suspicions of my slot. Is it TCC's or Socrates' play you're suspicious of? I'll add that to the list of things to look into.SaintKerrigan wrote:SPS because he still has yet to prove that my previous suspicions of his slot were wrong
Both. TCC because her meta didn't match her town meta plus lack of genuine scumhunting, and Socrates for basically lurking out of the game after defending himself against an attack from Fate early Day 2 (and I have seen this kind of behavior before from scum Socrates).Steam-Powered Shovel wrote:I didn't even know you had suspicions of my slot. Is it TCC's or Socrates' play you're suspicious of? I'll add that to the list of things to look into.
And seeing how your first post in, with extra days to get caught up, is basically listing SK as scummiest I don't see why I did anything terrible by hammering when I did since you're even still commenting on how you haven't finished catching up. Unless you expected to vote SK and get a lynch there (Michel and Copper were openly against an SK lynch, which means you would have had to convince both charter and myself within the span of a few hours) all I did was hammer Pie a few hours before you would have or I hammered Pie a few hours before you would have come in, voted SK and I would have hammered Pie.Steam-Powered Shovel wrote:Well, thanks, Thor. I ISO Pie, go to the university planning to ISO kthxbye and NS to get a full picturewhen I got back and then come home to find the thread closed. Also, I'm noting that you didn't mention SK's no-result on Pie nor do any of the linked posts mention it. Which is very much consistent with a Thor-SK pairing.
It has to do with my speculation as to what Michel's role is. Since I don't wish to give the scum any ideas they might not otherwise had thought of, I'll refrain from elaborating further on this subject for now.Thor665 wrote:@SK - you say there was 'no surprise' that Copper was the NK target. Yesterday you had predicted Michel as the obv. NK target. Why doesn't the Copper NK surprise you now, and why do you think scum didn't block or NK Michel?