![Razz :P](./images/smilies/icon_razz.gif)
Not the point, though. Survival is presumably not within your win condition, if you're a townsperson.
I think I remember saying it lacks substance. Twice.Kdub wrote:Ythan:
You just said my case is weak with no reason why it is weak, how do you want me to shore it up? I think my initial reason to suspect millar was a pretty clear point, what is there to clear up about it?
Oh look I found today's lynch.Furcolow wrote:Some OMGUSAREtown. Are you DENYING that? If so, I completely disagree. I know a guy I play with on another website that ALWAYS does that when he is town, and I'm the same way.
AtE ugh. Why did you make this useless post right after your claim post?Furcolow wrote:if you want to lynch our detective on day 1 go for it. lord knows i've done that before.
Please tell me you're dead. I haven't caught up to the last post yet and I'm hoping you've been lynched already.Furcolow wrote:knowledgeable millar, surprising.
I have another ability, but I'd like to keep that a secret, as it doesn't really affect anyone. (no, it isn't a treestump)
I don't like or get the point of this. Plus it's anti-town.millar13 wrote:yes i do know that lol....i have been here longer than you.
But Neto? Don't tell me you would rather be in the game on D4, than in D1.
Everyone is selfish in this game (but i have sacrificed myself) but i am erratic.
False argument .. no-one asked you to make a case on everyone – just the player you said you were “going after”. Given your play is so atrociously bad why should Town keep you alive? You are adding no scum-hunting, you aren’t even bothering to pay attention to who is actually playing the game and are making crap arguments. At this point I really don’t care if I don’t see your case on Shotty because quite frankly your play so far tells me it will be worthless.millar wrote:I'm not going to make MAJOR CASES on everyone on D1...im not an idiot (there is a survivor aspect of this game; that everyone denies and very few actually sacrafice)
I’m going to ask you what I’ve asked Furc – why do you assume that Furc’s ability is Town based?kdub wrote:Furcolow's play has been almost as crazy as millar's, but I'm leaning toward believing his claim. It's at least provable and is a useful town role. And if we're not going to believe a D1 investigative role claim, what are we going to believe anyway?
You think that Shotty’s reasons presented when voting were worse than Furc’s or millar’s?Neto wrote:In regards to my Shotty case, my point is that Shotty didn't say much at all to support it. I think that his vote is more scummy for that reason, although Furcolow and Millar are close second and third.
Shotty wrote:Guilty people are paranoid, innocents have nothing to fear.
Unvote vote robo
Furc wrote:this game is getting on my nerves
i attribute it to robocopter, who always manages to get on my nerves
i am wanting a more fun game
##vote robocopter87
All three of the votes are pretty bad but Shotty at least advanced something that somewhat resembles an actual game reason. Furc’s reasoning is personal dislike and millar at voting time said nothing at all.millar wrote:Just caught up Vote: Robo
semes quite scummy from what i have gathered
Pointless speculation about what Ythan would or wouldn’t have done is not scum-hunting. Your conclusion is invalid.Furc wrote:ythan, if you had been around when that zerg rush thing happened, i bet you would have hammered. muffin, millar, and robocopter were the ones who were on at that time.
Please provide links of completed games where you were not lynched as scum. If you can’t this is an invalid argument.Furc wrote:they don't have to waste them on me either, because i don't get lynched as scum, and i always get lynched as town
I thought I made it quite clear that I didn't think he was scum with my chainsaw defense.MoI wrote:@Robo – Please share your thoughts on millar.
You see his play and don't think in anyway it resembles scummy play?Robocopter87 wrote:I thought I made it quite clear that I didn't think he was scum with my chainsaw defense.MoI wrote:@Robo – Please share your thoughts on millar.
does it have to be a mutual chainsaw defense to guess alignments based upon one flipping, or is that still not that good? I know it wouldn't be exact, but say robocopter is scum, and is defending millar like this. Millar is likely mafia then, right?MagnaofIllusion wrote:You see his play and don't think in anyway it resembles scummy play?Robocopter87 wrote:I thought I made it quite clear that I didn't think he was scum with my chainsaw defense.MoI wrote:@Robo – Please share your thoughts on millar.