Scummies 2010 Nominations

[Iecerint]

Nominate: ReaperCharlie for best flavor text in Mini 1000 - The Brave and The Beautiful

Fourthed,

Reaper did an OUTSTANDING job with flavor and the sort. It was also a pretty darn good setup.

It looks like we don't record them after Thirds, but

Fifth'd

.

[CSL]

Nominate Beefster

for most improved player. i played in his first game, in which he was scum, I nailed him Day One and his play was really bad. Later on I played in a game where I was lycnhed early and he replaced in and he is definetly a better player than he was. He really improved.

Can i see the second game please, i was his partner in first and still feel guilty for the bus.

Go look at Newbie 980.

Summary: Nexus was confirmed town. Beefster did NOT vote for singer, who was the only other player left.

I do not endorse this nomination.

[DemonHybrid]

I'm going to

Nominate the Mafia of Mafia 117 for Best Performance Scum Group

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... =1&t=14720

Absolutely floored the town, killed off two of the game's three power roles on Day 1, with RedCoyote sealing the win on Day 2 by dissuading a lynch on his predecessor. Claimed gunsmith after some shenanigans and got the final LYLO mislynch.

I won't second that, as one of the 3 scum in that game, we had an easy ride. BUT: We would have lost hardcore if Red didn't replace in...

...so I will

Nominate RedCoyote for Best Replacement in Mafia 117

. http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... =1&t=14720

[Fate]

...so I will

Nominate RedCoyote for Best Replacement in Mafia 117

. http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... =1&t=14720

Second'

[sykedoc]

Do we still have a losing cause award?
http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=14228

LlamaFluff would certainly deserve something like this if we still have it. He died in the most infuriating way possible.

[boberz]

Nominate Beefster

for most improved player. i played in his first game, in which he was scum, I nailed him Day One and his play was really bad. Later on I played in a game where I was lycnhed early and he replaced in and he is definetly a better player than he was. He really improved.

Can i see the second game please, i was his partner in first and still feel guilty for the bus.

Go look at Newbie 980.

Summary: Nexus was confirmed town. Beefster did NOT vote for singer, who was the only other player left.

I do not endorse this nomination.

I don't have enough experience to have an opinion (but your gonna get one anyway). I skimmed it and read him in iso. It is an improvement award and blimey had he imrpoved. (I you want to see his first one then my wiki (look for m only scum game)) he claimed scum among other things. But I did not help him b attacking him after his very first post. (I was still new and quite poor myself)

[Porochaz]

Nominate Flameaxe for most improved player

- Mafia Mini Theme 1013 -Whilst he hasn't played in a while, the difference in my games and other games Ive been in with him is truly astounding. At the end of the last game I felt I wouldn't let him /in on another one of my games after a truly terrible performance. However I gave him one more chance and I don't think he was prodded once and contributed actively and was an asset to town.

Nominate Blackberry for best performance in a losing cause

I don't see it anymore but I feel BBerry was also fantastic in this game and kept fighting until the end even though it was fairly clear the town was going to lose.

I don't know if I can do this but...

nominate everyone who played in Mafia Mini Theme 1013 for best performance for players within a game

, one replacement on personal grounds. All were active, all got there night actions in on time and all gelled together perfectly, for me it was like modding the perfect game and I think its a credit to everyone who /inned into it. Scum, SK or Town.

[Antihero]

Nominate Anon for Funniest Role Claim

Mini 1019 "Claim"

[KittyMo]

2nd gandalf5166's nom of Fate for Most Outstanding New Player

Links provided:
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 54&t=14758
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 53&t=14367
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... =3&t=14592
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 58&start=0
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 1#p2196691

[Robocopter87]

I think my opinion on Fate has always been blinded by the CAPS LAWKE RAGE thing that goes on constantly. But after reading the first link and the last link I think he is a pretty decent players. He nailed scum perfectly both games.

Now, I've called the scum out before in early game but never taken it to the level to actually pull through with it. It was more of a wild guessing thing that went on. But Fate actually figured the scum out.

I'm going to have to

third that Nom.

[Ythan]

Is he a hydra? Of a good player and a rage player?

[Robocopter87]

I'm pretty sure hes not a hydra.

[Parama]

He's an alt, but not a hydra.

[Ythan]

It was a joke.

[VP Baltar]

Yeah, pretty sure alts cannot win best new player scummy.

[Fate]

Alt? What? Nah I just said that so people would respect me with my early join date.

SCUMMY PL0X

>_>b

[Vi]

Alt? What? Nah I just said that so people would respect me with my early join date.

SCUMMY PL0X

>_>b

Denied.

[Fate]

Shifty eyes aside, I'm 100% serious.

[Vi]

Shifty eyes aside, I'm 100% serious.

Ditto.

[Fate]

I'll have to be honest of all the people I'd expect resistance from I didn't expect Vi.

BTW Vi if you're the master of scummies you missed this nom awhile back:

[Fate]

Nominate Fate for Best Mafia Manipulation

for Mini: #994 Elliland

[Nikanor]

Knowing Fate's "main" account, I can say both that his first account is new enough to qualify for best new player and that Fate is more of a main than his other account ever will be.

I'll

4th Fate for Best New Player

, but I don't think he's an outstanding scum player (at least not so much as for me to second his Best Manipulation).

[VP Baltar]

Well, unless his other account is public knowledge the nomination is null. Unless you're insisting that the site should take your word for it. The fact remains that known alt is known, and that leaves a question mark as to whether or not Fate qualifies. It's up to Fate whether the scummy nom is worth it or not.

[Vi]

I'll have to be honest of all the people I'd expect resistance from I didn't expect Vi.

BTW Vi if you're the master of scummies you missed this nom awhile back:

I respect alts. I don't respect fraud.

I'm not on the Scummies committee.

his first account is new enough to qualify for best new player

One of us is mistaken.

[Fate]

I have to make it public? I can just PM the ringleader or something?

*shrug* I'd say its worth it either way. Since what Nika said is true and I can hardly be considered an "alt" since I've been in 20+ more games than my first account