Open 258 --- Night Watch --- Game Over

[drmyshottyizsik]

I disagree. We'd be putting scum in a very advantageous position for their night kills, all to see whether Joystick is lying or not.
I think we should give andrew a chance to post. If he maintains that Joystick is scum, then we should lynch him without endangering any more PRs.

no let hop say his results before dieing, this way we will be 100% sure on the him or andrew thing

[curiouskarmadog]

Bazz, the reason I asked those two about hop is because both are accusing me of bussing (I find this type of heat interesting, considering there has been a flip yet)..I asked them what their position on me would be when/if hop flipped town because i wanted to see if they would still say I was scummy...

if hop DOES flip town, pretty sure at this point shotty is scum....

[jasonT1981]

I disagree. We'd be putting scum in a very advantageous position for their night kills, all to see whether Joystick is lying or not.
I think we should give andrew a chance to post. If he maintains that Joystick is scum, then we should lynch him without endangering any more PRs.

no let hop say his results before dieing, this way we will be 100% sure on the him or andrew thing

you really want to out another possible power role? with so many out already? Yea, I stand by my assertation you are scum.

[drmyshottyizsik]

Bazz, the reason I asked those two about hop is because both are accusing me of bussing (I find this type of heat interesting, considering there has been a flip yet)..I asked them what their position on me would be when/if hop flipped town because i wanted to see if they would still say I was scummy...

if hop DOES flip town, pretty sure at this point shotty is scum....

No at this point Andrew is scum,
And STOP SETTING UP THE WHOLE IF HE FLIPS THIS OUR THAT, IT SIMPLY TELLS SCUM WHO TO KILL, AND MAKES YOU LOOK SCUMMY!!!!!!

[PogoStick]

I am not outing the other name, would not be fair to give andrew even more of an advantage knowing who all the town power roles are

[drmyshottyizsik]

I am not outing the other name, would not be fair to give andrew even more of an advantage knowing who all the town power roles are

Hop right now you are scum, and you always will be unless you answer my question

[PogoStick]

I am not outing the other name, would not be fair to give andrew even more of an advantage knowing who all the town power roles are

Hop right now you are scum, and you always will be unless you answer my question

what question? the one who visited, I won't answer, if you asked another I missed it

[jasonT1981]

The way i see it, we have two choices/possible outcomes

If we lynch JS and he flips town we know Andrew is lying
if we lynch Andrew and he flips rolecop then we know JS is lying.

Either way, we are assured to out scum... right now given Andrew is completly uncountered I think option one is the better. But I am still fond of a Shotty lynch too

Shotty, your reaction right now are making you look worse, right now Andrew is town until proven otherwise and JS is scum. At this point, no.. Andrew is not scum, as much as it pains me to say that as I spent the first part of the game going after him.

[jasonT1981]

flips town watcher I meant to say about JS

[drmyshottyizsik]

I am not outing the other name, would not be fair to give andrew even more of an advantage knowing who all the town power roles are

Hop right now you are scum, and you always will be unless you answer my question

what question? the one who visited, I won't answer, if you asked another I missed it

Hop you are so scummy

vote hop

[ooBAZZoo]

@Jason - I agree.

@Curiouskarmadog - Oh I see now; didn't read the bussing side of things.

@Everyone - I think the thread's getting clogged up with the same players posting. I'd like to give andrew one more chance to take what he says back, and I'd also like to hear what the more inactive players make of Joystick (2003 is the player who most comes to mind as being yet to comment, but there may be others). Not that I'm trying to stifle discussion, but I think we should lay off slightly until these things can happen, because we're going round in circles, and making the situation more confusing than it needs to be.

[jasonT1981]

Hop you are so scummy

vote hop

Why the sudden flip from above, to below in less than a page.. either Andrew is scum, or JS is scum.

No at this point Andrew is scum,

And STOP SETTING UP THE WHOLE IF HE FLIPS THIS OUR THAT, IT SIMPLY TELLS SCUM WHO TO KILL, AND MAKES YOU LOOK SCUMMY!!!!!!

Which one is it to you? Or do you think they could both be scum?

[jasonT1981]

oops quotes wrong way around I think.. but yes, why the sudden flip, Shotty?

[Antihero]

also, anti, i just realized that you just replaced into another game that I was having issues posting in..

FoS Anti

...you should know that I have been busy without having to fact check much.

The number of posts isn't whats bothering me. It's that I don't see much content to them.

[drmyshottyizsik]

Hop you are so scummy

vote hop

Why the sudden flip from above, to below in less than a page.. either Andrew is scum, or JS is scum.

No at this point Andrew is scum,

And STOP SETTING UP THE WHOLE IF HE FLIPS THIS OUR THAT, IT SIMPLY TELLS SCUM WHO TO KILL, AND MAKES YOU LOOK SCUMMY!!!!!!

Which one is it to you? Or do you think they could both be scum?

Yes they both could be scum, but I was saying that inrefrence to another post that was "if hop flips town shotty is our scum"

[PogoStick]

cmon shottty

[drmyshottyizsik]

cmon shottty

do as i requested and i will unvote

[jasonT1981]

So you will unvote if he outs ANOTHER possible role...

jesus..

[curiouskarmadog]

also, anti, i just realized that you just replaced into another game that I was having issues posting in..

FoS Anti

...you should know that I have been busy without having to fact check much.

The number of posts isn't whats bothering me. It's that I don't see much content to them.

ok did you see more content in the other game around the same time?

[drmyshottyizsik]

So you will unvote if he outs ANOTHER possible role...

jesus..

I will unvote so he doesn't get hammered before who he out agree's/disagree's

[jasonT1981]

giving the scum more info... either outting a power role, or narrowing down the field for scum to find other power roles.

[PogoStick]

So you will unvote if he outs ANOTHER possible role...

jesus..

exactly this

but I am not going to do it unless EVERYONE is going to unvote me, no point in doing it just to please mafia

[andrew94]

i confirm that i am the role cop and that hop is not a power role.
he is either a lying townie or a scum.

he has repeatedly said he is a watcher. he is not a power role. he also said town shouldnt fakeclaim/gambit. therefore he is scum.

@ for those that dont know: role cop only tells whether he is powerole or not

[andrew94]

my case on jason: you spent half the day going after me and saying that im using my vi ness to escape notice. you also say i fakeclaim often in an attempt to discredit my claim. then suddenly u believe my claim.


this applies to other ppl who refers to my vi ness and fakeclaining. every game is different.

[PogoStick]

my case on jason: you spent half the day going after me and saying that im using my vi ness to escape notice. you also say i fakeclaim often in an attempt to discredit my claim. then suddenly u believe my claim.


this applies to other ppl who refers to my vi ness and fakeclaining. every game is different.

yet every game is the same