Mini 1080 -- txtMafia -- Game OVER

[Tasky]

ftf: how about reading what I say before asking redundant questions?

[Herodotus]

I no longer think Kast was lying; the format made it look like ISO 2/3 said something more specific than K intended.

All 3 AV votes still look bad. (ctd)

[Herodotus]

Still have a bit of a town read on Tasky.
Chamber needs to explain cop issue.
TF left this without followup - why?

[Tasky]

Herod:
1. do you think AV is town? if yes why?
2. who exactly is your top scum-read atm?

[Herodotus]

I do think AV is town. On day 1 he was scumhunting (though he's off track now) and the attacks on him were overdone.

[Herodotus]

I don't have a top scumread. I want to hear from chamber about AV, and I want to see if Ray or AH feels like scumhunting.

[Vi]

Catching up...

Kast 1455/6 doesn't seem to mesh. Why accuse someone you think is Town of being not-genuine? (1328)

[Vi]

AH 1474/6 beating the anti-Kast drum immediately after Vi vs. Kast without mentioning the prev. flareup doesn't seem genuine either.

[Vi]

Kast 1487 still isn't quite correct but not worth arguing. Don't think subseq. argument will help anyone.

Tasqui: Does AV-potential PR change your read on him?

[Vi]

Kast 1520 is actually a good point. Also, 1532 is second time H says he was really thinking what became common knowledge all along.

[The Fonz]

Herod: What? I didn't leave it without follow up. I still think one of the two is very likely scum, and i'm leaning Kast.

[Herodotus]

@Vi I said in 1510 that I think AV's specific role is easy to figure out. Ask me about it once there isn't anything to lose if he's outed.

[Herodotus]

@TF: I expected you would do something like asking them questions to try to figure out which one was scum.

[Herodotus]

There's also the fact that you're voting RF. He is scummy, true, but do you find him scummier than either Kast or chamber?

[Herodotus]

@Tasky: There are other big clues that AV is town, but I'm holding on to some for now.

[Vi]

H1563 - chamber is scummy?

[Kast]

Vi-Lulz! Is that a joke? Clarify if you seriously believe

Towns ALL PLAY PERFECTLY

and never let emotion/bias/preconception affect them.

[Kast]

Hero- Clarify, this implies you really meant AV's role is obvious to Hero (not everyone).
-Why does that make other input unlikely?
--Clarify, despite thinking

[Kast]

AV non-cop-PR, you wanted AV to claim cop/non, but thought others wouldn't?
-Your current stance minorly contradicts this. TBC, are you claiming it was a trap?

[Vi]

Improper use of 'lulz' aside, there's an obvious difference between being emotionally compromised and not being genuine.

[Vi]

If you think someone is Town but not thinking straight, you don't word things toward them like an accusation unless you plan to use it as a weapon later.

[AurorusVox]

Struggling to get any good reads in this game. /sigh

Will re-read when I have more time later.

[Herodotus]

Kast, it was sufficiently obvious to me that I expected everyone was thinking it but no one wanted to say.

[Herodotus]

As for the rest, I've made it clear I want chamber to explain first. In case anyone intends to accuse me of copying his answer,
doetfrsmnsenprmdtapm.kftseetrsn

[Herodotus]

H1563 - chamber is scummy?

IMO the only thing scummy about chamber is his approach to AV