Mini 1130 - A Fishbowl Invasion by Ninja Monkeys! - Over

[[winger]]

You said you weren't giving context with the question but you just admitted your question implied a context.

The context I gave wasn't that the "Lol" was scummy. It was that it seemed out-of-place. Your response to my question is what made it scummy. Not once did I ever say I wasn't trying to read something further, which is all the original context was.

I don't like AGar's vote on TwistedSpoon, though. He essentially voted spoon for automatically believing my claim. Is that really so weird?

[AGar]

I don't like AGar's vote on TwistedSpoon, though. He essentially voted spoon for automatically believing my claim. Is that really so weird?

I voted him for being all like "Welp, I was totes right on [winger], he's so town, he's our doc and now our doc is gonna die, thx gaiz."

But thanks for playing! Try again next time.

[[winger]]

Thanks for the non-sarcastic, non-douchebag explanation.

[/sarcasm]

[AGar]

Thanks for the non-sarcastic, non-douchebag explanation.

[/sarcasm]

I was 100% serious, no sarcasm until the last line.

[sordros]

Hey fellas. I'm afraid I won't be able to commit to this game due to other matters hitting most of my bandwidth. I have requested replacement.

My apologies for the disruption.

[Twistedspoon]

*shrug*

Don't get me wrong, It's not that i didn't consider winger's case, Heck, I even started his wagon.

It's just that you guys all pressured him and now he claimed Doc.
Advantage mafia

But seriously, someone on the [winger] wagon had to be scum, and I'm betting CP

@AGar: It's true that the doc's chances of a successful protection are low. But still, it's nice to have the comfort of a possible doc around.

[AGar]

Heck, I even started his wagon.

told you guys he was probTown/newbtown

Uh contradiction much?

[Oso]

..
I don't like AGar's vote on TwistedSpoon, though. He essentially voted spoon for automatically believing my claim. Is that really so weird?

Yes. D1, only a VT is going to claim VT. Town PR will claim their role, scum will claim town PR, as a general rule. And even being just a "general rule", I've found it to be a pretty good one.

Still re-reading and it's shaping up to be a busy day.

Will have a vote and a case to go with it before bedtime, I hope. Tomorrow morning at the latest.

[Twistedspoon]

Uh contradiction much?

not really

It was the RVS stage when I voted Winger

[AGar]

Uh contradiction much?

not really

It was the RVS stage when I voted Winger

But you claim to have "started" the winger wagon, implying your intent was to see a wagon get going on Winger.

[Oso]

Uh contradiction much?

not really

It was the RVS stage when I voted Winger

Eh, caught that before I logged off.^^

That is a good example of what's been bugging me about your posts all game TS.

You claim you started his(winger's) wagon and that your opinion should carry some weight because of that when your start was nothing more than RVS. I can't articulate what bugs me about that, just that it does.

This whole newb thing. I have a bit of a soft spot for newbs (and VIs), having been both, but winger is not a newb. He might be new to MS and having some trouble with site meta but he's not a newb.

That pretty much sum's up what I think of your comments like that above. You're giving off mixed signals like crazy.

[Twistedspoon]

But you claim to have "started" the winger wagon, implying your intent was to see a wagon get going on Winger.

true

That pretty much sum's up what I think of your comments like that above. You're giving off mixed signals like crazy.

:3
I'm sorry

This whole newb thing. I have a bit of a soft spot for newbs (and VIs), having been both, but winger is not a newb.

Fair enough, but what matters in this game is alignment and he certainly seems more newb than mafia to me.

[Akira]

I'll quickly express my thoughts as I can't be online for too much right now:

I don't believe the claim myself. Putting aside all his scummy behavior, he was way too quick with the claim. A real doc would have at least waited until someone was about to hammer. He even wanted to claim at L-2, which strikes me as scummy.
But staying on the wagon won't do much. We'll most likely lose him tonight, so UNVOTE:

[DemonHybrid]

I'll quickly express my thoughts as I can't be online for too much right now:

I don't believe the claim myself. Putting aside all his scummy behavior, he was way too quick with the claim. A real doc would have at least waited until someone was about to hammer. He even wanted to claim at L-2, which strikes me as scummy.
But staying on the wagon won't do much. We'll most likely lose him tonight, so UNVOTE:

So, you don't believe the claim, but "We'll most likely lose him tonight"?

NEW TARGET ACQUIRED

UNVOTE, VOTE: AKIRA

[DemonHybrid]

This vote is not coming off. Akira is slipping all over the place, harder than a baby on an ice skating rink.

[Parama]

sordros is still town as hell

Yes. D1, only a VT is going to claim VT. Town PR will claim their role, scum will claim town PR, as a general rule. And even being just a "general rule", I've found it to be a pretty good one.

Funnily enough, town almost always lynches VT claims D1 regardless! <_<

I don't believe the claim myself. We'll most likely lose him tonight.

Oh hey, a scumslip!

unvote, vote: Akira

choo choo

[Twistedspoon]

I don't believe the claim myself. We'll most likely lose him tonight.

Oh hey, a scumslip!

unvote, vote: Akira

It's probably that I misunderstand, but can you explain why this is a scumslip?

I'm not defending him, but I just interpreted it as that he didn't believe the claim but thought the Mafia would kill him anyways in case the claim was true

[AGar]

TS buddying noted.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Akira

Why do you find these people before me Matt?

[Twistedspoon]

TS buddying noted.

It's not buddying, I just seriously don't understand why It's a scumslip and want someone to explain it to me so I can learn

That's all
It seemed reasonable enough

[AGar]

If you can't figure out the correlation between "doesn't believe claim" and "thinks is a valuable night-kill selection", then you're in no position to be playing the newbie card for someone else. Just sayin'.

[[winger]]

Yes. D1, only a VT is going to claim VT. Town PR will claim their role, scum will claim town PR, as a general rule. And even being just a "general rule", I've found it to be a pretty good one.

Touché… so what do YOU believe regarding my claim? Do you think I'm scum bluffing, or do you think I'm town telling the truth?

This whole newb thing. I have a bit of a soft spot for newbs (and VIs), having been both, but winger is not a newb. He might be new to MS and having some trouble with site meta but he's not a newb.

This is an accurate way to describe me. I'm not a newbie to the game, just to some of this site's policies and practices.

I don't believe the claim myself. Putting aside all his scummy behavior, he was way too quick with the claim. A real doc would have at least waited until someone was about to hammer. He even wanted to claim at L-2, which strikes me as scummy.
But staying on the wagon won't do much. We'll most likely lose him tonight, so

I

did

wait until someone was about to hammer - I was one vote away from a lynch. I wanted to claim early so we could stop the foolishness and move on.

However, saying you don't believe the claim, then saying that you expect me to die overnight is the scummiest contradiction of them all!

Unvote; Vote: Akira

Note that if he flips traitor, he might've blatant-slipped to save crazypianist.

[Twistedspoon]

If you can't figure out the correlation between "doesn't believe claim" and "thinks is a valuable night-kill selection", then you're in no position to be playing the newbie card for someone else. Just sayin'.

ouch

but fair enough.
I wasn't buddying tho' and will probs be voting Akira as soon as i figure out how his post was a 'scumslip.'

He could have just meant that he thought [wingers] claim was false, but thought he would be NK'd by the mafia in case they thought it could be true.
But hey, you guys probably know better than me, so go ahead.

I'll trust you guys on this one
VOTE: Akira

CP's going tomorrow if he flips town tho'

[Sundy]

I'm not defending him, but I just interpreted it as that he didn't believe the claim but thought the Mafia would kill him anyways in case the claim was true

In that case he's a lying townie, and lying's not much good anyway. I still have an outstanding question to you TS...

AGar, do you think TS is buddying to Akira and both are scum? Do scum usually buddy together?

unvote

[Twistedspoon]

I still have an outstanding question to you TS...

go for it

[AGar]

AGar, do you think TS is buddying to Akira and both are scum? Do scum usually buddy together?

I think there's a high possibility. Scum can buddy together or buddy up to a town player to make them look bad.