Mini 1122: Mafia.Exe Game Over

[GreyICE]

Whatever, bgg is vig bait, if we find out we don't have a vig we can lynch him later.

I'd prefer to lynch someone I feel more confident about flipping scum.

[bgg1996]

I thought I saw somebody acting like a cop. I'm most likely wrong, but that could mean either scum pretending, or an actual cop, who I don't want to lynch.

[GreyICE]

I thought I saw somebody acting like a cop. I'm most likely wrong, but that could mean either scum pretending, or an actual cop, who I don't want to lynch.

Vig.

Bait.

[DeathRowKitty]

bgg, 2 questions:

1) What do you consider to be "basic" town and mafia roles? (the types of roles you initially thought were in this game)
2) How do games tend to go where you normally play?

[TheButtonmen]

Alright reports are boring, lets do this.

I thought I saw somebody acting like a cop. I'm most likely wrong, but that could mean either scum pretending, or an actual cop, who I don't want to lynch.

Your only other game on this site no zero town PR's in it, at the start of this game you said this;

Does this mafia even have roles other than regular townies and mafia members?

So I'm calling bullshit on your suspecting cop meta because quite frankly nothing of what you've previously said indicates

any

prior experience with cops here, let alone enough that you have a solid meta understanding of what cop play looks like.

[TheButtonmen]

Ninja'ed by DRK I see.

[TheButtonmen]

So, Redacted. You'd like to talk? What about?

I asked you about Xine and you said you would get back to me later.

TBM: I've wanted Bgg dead for awhile. That was more towards DRK's comment.

There's probably more that I've said about Xine but I'm on my iPod, so that's all I'll post for now.

Still interested in your case agianst her.

@GreyICE:

Could you please carefully spell out what you mean by that story as ambiguity doesn't help us at all.

[GreyICE]

@TheButtonman: No.

[TheButtonmen]

@Nath:

Stop coasting, your last post you said;

right now I am still trying to find out who the scum is, and I am not yet in the phase where I try to convince people that someone is scummy. While I do have (founded) suspicions, I want to make further inquiries.

It's page thirty with the end of the day rapidly approching, so this won't hack it, who do you think is scum and why should I vote them, none of this I need more time stuff, the deadline should have already long passed.

[TheButtonmen]

@TheButtonman: No.

Unvote; Vote: GreyICE

Not joking, I will happily lynch you if you don't explain.

[bgg1996]

Initially, VT, VT, VT, VT, VT, VT, VT, VT, VT, VT, Goon, Goon, Goon.
Of course by now I get it.

And yes. Zero understanding of all metas. I went by the wiki's guides.

[bgg1996]

The second quuestion has no answer. This is the first mafia game that I have played in over a year.

[DeathRowKitty]

Ughhh, fine, how

did

games normally go where you played off-site? What sorts of roles? How long were deadlines? Were you a common early night kill target? etc.

[GreyICE]

@TheButtonman: No.

Unvote; Vote: GreyICE

Not joking, I will happily lynch you if you don't explain.

Cool story, bro.

[bgg1996]

1. All kinds of strange and complex roles.
2. Wasn't any, they weren't needed. Days lasted about a day.
3. Nope.

There were 30-40 people.

Can we please change the subject.
It's not easy sifting through threads on another website from over a year ago.



Maybe we should lynch the one who we could learn the most from lynching. The one who would be the most beneficial if we learned that all things he/she said was true.

[Neruz]

Fuck you and your vig bait GreyICE. We're lynching him,

now.

I've had it up to here with his shit and i'm sick of it.

bgg1996
This lynch
All votes
Final Destination

VOTE: bgg1996

[DeathRowKitty]

Is it bad i still don't think bgg is scum? :/

I have no idea what bgg is doing anymore. Whether he's town or scum, his play just makes no sense whatsoever.

He's not godfather. If he was, I doubt he'd have said he thought there were only vanilla roles in this game. His whole "hmmm...have cops inspected yet?" thing

could

make sense if he were just a mafia goon and he thought a player hyper-tunneling on him was cop, but I don't think that's the case either. Considering explanations he could have given, "I thought I saw somebody acting like a cop. I'm most likely wrong, but that could mean either scum pretending, or an actual cop, who I don't want to lynch." doesn't seem like an explanation he'd give if he were goon.

Things I don't get:
1. Why...WHY would you ask about a cop? aosjgasodjfasdf
2. If bgg isn't used to getting killed early, why bother playing to avoid a night kill?
3. Pretty sure there's something else I'm forgetting...

At this point, I'm pretty sure bgg will end up being lynched (and he probably deserves to be), but I still just don't think he's scum. I don't know.

People Who Desperately Need to Give Content

MyMilkedEek
Llamarble (preferably on something besides bgg)

You can add Xine to that list if you want. And Mute.

[Neruz]

bgg is throwing up a massive smoke screen, at this point i honestly don't care what his alignment is; i

cannot

play properly with him in the game. Almost every time he posts i'm sent careening off into nonsense and i start uselessly questioning everything i know.
bgg is a liability to the town regardless of his alignment and the sooner we get rid of him, the better. If his play wasn't so blatantly anti-town i would just write him off as a VI and ignore him, but he's making that pretty much impossible and every now and then he does something which proves that he

isn't

a VI and is just pretending to be one, which is not only incredibly scummy but is also incredibly anti-town.

He's admitted to deliberately acting like an idiot so as to protect his own skin, that's more than scummy enough for me even without the rest of the anti-town nonsense.

[GreyICE]

Krazy is scum jesus read responses he just sits there and scumplains
Xine is obv scum she roleclaimed cookie monster in thread for fucks sake
Buttonman/Mute/Eek/bgg/someone else who has contributed jack shit is #3.

[Neruz]

Good, we can lynch them all tomorrow, after we've gotten rid of bgg and i can concentrate on this game without having my thought processes derailed twice a page with crap like #726

[GreyICE]

Fine.

I call last scum as The Buttonman for this amazing post:

In honor of DRK's Good Posting allow me to make somethings clear;

PEOPLE I'M WILLING TO KILL TODAY: NERUZ, MUTE,

KRAZY AND XINE.

PEOPLE WHO NEED TO TALK AT AND/OR WITH ME MORE: MY MILKED EEK, LLMARBLE, HIKARI AND NATHANAL.

Oh look, he asked Nath, me, you, Mute, MME, Llamarble, and Hiraki questions - at least. He doesn't want to draw more attention to his failboat partners until he can scream at them in the QT to clean up their act. The only questions he's asked Krazy are to make him try and make a case on you since he seems vaguely competent. And he's asked Xine jack shit all game.

Yeah, if I had partners like that, I'd want to ignore it.

bgg is probably going to flip some flavor of town, but he's getting too fucking irritating.

Vote:bgg

Roleclaim: I'm a 1-shot paranoid gun owner or doctor

Town power roles and scum, make of that as you will. Not too worried about anything unless we get fucked on night actions.

[Neruz]

Never heard of a 1-shot PGO before, different, but at least you claimed at the right time.

[Xine]

That's L-1

Llam: I wanted to hammer, because I never have before, ready to pop that cherry. oh well, some other time.

[Exe]

L-1!!!

Vote Count #14

Day 1

bgg1996

(6): Pappums Rat, Llamarble, Krazy, Xine, Neruz, GreyICE,

Krazy

(2): DeathRowKitty, Nathanael,

Neruz

(1):Mute,

Xine

(1): Hiraki,

GreyICE

(1): TheButtonmen,

Mute

(0):

Nathanael

(0):

DeathRowKitty

(0):

Pappums Rat

(0):

Llamarble

(0):

TheButtonmen

(0):

My Milked Eek

(0):

Hiraki

(0):

No Lynch

(0):

Not Voting

: My Milked Eek, bgg1996,

With

13

alive it takes

7

to lynch.
Deadline for Day 1 is 12:00 PM EST, 3/9/11.

[Nathanael]

I think I would be ok with a bgg lynch, but right now I don't have the time to think about it properly. will post tomorrow (and maybe hammer).