Sherlock Holmes Mafia (The Game's Afoot!)

[GummyBear]

What are we supposed to say about Jedo? We thought RBT was scummier. Unless they're scum together, we were wrong.

Edited in vote count:

Sorasgoof (L-4): GreyICE, Packbat
Wraith (L-5): GummyBear
GreyICE (L-5): Wraith

Not voting: Everyone else

[smargaret]

VOTE: Gummy

[GummyBear]

Also, for someone catching up in the game, you certainly didn't pay much attention...

Curious choice...Wraith has more votes. Afraid to bandwagon?

Are you satisfied with the lurkers?

[GreyICE]

You are so full of yourself it really isn't even funny anymore. I almost want to be lynched just so you can see how wrong your "scumreads" are. Repetition for emphasis: YOU. ARE. WRONG. GET. OVER. YOURSELF. I did not flip out, I merely pointed out the flaws in your assertion, and you flipped shit. You said I am 100% scum if there are two night kills tonight, which is completely and utterly wrong. Of

course

I'm going to say something.

I said you should be lynched. That's slightly different. It's the same thing with trackers. If a tracker targets someone who targets the Night Kill, lynch em. Sure, maybe they flip "town roleblocker" or something, but you don't take that chance. If kills suddenly multiply, and I'm eating dirt, how is it pro-town NOT to leave some sort of clue what I did?

Your reaction was a complete mess. As for 'proving to me how wrong I am' is this a newbie game and no one told me? Dear lord. Of course I've been on quite a few town bandwagons. My scumreads are good, you should damn well know this. Ain't nobody perfect.

I really, really hate this. The "prove how wrong you are" usually comes from total newbies in a newbie game. Once you've mislynched a few dozen townies and lynched a few dozen scum, you realize that sometimes you're wrong and sometimes you're right, and that you don't prove anything by scumplaining to your mislynch except that you suck at being town.

I really don't think you suck that badly at being town.

Regardless, as I said, my vote is in the right place today.

[smargaret]

Gummy, I just checked your iso. You mention Jedo 4 times day one in the context of is/is not scum. Since he was one of the top two wagons and you were fairly active, I find that suspiciously low.

I'm not afraid to bandwagon. I just have a stronger scumread on you than I do on Wraith. Are you afraid of being voted for?

lol @ grey complaining about newbies

[GreyICE]

Wraith isn't an easy mislynch. He's scum. You can't mislynch scum.

I don't deny that you put everyone that did something YOU disagreed with on your list of scum, which was quite long before you narrowed it down to thinking you nailed all three scum by the end of DAY ONE. I can confirm you were wrong about

at least two

of those on your list.

Since you're one of them, Jedo is dead scum, are you saying Soras in-thread arguments clear him, or Quaroath?

'cause that's fucking nonsense.

Or is this the 'wraith has to be scum, because I was so right about RBT/Jedo issue that I CANNOT BE WRONG TODAY' again?

[Quaroath]

Also, for someone catching up in the game, you certainly didn't pay much attention...

Curious choice...Wraith has more votes. Afraid to bandwagon?

Are you satisfied with the lurkers?

This is a lie. Unless I'm just a total retard, wraith has one vote... yours. Waith, GreyIce, Gummybear and Soras all had one vote. How the hell is one > one?

I'll bandwagon the lie

vote gummybear

[GummyBear]

@ smargaret...Why is that low? We didn't mention much about RBT either, even though he would've been our next lynch. Up until today we were fairly confident GreyICE was scum because of all the reasons previously mentioned (we agree that your lack of reasoning to vote us due to your blatant sheeping of GreyICE is just terribad). We don't go throwing around OMGUS accusations to everyone that disagrees with us.

In response to GreyICE's most recent two posts.
1. You can't do math. That either/or scenario you presented implies only being wrong about one of them.
2. I'm saying we're not scum, and you never listed Wraith as being scum. Hence why you were wrong at least twice.

Preview Edit:
I'm saying that Wraith had the most votes of smargaret's top two suspects. The only "vote" on us for was for singersigner. Correct me if I'm wrong here, but I don't see anyone by that name in the playerlist.

[GreyICE]

Vote: Scummy the Magical Insult Bear

Nice job dropping the put downs.

Fine, I'm done flying into a rage. You've decided you want to trigger that today. I'm well past that stage. This is the deadly calm, the endless ice. This is your death.

[GummyBear]

We really don't know how to make it any more obvious...the fact that you guys are missing it is beyond us...

[GummyBear]

Hint: We're not getting lynched today. Your words.

[Packbat]

UNVOTE: sorasgoof
VOTE: GummyBear

Of GreyICE and GummyBear, my money's on the Gummy. That's L-2.

[GummyBear]

I cannot stress the amount of disappointment I have in this town. Not ONE of you commented on our case on Wraith. GreyICE, I don't want to hear it. If you think what you did was "comment on our case," then you're sadly mistaken. Your refusal to look at logic astounds us. Same for the rest of you. ISO us. Please. Look at our case. Look at what follows. Look at everything we've said about Wraith in the past two days.

Then ask yourselves this:

What reason does Gummybear have to tunnel one person on DAY TWO?

[GreyICE]

I don't view forcing a hammer on a scumbuddy on day 1 a scum tell.

But if you are claiming cop, then I'll lynch Wraith. Claim is very testable, and no scum in their right mind would bus their partner when one is dead.

Cop+Doctor+Watcher+Jailkeep+No scum roleblocker (CMAR wasn't blocked) = a lot of town power for one night kill.

But I wonder why you wouldn't guess that my 2-kill claim was very viable with THAT much town power.

Town ain't just loaded, it loaded for bear.

[smargaret]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Wraith

with the proviso that if Wraith flips town, we lynch Gummy tomorrow. I don't like Quaroath's reason to wagon; without a votecount (speaking of which,

Vote count please

) that's an easy mistake. He moves lower on the nullscum, order there now matters.

[GummyBear]

If a tracker targets someone who targets the Night Kill, lynch em.

confirm vote: Wraith

[GreyICE]

Unvote

Vote:Wraith

CMAR watches GummyBear. No games, no evasion. Submit the watch.

I will flip a coin. If flip is heads, I will submit:

Jailkeep:CMAR

to BV310

If it's tails, I will submit

"Jailkeep: ___________"

where that blank is whoever I damn well choose.

There's no gaiming the coin.

Whichever way the coin comes up, the PM shall go in and shall not be changed.

If they shoot the claimed tracker, 50% they get watched
If they shoot the watcher, 50% no night kill, and the tracker lives, and the watcher lives, and the jailkeeper lives, and we get to play this game tomorrow.
If they shoot me, we get two more investigations or they shoot into a known watcher.

Vote:Wraith

Could be scum tracker. But claim. Is ludicrous. Wraith should claim role and target before we lynch him. Not so that we don't lynch him (because we will be). But because if he claims something that wasn't targeting the NK and a town role, and he flips town, we know Gummy is scum.

If he claims to target the night kill, and he flips claimed role, could just be miserable luck.

Don't hammer until we have the fullclaim from him. He dies, this is certain, but he has information for the town before he goes.

Or he can save us time and selfvote. People targeting the NK die.

[GreyICE]

Also with this much town power. There are issues.

Tracker
Watcher
Doctor
Jailkeeper

P.S. I swear unto god if Wraith flips Vig of any flavor or Serial Killer, burn the hell out of Soras. He is rubbing me all sorts of wrong.

[smargaret]

I approve of this plan.

[Riceballtail]

If anyone isn't going to CC Grey, then he's confirmed town.

[GreyICE]

Meh, my corpse.

Will be on the floor tomorrow, which will confirm me well enough.

CMAR will stick to the plan no matter what, as will I, so scum would be ridiculous to WIFOM it. If we're down two scum though, the investigative roles are worth a LOT more than my protective one.

[GreyICE]

I mean even if they had a roleblocker, Natural Action Resolution says roleblocks go off at the same time, and that means that my ability goes off at the same time as any other Roleblock. I'm immune. They're just going to waste me.

[GummyBear]

If anyone isn't going to CC Grey, then he's confirmed town.

...

You realize there's more than one claim on the table, and more than one lack of a CC, right?

[GreyICE]

I believe she's referring to Name Claim here. Lestrad is quite the role to leave out of the Sherlock Holmes Mafia.

[Riceballtail]

If anyone isn't going to CC Grey, then he's confirmed town.

...

You realize there's more than one claim on the table, and more than one lack of a CC, right?

No, I'm using information I have to say that Grey is clear unless someone CCs.