Newbie 1072 - Game Over!

[KingTwelveSixteen]

I still think Mute is Ghostlin's scumbuddy. Ghostlin even made a little argument against lynching him tommorow since he would be the most scummy and lynching the most scummy person failed us the first two days . That part was the final little nail in the coffin that is Mute-scum.

------------

Good game to the scum though, before Ghostlin messed up at the end of day-1 I had a pretty good town read on him and everything. Mute managed to pull off being null for the whole game, which is pretty good for scum I think, but to bad for him he got POE'ed and partnered(is that a word?) out today.

If the other scum is Dazzy or Charlie then

very

good game sirs, you have most certainly earned the win you are probably going to get tommorow. I tip my non-existant hat to you.

Good game to the townie people as well, since I'm giving out GG's like hot-cakes right now.

[Dazzy]

Whoa King don't start calling the game just yet. I'm definitely not set on Mute as scum. I'm working on something, it will go up before my vote for safety.

Why does everyone have to start acting weird AFTER I make up my mind...

[KingTwelveSixteen]

Whoa King don't start calling the game just yet.

I'm definitely not set on Mute as scum

. I'm working on something, it will go up before my vote for safety.

Why does everyone have to start acting weird

AFTER I make up my mind...

Wait, what?

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Vote Count 3.5

KingTwelveSixteen - 1 (Ghostlin)
Ghostlin - 1 (KingTwelveSixteen)

Not Voting - 3 (Charlie, Dazzy, Mute)

3 to Lynch.

Click for Deadline

[Dazzy]

The second underline is me saying that I've basically made my mind up to vote for Ghost today. I'm waiting for any possible input Mute might have.

The first is me saying that I haven't cleared Charlie as being scum. Mute is most likely at this point, but Charlie is not obvtown in my books. I'd say it still warrants a bit of discussion, tomorrow if not today.

My point is this: I'm almost definitely voting Ghostlin today. If I get NK'ed, I don't want you to assume that Mute is Ghost's buddy, simply because there are a lot of things that point to Charlie as well.

[Mute]

I've said my peace really. My head can't make heads or tails of either Ghost or King. I can't believe Ghost's cop claim, it's just too well timed, and I can't accept King's innocence for the action's he's had over the course of the game. Ghost's claimed a PR though where King claimed VT.

Yeah townie's really don't have much to fear in death, in that so long as all scum is lynched they will win with the town. (This is in response to Ghost's comment.) But if a townie has something that can implicate a scum, or draw one out, then there'd be a reason for them to want to stay alive. Does this clear King? No.
Really that's all I've got to say. My mind can't make itself up.

[Dazzy]

Alright.

Hopefully this isn't a mistake.

VOTE: Ghostlin

[Mute]

It is.

Vote Ghostlin

[KingTwelveSixteen]

Sweet.

[Charlie]

Uh-oh!

[KingTwelveSixteen]

Hehehe.

Just FYI: The scum motivation that I totally screwed up in revealing day-1 twilight was that me saying something then would likely result in a cop investigation.

[KingTwelveSixteen]

Whee! First game as scum and I get the win.

Actual trueness Good Games to all who participated, instead of the fakey-type ones I made previously. Thought I was done for for a sec' there when Ghostlin claimed cop.

[Charlie]

And just when I'm getting an inkling of changing my mind about Ghostlin's claim...

[Mute]

Good game everyone.

And ghostlin... 1024 says hi.

[Charlie]

Good game.

Well, in terms of gameplay I thought I did pretty okay. Didn't draw a NK as Doc and VCA did manage to pick out Mute as scummy. Didn't read Ghostlin correctly, and highly probable that I'd end up voting for him anyway if Dazzy didn't. Congrats to the Mafia team for the prefect win.

I'll try to post some comments to each individual player for some constrictive feedback after the game has officially been declared over.

Also, maybe then you guys can comment on how I did as a first time IC. I personally feel that both SE Ghostlin and SE Mute were great in helping out in explaining the basics of the game. I hope there was no aspect of game theory/jargon that was confusing in this game.

[KingTwelveSixteen]

Oh yeah, special props to the mod for that little deadline-timer thingie, that was really nice. Completely destroys any chance of people being unsure about when the deadline is.

[Mute]

Your first time as IC? My only comment is entirely gameplay-related: pick a better RQS question that isn't blatantly scummy in it's entirety. That aside you did a good job as IC I feel.

[Mute]

'course this is from the perspective that, had you not been confirmed townie from the cop, you'd certainly have that as heavy evidence against you later on if scum bussed you.

[Dazzy]

Well...

Yeah. @#$% lol.

Sorry Ghost. Good game to all. I learned a lot this game (hopefully), and hope to play with you guys again.

Looking forward to the post-game.

[Dazzy]

The stupid thing is that I actually had a moment just before I voted when I read a post of Ghostlin's and said "Wait a minute... He can't be scum!", and then dismissed it as him tricking me. ndfvlskdfnvlskdjsl.

[Mute]

Dazzy, take it from Charlie. Look back and notice how he once referred to me as "pro-town," and later saying he had a "gut feeling" about me. 7 times outta 10, your gut knows what it's talking about.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Vote Count 3.6

KingTwelveSixteen - 1 (Ghostlin)

Ghostlin - 3 (KingTwelveSixteen, Dazzy, Mute)

Not Voting - 1 (Charlie)

3 to Lynch.

Click for Deadline

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Despite his best arguments, Ghostlin is condemned as Mafia. As he's led off to the gallows, you can't help but feel that something just isn't right...

Ghostlin,

Cop

, lynched Day 3

Dazzy,

Townie

, killed in Endgame

Charlie,

Doctor

, killed in Endgame

Mute and King

win the game for the

Mafia

team!!

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Role Reveal:

Player	Replaced	Role
Charlie *		Doc
Dazzy		Townie
Meransiel	FarmeriXi	Townie
Forseti		Townie
Ghostlin ^		Cop
tclawren	gxw	Townie
KingTwelveSixteen		Mafia Goon
Mute ^		Mafia Roleblocker
Twistedspoon		Townie

---

Night Actions:

Night 1:

Charlie protects Ghostlin.
Ghostlin investigates Charlie.
KingTwelveSixteen kills Forseti.
Mute blocks Meransiel.

Night 2:

Charlie protects Dazzy.
Ghostlin investigates KingTwelveSixteen.
KingTwelveSixteen kills tclawren.
Mute blocks Charlie.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Everyone should use this time to post thoughts and observations about the game. Ask questions and try to figure out what went wrong (and right) with your play and how you can learn from it and improve. Be polite in pointing out mistakes made by others! Conversely, if someone points something out, learn from it – don’t get offended!!

My Observations

:

I have to agree that gut reads, especially in endgame, are much more often than not correct. Ghost you did a good job, but it's hard to be a Cop in LyLo with a guilty. I don't know what you could have done differently. Not sure how much your quick hammer on Day 1 (?) played a factor, but I find that forcing things to go the way you want as a PR usually doesn't work out the way you exect it to.

Charlie, feel free to sign up as an IC again. I think you did well.

Mafia QuickTopic

Green Room